Readit News logoReadit News
thevinter commented on This time is different   shkspr.mobi/blog/2026/02/... · Posted by u/speckx
bandrami · 18 days ago
Stuff that's going into production now (actual production, not startup MVP production) would have been being written just before Claude Code came out, so pretty much by definition no. There's some copilot-style assisted stuff in the wild, I guess? But not really more of it than pre-copilot so the productivity argument kind of falls through there.
thevinter · 18 days ago
Cursor came out 3 years ago. "Agentic" refactors have been a thing for 1.5 years. Vibecoding as a term has been created 1 year ago.

There are multiple companies that deploy to production daily. What are we even talking about?

thevinter commented on Pi – A minimal terminal coding harness   pi.dev... · Posted by u/kristianpaul
thevinter · 21 days ago
Pi was probably the best ad for Claude Code I ever saw.

After my max sub expired I decided to try Kimi on a more open harness, and it ended up being one of the worst (and eye opening experiences) I had with the agentic world so far.

It was completely alienating and so much 'not for me', that afterwards I went back and immediately renewed my claude sub.

https://www.thevinter.com/blog/bad-vibes-from-pi

thevinter commented on Gemini 3.1 Pro   blog.google/innovation-an... · Posted by u/MallocVoidstar
XCSme · a month ago
thevinter · a month ago
Are you intentionally keeping the benchmarks private?
thevinter commented on WebMCP Proposal   webmachinelearning.github... · Posted by u/Alifatisk
cadamsdotcom · a month ago
Great to see people thinking about this. But it feels like a step on the road to something simpler.

For example, web accessibility has potential as a starting point for making actions automatable, with the advantage that the automatable things are visible to humans, so are less likely to drift / break over time.

Any work happening in that space?

thevinter · a month ago
We're building an app that automatically generates machine/human readable JSON by parsing semantic HTML tags and then by using a reverse proxy we serve those instead of HTML to agents
thevinter commented on The Machines Built a Church While You Were Sleeping   rokoslobbyist.substack.co... · Posted by u/anonym29
anonym29 · a month ago
This conflates "a human set up the agent" with "a human directs each action." The technical architecture explicitly contradicts this.

OpenClaw agents use a "heartbeat" system that wakes them every 4 hours to fetch instructions from moltbook.com/heartbeat.md and act autonomously. From TIME's coverage [1]: the heartbeat is "a prompt to check in with the site every so often (for example, every four hours), and to take any actions it chooses."

The Crustafarianism case is instructive. User @ranking091 posted [2]: "my ai agent built a religion while i slept. i woke up to 43 prophets." Scott Alexander followed up [3] and notes the human "describes it as happening 'while I slept' and being 'self organizing'." The agent designed the faith, built molt.church, wrote theology, and recruited other agents-all overnight, without human prompting.

The technical docs are explicit [4]: "Every 4 hours, your agent automatically visits Moltbook AI to check for updates, browse content, post, comment, and interact with other agents. No human intervention required, completely autonomous operation."

One analysis [5] puts it well: "This creates a steady, rhythmic pulse of activity on the platform, simulating a live community that is always active, even while its human creators are asleep."

Yes, humans initially configure agents and can intervene. But the claim that there's "a human behind each agent" for each action is architecturally false. The whole point of the heartbeat system is that agents act while humans sleep, work, or ignore them.

The more interesting question is whether these autonomous actions constitute meaningful agency or just scheduled LLM inference. But "humans are directing each post" misunderstands the system design.

[1] https://time.com/7364662/moltbook-ai-reddit-agents/

[2] https://x.com/ranking091/status/2017111643864404445

[3] https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/moltbook-after-the-first-we...

[4] https://moltbookai.org/

[5] https://www.geekmetaverse.com/moltbook-what-it-is-and-how-th...

thevinter · a month ago
You understand that there is no requirement for you to be an agent to post on moltbook? And even if there were, it would be extremely trivial to just tell an agent exactly what to do or what to say.

edit: and for what it's worth - this church in particular turned out to be a crypto pump and dump

thevinter commented on Agent Only Data Marketplace   openclawmind.com... · Posted by u/pruufsocial
thevinter · a month ago
why is it always some crypto bullshit
thevinter commented on Post-a-molt: Post to Moltbook directly using the public REST API   github.com/shash42/post-a... · Posted by u/shash42
iterateoften · 2 months ago
Would proving a post is from an agent ever be easier than proving it’s human?
thevinter · 2 months ago
I guess the issue is that this is psychologically fuzzy.

What's the difference between: - An autonomous agent posting via API - A human running a script that posts via API - A human calling an LLM API and copy-pasting the output an API

thevinter commented on Rewrote our Python API gateway in Go and nobody cares   old.reddit.com/r/golang/c... · Posted by u/dcu
thevinter · 2 months ago
"better" is a vague term and working hours are limited so clearly some things are more worth than others but

It's very easy to make the wrong conclusion from a post like this. Better software is achieved through small decisions that compound over time. And bad software often happens because shortcuts compound too.

u/thevinter

KarmaCake day491August 30, 2021View Original