Readit News logoReadit News
ChrisKnott commented on How to Draw a Space Invader   muffinman.io/blog/invader... · Posted by u/abdusco
pachevjoseph · 5 days ago
This is one of the best mobile experiences I’ve had reading an article.
ChrisKnott · 5 days ago
Yeah, what a tiny joy when it "picked up" the canvas as it went
ChrisKnott commented on Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act   bbc.com/news/articles/cjr... · Posted by u/phlummox
Lio · 13 days ago
> Ludicrous to call William Perrin “the founder” of Ofcom or refer to it as “his” quango

From his own Carnegie UK webpage linked above:

> William was instrumental in creating Ofcom, reforming the regulatory regimes of several sectors and kicking off the UK government’s interest in open data.

William was awarded an OBE for his highly influential work at Carnegie UK with Prof Lorna Woods that underpinned the UK government’s approach to regulating online services.

How is he not a founder of Ofcom?

That’s not a conspiracy theory, that’s just a verifiable statement of fact.

Or is it the use of the word founder you object to? If you prefer, “was instrumental in setting up and is closely related to the running of Ofcom”.

ChrisKnott · 13 days ago
Both the use of “founder” and “the” are inaccurate and misleading (I notice you’ve switched to “a” without comment). He was a government adviser 20 years ago that was central to the work of creating Ofcom. How is he closely related to the running of Ofcom, today?

The conspiracy theory is your suggestion he is deriving some kind of financial benefit to Carnegie via Yoti - what is the basis for this? (I agree it would be a conflict of interest, though not hypocritical).

ChrisKnott commented on Wikipedia loses challenge against Online Safety Act   bbc.com/news/articles/cjr... · Posted by u/phlummox
Lio · 14 days ago
One of the most interesting things about this legislation is where it comes from.

Primarily it was drafted and lobbied for by William Perrin OBE and Prof Lorna Woods at Carnegie UK[1], billed as an “independent foundation”.

William Perrin is also the founder of Ofcom. So he’s been using the foundation’s money to lobby for the expansion of his unelected quango.

It has also been suggested that one of the largest beneficiaries of this law, an age verification company called Yoti, also has financial ties to Carnegie UK.

It’s difficult to verify that because Yoti is privately held and its backers are secret.

It’s not as if anyone was surprised that teenagers can get round age blocks in seconds so there’s something going on and it stinks.

1. https://carnegieuk.org/team/william-perrin-obe/

ChrisKnott · 13 days ago
Ludicrous to call William Perrin “the founder” of Ofcom or refer to it as “his” quango.

Passive voice, evidence free conspiracy nonsense that flatters HN biases? Updoots to the left!

ChrisKnott commented on Wikimedia Foundation Challenges UK Online Safety Act Regulations   wikimediafoundation.org/n... · Posted by u/Nurw
aaronmdjones · a month ago
Their homepage certainly is.
ChrisKnott · a month ago
The homepage is manually edited isn't it?
ChrisKnott commented on Wikimedia Foundation Challenges UK Online Safety Act Regulations   wikimediafoundation.org/n... · Posted by u/Nurw
philipwhiuk · a month ago
Is search results 'an algorithmic feed'.
ChrisKnott · a month ago
The phrase they actually use is "content recommender system". The definition is in the link; you could maybe see some search features falling into it but I don't see how Wikipedia as it exists now is Category 1.
ChrisKnott commented on Wikimedia Foundation Challenges UK Online Safety Act Regulations   wikimediafoundation.org/n... · Posted by u/Nurw
codedokode · a month ago
How is "algorithmic feed" related to safety? Or is it, along with seemingly arbitrary numbers like 7 or 34 millions, a way to target a specific platform for those who are afraid to spell the name explicitly?
ChrisKnott · a month ago
One of the main motivations for this law was pro-suicide and pro-anorexia content being pushed to teenage girls. In particular Molly Russell's death received a lot of press coverage and public outrage at tech companies. The coroner's report basically said Instagram killed her. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Molly_Russell

Of course if you get your news from HN then the motivation is actually something to do with limiting discussion of immigration or being dystopian just because.

But yes, if they could just name Instagram and TikTok they probably would.

ChrisKnott commented on Wikimedia Foundation Challenges UK Online Safety Act Regulations   wikimediafoundation.org/n... · Posted by u/Nurw
cubefox · a month ago
The headline seems a little misleading. From the article:

> The Wikimedia Foundation shares the UK government’s commitment to promoting online environments where everyone can safely participate. The organization is not bringing a general challenge to the OSA as a whole, nor to the existence of the Category 1 duties themselves. Rather, the legal challenge focuses solely on the new Categorisation Regulations that risk imposing Category 1 duties (the OSA’s most stringent obligations) on Wikipedia.

ChrisKnott · a month ago
Is Wikipedia actually Category 1?

Seems to require an algorithmic feed to be Category 1 - https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukdsi/2025/9780348267174

ChrisKnott commented on VPN use surges in UK as new online safety rules kick in   ft.com/content/356674b0-9... · Posted by u/mmarian
alias_neo · a month ago
I don't think there's a clear consensus on what is considered middle class in this country now, for many it can be social, and other factors, I would consider it, in this context to be a certain standard of living.

Owning a home, having significant savings, holidays abroad at least once a year, sending your children to private school, etc are probably some things I'd consider markers of being in the lower middle class.

On that basis, homes are becoming harder to own, savings are being eaten up by higher cost of living, the pound is weakening and taxes are making it untenable to send your children to private school.

Maybe my idea of what being middle class is is wrong, but it can't be far off, and that's exactly the group of people who aren't going to go much further beyond that to whatever comes at the next stage, I don't know what living standards look like for people above that; multiple properties, significant portfolios, not working for a living?

If my perspective if off, I'm willing to hear it.

ChrisKnott · a month ago
I think the general point is you are presenting something as a hardship that is a quality of life unachievable for most people (even in the UK), and unthinkable for most people in the recent past, even in the West.

You come across as out of touch and entitled. You live in the future - enjoy it!

ChrisKnott commented on VPN use surges in UK as new online safety rules kick in   ft.com/content/356674b0-9... · Posted by u/mmarian
cs02rm0 · a month ago
This may be slightly chicken and egg; it's the 95th percentile of salaries partly because no one wants to take a salary above that. Instead they use salary sacrifice, pensions, dividends, capital gains, leaving money in personal service company, etc. anything to avoid having a personal paper income above that threshold.

I suspect it's nowhere near the 95th percentile of earned wealth.

ChrisKnott · a month ago
I don't think this hypothetical behaviour would change the 95th percentile or any percentiles below it, would it?

If the income of everybody above the 80th percentile dropped to be equal to the 81st percentile, the 80th percentile income wouldn't change the ones above would just be very closely bunched.

(Last time I checked the opposite was true and they got more spread out)

ChrisKnott commented on VPN use surges in UK as new online safety rules kick in   ft.com/content/356674b0-9... · Posted by u/mmarian
lucasRW · a month ago
Do you know of other western countries that send cops to your house because you posted memes on X ?

Saying that illegal migrants should be sent back home can literally land you at the police station. A hotel worker was arrested for testifying to what he saw in his hotels, ie. migrants being hosted, given a phone, meals, and NHS visit once every two weeks.

ChrisKnott · a month ago
> "Do you know of other western countries that send cops to your house because you posted memes on X ?"

This guy was prosecuted in the US for posting a meme on Twitter [0].

I imagine this can happen in almost every country. What ones do you think it can't happen in?

[0] https://www.courthousenews.com/on-trial-for-memes-man-asks-s...

u/ChrisKnott

KarmaCake day2110January 6, 2018
About
Former programmer based in London
View Original