Readit News logoReadit News
jastuk commented on Figma will IPO on July 31   figma.com/blog/ipo-pricin... · Posted by u/nevir
_fat_santa · a month ago
Sketch's biggest drawback was they only build a Mac app. The "mac app" space will get you consistent business but you will never grow your company to the scale of Figma or Adobe.

It's funny how the successes and failures of these two companies ultimately comes down to a single architectural decision that both took different paths on. Sketch's biggest drawback (even back in the 2010's when they were on top) was always that they didn't support Web, Windows or Linux and focused only on Mac's. Honestly it paved the way for Figma to just come up and eat their lunch.

The biggest mistake that Sketch made was not realizing there was a sea change sooner and shifting their focus to a web based app or even releasing Windows and Linux clients. Even now I went to their website and they only offer basic viewing tools on the web, if you want to create with Sketch you need a Mac and there's no way around that.

jastuk · a month ago
And yet, I cannot stop myself of thinking about that native architecture decision whenever my beefed up Mac Studio takes a minute to load a mediocre-sized Figma project and struggles to keep up as I try to navigate it, just so that I can leave a couple of comments somewhere.

I will say that some outsourcing phases/efforts would definitely not be possible with Sketch though. It's one thing when we as a company all have company-provided Macs, but another when remote hiring/collaborating.

jastuk commented on Figma will IPO on July 31   figma.com/blog/ipo-pricin... · Posted by u/nevir
danielvaughn · a month ago
That’s been going on for a while with Figma. Their core user base (at least historically core) generally feels neglected, because they’ve been trying to go horizontal with a slew of related products. Meanwhile they’re charging designers to use variables.

Imagine being charged to use variables. Crazy.

jastuk · a month ago
Yup, I'll confirm this 100%. I do not like Figma and have 0 trust and optimism about it; I use it because I have to and will ditch it at the first corner, probably for Penpot. When you have trivial-to-fix bug reports with hundreds of comments and votes collecting dust for 3-4 years, you lose all respect from your userbase.

My hope is that at least with Penpot I can submit a PR if I am motivated enough. With Figma, I've done all I can.

jastuk commented on Figma will IPO on July 31   figma.com/blog/ipo-pricin... · Posted by u/nevir
Fraterkes · a month ago
I recently tried Sketch for the first time, and was kind of blown away by how Figma looks identical to it. Did Figma exactly copy the Sketch ui or did they copy eachother and slowly grow closer?
jastuk · a month ago
I've used Sketch since its early days and then after (who knows how many) years, reluctantly and angrily moved from Sketch to Figma. Sketch was the pioneer and Figma took a very long time to catch up with what I've considered important features, and of course Figma had the advantage of being cross-platform but that was a non-issue for me as Sketch introduced web-based previews for clients.

The reason why I ditched Sketch (even though I loved it) was because Sketch had quality control issues over time and they started messing with my work, even losing some of it (cloud saves). The frustration grew over a longer period of time until I lost all hope and just had to admit that it was a lost cause. I peeked at Sketch's changelogs for a year and saw only bugfixes and no features. I assumed it was dead; either way the chapter was closed, the entire company shifted to Figma.

P.S. which is not to say that Figma is in a good state now, or that I don't feel history repeating itself.

jastuk commented on Kite News   kite.kagi.com/... · Posted by u/tigroferoce
olivierduval · 2 months ago
Hi

First, it's a great idea! The "introductory" speech is interesting then... the result is really disappointing :-(

You see: I'm French (and European). So, I don't necessarily consider that "Trump" is the center of the "World" (actually quite the opposite). However, on the "World" tab, 50% of the news are about "Trump". I would have thought that the aim of this kind of newsfeed is to challenge Trump tactic's of "newsroom saturation". In particular in that tab (Trump can be the alpha & omega for the USA tab)

jastuk · 2 months ago
As another European, I second this. I avoid Trump "news" like a plague. This was 50% Trump; 8 out of 10 was US.
jastuk commented on Show HN: Browser MCP – Automate your browser using Cursor, Claude, VS Code   browsermcp.io/... · Posted by u/namukang
StevenNunez · 5 months ago
I feel like I slept for a day and now MCPs are everywhere... I don't know what MCPs are and at this point I'm too afraid to ask.
jastuk · 5 months ago
And the worst part is that it opens a pandora's box of potential exploits; https://elenacross7.medium.com/%EF%B8%8F-the-s-in-mcp-stands...
jastuk commented on Design Token-Based UI Architecture   martinfowler.com/articles... · Posted by u/mpweiher
kaelig · 8 months ago
Hi, I'm the founder of the Design Tokens W3C Community Group, we are writing a spec to help with interop across design and developer tooling [1]

There's a whole movement bringing DevOps and SRE thinking to design/UX, essentially working on design infrastructure. Design Tokens are a part of it.

Ask me anything — this may be confusing to some folks ("isn't it just... variables?") and I'm happy to say more.

1: https://tr.designtokens.org/format/

jastuk · 8 months ago
I was super happy learning about design tokens a couple of years back, and eager to use them, but since then my enthusiasm fell as it seemed to "never get there". Figma implemented something which is okay-ish, but completely useless for our needs, while Penpot announced their collab efforts and then radio silence for roughly 2 years now.

I could be out of the loop a bit, but I see that this spec is also still a draft. As somone who'd love to evangelize and implement design tokens internally, when do you see this stepping into the spotlight in a meaningful way? Is there a roadmap of some kind that's available to the public?

jastuk commented on If not React, then what?   infrequently.org/2024/11/... · Posted by u/pier25
phreack · 9 months ago
I call that "developer happiness". It's extremely subjective but yeah, writing and then maintaining React code makes me the most happy in the best case scenarios, makes me feel like I can do more with less, it's easy for me to read and design. I feel like I have more friction with other JS tools.
jastuk · 9 months ago
Just in case you're unaware of it and wish to read similar content, there's a term/thing floating around for some time now, called "Developer Experience" (often abbreviated as "DX") that seems to cover this, and more.
jastuk commented on Ask HN: What are you working on? (October 2024)    · Posted by u/david927
fandorin · 10 months ago
I’m developing a simple iOS app to detect Ultra Processed Food (UPF). The ones that are in Apple Store now are either too complex or paid-only without a chance to test it for free. I believe people should be able to detect UPF and learn how to detect it even without the app (in a long term). I will launch it in 2 weeks max.
jastuk · 10 months ago
English language only, or language independent?
jastuk commented on Cancel Adobe if you are a creative under NDA with your clients   twitter.com/Stretchedwien... · Posted by u/wanderingmind
srameshc · a year ago
Side question: how good are Affinity Designer & Photo as a replacement for Adobe tools ?
jastuk · a year ago
They've recently been bought by Canva, in case that's relevant to you.
jastuk commented on Generation Junk   walterkirn.substack.com/p... · Posted by u/blueridge
jastuk · 2 years ago
It feels at least some of it has to be survivorship bias. Although I do believe there’s tons of cheap, low quality products now more than ever.

u/jastuk

KarmaCake day30August 6, 2010View Original