Readit News logoReadit News
qualeed commented on Undisclosed financial conflicts of interest in DSM-5 (2024)   bmj.com/content/384/bmj-2... · Posted by u/renameme
dang · 4 months ago
Please don't respond to a bad comment by breaking the site guidelines yourself. That only makes things worse.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

qualeed · 4 months ago
Calling a comment "ridiculous" is against the guidelines?

Okay. Hopefully it isn't against the guidelines to say I think that's a silly guideline. Apparently saying "ridiculous" in response to a comment is very selectively enforced, must be my lucky day.

Anyways, this is probably the reminder I needed to stop commenting to HN. Some of the moderator decisions you guys are making lately are just.. way off base to me. Either you've changed or I have. Probably me.

Time to randomize the password. Cheers.

Dead Comment

qualeed commented on Undisclosed financial conflicts of interest in DSM-5 (2024)   bmj.com/content/384/bmj-2... · Posted by u/renameme
dlcarrier · 4 months ago
When the APA elected Philip Zimbardo, creator of the infamous Stanford Prison Experiment (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanford_prison_experiment#Cri...), as their president (https://www.apa.org/about/governance/president/bio-philip-zi...) they lost my trust. He came up with a hypothesis on human behavior, then did everything he could to force the data to reflect that, including coercing volunteers into torturing each other.

His whole career revelved around promoting strategies for policing and incarceration that clearly don't work, and the APA celebrated him for it. They have a huge bias toword the notion that everyone needs their help. Problems with the DSM wouldn't matter so much, if the APA hadn't shoehorned themselves, and their bible of the DSM, into countless aspects of government and healthcare.

qualeed · 4 months ago
The DSM-5 is from the "American Psychiatric Association".

Phillip Zimbardo, and the link you linked to, are the "American Psychological Association".

These are two different associations.

Theresa Miskimen is the president of the American Psychiatric Association, not Zimbardo.

qualeed commented on Neuralink 'Participant 1' says his life has changed   fortune.com/2025/08/23/ne... · Posted by u/danielmorozoff
shkkmo · 4 months ago
> No one in this thread is helping "spread hatred".

What do you think partisanship is these days?

qualeed · 4 months ago
Not synonymous with "spreading hate".

Deleted Comment

Deleted Comment

qualeed commented on Neuralink 'Participant 1' says his life has changed   fortune.com/2025/08/23/ne... · Posted by u/danielmorozoff
shkkmo · 4 months ago
> You should explain the active harm this causes, because your partisan celebrity worship is causing you to look goofy in front of strangers.

I explained the active harm in the very sentence you quoted.

>> he told me that a SWAT team showed up with AR-15s after someone gave a false tip to the local sheriff’s office that Arbaugh was in danger.

I'm not a big fan of Musk for a number of different reasons. I'm even less a fan of the cult of hatred that pops up whenever his name is mentioned.

I'd rather look like a goof (nothing wrong with being goofy or weird sometimes) than help spread hatred.

qualeed · 4 months ago
>I'd rather look like a goof (nothing wrong with being goofy or weird sometimes) than help spread hatred.

No one in this thread is helping "spread hatred".

Deleted Comment

qualeed commented on Meta just suspended the Facebook account of Neal Stephenson   twitter.com/nealstephenso... · Posted by u/SLHamlet
bachmeier · 4 months ago
Are you implying that being banned from Facebook is a bad thing?
qualeed · 4 months ago
I'm pretty sure they are implying that it might be a bad policy to not ban nazis.
qualeed commented on The Size of Adobe Reader Installers Through the Years   sigwait.org/~alex/blog/20... · Posted by u/henry_flower
wat10000 · 4 months ago
I think this is an argument for the log scale. I'd argue that the things you say it communicates are not actually correct.

Adobe's size has been growing exponentially pretty much this whole time. The rate increased slightly in the mid-2010s. SumatraPDF started out that way too, but managed to level out after about a decade.

Relative size is what matters here. That increase from ~2.5MB to ~5MB in the mid-90s was pretty significant for the time. In terms of the impact on users, it's probably at least as important if not more so than going from 300MB to 600MB 25-30 years later.

qualeed · 4 months ago
>Relative size is what matters here.

This is where our disconnect is. Relative change in size means nothing to me. I care about the absolute size of the final thing I'm installing.

Adobe big, getting bigger. Sumatra small, staying small.

u/qualeed

KarmaCake day1096June 5, 2025
About
i think this might be one of the most fickle communities on the internet.
View Original