Readit News logoReadit News
iKevinShah · 2 years ago
Congratulations ISRO. What you have achieved with what you have got, its truly marvelous.
dcow · 2 years ago
Without context this could be interpreted as patronizing (or worse). You’re talking about their small budget, right?
checker659 · 2 years ago
I'd love to know the total cost of the whole project. This has go to be the cheapest moon landing ever, right?
vijaykodam · 2 years ago
On the day of the launch, news agency Reuters said in a report that Chandrayaan-3 has been built on a budget of just under $75 million (around ₹ 615 crore).

Deleted Comment

mikepurvis · 2 years ago
Wow, so definitely well within the range of private industry or even private individuals.

Dead Comment

sidcool · 2 years ago
This will inspire more Indians to go into STEM and stay in India. Golden age of India's space ambitions has arrived.
matthewfelgate · 2 years ago
Congrats. Landing on the moon is hard.

This makes India just the 4th country to land on the moon.

VWWHFSfQ · 2 years ago
It seems like there's a lot of renewed activity of various nations trying to land on the moon recently. Is this just a rite of passage for a space program? Or is there some other reason? I have to imagine that if there was actually some real benefit then USA would still be sending landers all the time. Curious what the interest is.
gsatic · 2 years ago
Back in 2017 ISRO had a record setting 104 satellites deployed on a single launch. Everyone said India would become the goto destination for cheap launches. Since then tens of thousands of satellites have been launched but very few via ISRO. So for whatever reason they totally missed that boat, and maybe their moon/sun/human space flight stuff is some kind of pivot.
isignal · 2 years ago
Wouldn’t say they missed the boat. ISRO did launch some of the OneWeb constellation recently https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/NewSpace_India_Limited

It’s just a slow ramp up. India’s rockets aren’t yet capable pf heavy payloads like SpaceX.

catchnear4321 · 2 years ago
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artemis_program

less a rite of passage, more a new wave of activity.

psychphysic · 2 years ago
Out of curiosity, what are flat earthers saying? That Russia faked a crash and India faked a success? Why?!
bearjaws · 2 years ago
You can't logic your way out of a position you didn't logic your way into.
readthenotes1 · 2 years ago
A friend of mine said:

You can't logic your way out of a crazy box.

(Referring how to treat with people who are somewhat mentally Disturbed)

Waterluvian · 2 years ago
Google doesn't return any meaningful results for this. Is this your quote? It's really good and I'd like to duplicate it for regular use.

Edit: Aha I found it by relaxing the query params: probably Jonathan Swift.

jackmott42 · 2 years ago
Yeah, a lot of people have this idea that you fight misinformation with calm, collected, rational argument.

Well, I guess I need to prepare a cold, calm, collected rational argument about how that isn't at all effective, heh.

Deleted Comment

robofanatic · 2 years ago
Only if you can prove that birds are real.
psychphysic · 2 years ago
Well put.
sph · 2 years ago
The counter-conspiracy is that flat earthism is larger than it actually is. It's basically a meme about making fun of them, when I reckon in reality there's not a lot of them; I would bet there's a percentage of flat earthers well below the lizardman constant of 4%.

So in effect, the Flat Earth theory is popular purely because of people making fun of it. There are no more flat earthers than people who hear voices or that believe they are actually reincarnated Jesus.

Daviey · 2 years ago
I used to work with an engineer that assured me he had looked into flat earth theory and it was "legit". This same person told me he could re-write Terraform in a day, so my view of him was skewed.

However, I was genuinely surprised to find a real flat-earther in a technical role.

narrator · 2 years ago
I kind of like flat earth because it uses all the bad argument techniques that people I can't criticize on HN without getting downvotes use. Thus, it provides a good example cases for most common bad arguments used in online debates, especially science related debates.

Somebody should put together a dictionary of informal fallacies with examples from the flat earth movement because it is not politically incorrect to criticize them while it is to criticize other movements that are more popular that regularly employ these fallacies.

One more thing: speaking of people believing they're Christ, a random guy in China in the 1850s started to believe he was the younger brother of Jesus Christ and started the biggest civil war in world history.

jmondi · 2 years ago
That’s what I thought about QAnon too. Turns out, there’s a boatload of morons out there. I have extended relatives that were QAnon fools, and are now flat earther fools.
jimmydddd · 2 years ago
There may be a sub-group that just wants to be open-minded. I'm 100% a science guy, but I refuse to put the probability of flat earth at 0%. Maybe 0.00000000000000001%, but not 0. :-)
narrator · 2 years ago
Attacking the source of the information is so common these days that most people mistake that for a good argument.
matt-attack · 2 years ago
Doesn’t help that the video they’re all cheering over is a computer rending (presumably being pieced together from real time telemetry data being received). Gives the layperson the idea that the whole thing is being faked.
moopie · 2 years ago
NASA paid both to keep the globe earth delusion alive

Or something like that

tzfld · 2 years ago
Wondering how Russians feel about the success of Chandrayaan-3 after the failure with their Luna 25.
ben_w · 2 years ago
"Glorious Russian probe came second, decadent Indian probe came second-last"

(I vaguely remember there was a headline along those lines about a 2-way athletics event between the USSR and the USA)

justplay · 2 years ago
The crash of Luna 25 disheartens me as an engineer, representing a substantial loss of effort and work. However, I'm pleased with Chandrayaan-3's success.
actuator · 2 years ago
Russia has a wonderful space program with ability to reliably go to space and are one of the biggest contributors to ISS.

Setbacks happen, but I am sure that doesn't change how they feel about Chandrayaan-3

Ingaz · 2 years ago
Sh*t happens.

What else?

AwaAwa · 2 years ago
The global south reaches the lunar south.