Readit News logoReadit News
adriano_f commented on AI: Accelerated Incompetence   slater.dev/accelerated-in... · Posted by u/stevekrouse
sensanaty · 3 months ago
> Input Risk. An LLM does not challenge a prompt which is leading...

(Emphasis mine)

This has been the biggest pain point for me, and the frustrating part is that you might not even realize you're leading it a particular way at all. I mean it makes sense with how LLMs work, but a single word used in a vague enough way is enough to skew the results in a bad direction, sometimes contrary to what you actually wanted to do, which can lead you down rabbit holes of wrongness. By the time you realize, you're deep in the sludge of haphazardly thrown-together code that sorta kinda barely works. Almost like human language is very vague and non-specific, which is why we invented formal languages with rules that allow for preciseness in the first place...

Anecdotally, I've felt my skills quickly regressing because of AI tooling. I had a moment where I'd reach out to it for every small task from laziness, but when I took a real step back I started realizing I'm not really even saving myself all that much time, and even worse is that I'm tiring myself out way quicker because I was reading through dozens or hundreds of lines of code, thinking about how the AI got it wrong, correcting it etc. I haven't measured, but I feel like in grand totality, I've wasted much more time than I potentially saved with AI tooling.

I think the true problem is that AI is genuinely useful for many tasks, but there are 2 camps of people using it. There are the people using it for complex tasks where small mistakes quickly add up, and then the other camp (in my experience mostly the managerial types) see it shit out 200 lines of code they don't understand, and in their mind this translates to a finished product because the TODO app that barely works is good enough for an "MVP" that they can point to and say "See, it can generate this, that means it can also do your job just as easily!".

To intercept the usual comments that are no doubt going to come flooding in about me using it wrong or trying the wrong model or whatever, please read through my old comment [1] for more context on my experience with these tools.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44055448

adriano_f · 3 months ago
What I've been doing when I want to avoid this "unexpected leading", is to tell the LLM to "Ask me 3 rounds of 5 clarifying questions each, first.". The first round usually exposes the main assumptions it's making, and from there we narrow down and clarify things.

I've read you comment about all the things you tried, and it seems you have much broader experience with LLMs than I do. But I didn't see this technique mentioned, so leaving this here in case it helps someone else :).

adriano_f commented on Zed: High-performance AI Code Editor   zed.dev/blog/fastest-ai-c... · Posted by u/vquemener
dimaor · 4 months ago
I'm not sure, it might have changed since, but my personal experience was different.

Tried using zed on Linux (pop os, Nvidia) several months ago, was terribly slow, ~1s to open right click context window.

I've spent some time debugging this, and turns out that my GPU drivers are not the best with my current pop os release, but I still don't understand how it might take so long and how GPU is related to right clicking.

Switched back to emacs, love every second. :)

I'm not sure if title referring to actual development speed or the editor performance.

p.s. I play top games on Linux, all is fine with my GPU & drivers.

adriano_f · 4 months ago
I also tried Zed on Linux a few months back, and had GPU/driver issues, so it was either slow or didn't run. Tried it just now and it worked right out of the box, and it's incredibly fast.

I will keep playing around with it to see if it's worth switching (from JetBrains WebStorm).

adriano_f commented on How to build quickly   learnhowtolearn.org/how-t... · Posted by u/fagnerbrack
adriano_f · a year ago
I don't promote often enough, but my writing platform is basically built for working this way:

https://gingkowriter.com

(came up with the concept when struggling to write my PhD thesis)

Hope it helps!

adriano_f commented on Bring back private offices   albertcory50.substack.com... · Posted by u/AlbertCory
windock · a year ago
It is just listening to noises that would distort other unpleasant sounds in a way that they stop being distinguishable/audible. Not a therapy, just masking them temporarily. I know when the risk of disturbing noises is high, and turn on the noise beforehand, or right after it starts. Like, there is a kindergarten near my house, it is noisy, but predictable. So every day I close the window and turn on headphones during the time children are outside.

The therapy, unrelated to this coping approach, was focused on figuring out why I got sensitive to some noises in the first place during childhood. Very individual, but to give an example, appearance of stepfather in my life, whose eating habits were conflicting with the way I was raised before.

adriano_f · a year ago
Thanks for taking the time to add these details. Will add to the arsenal of tools. Best of luck!
adriano_f commented on Bring back private offices   albertcory50.substack.com... · Posted by u/AlbertCory
windock · a year ago
I have misophonia too, related to chewing sounds. It actually developed in offices. I don’t really go to offices anymore. But the thing that definitely helped was listening to violent noises: wind storm in the forest, sound of jet engine, etc. Naturespace app for phones have some really high quality recordings. Well, that and psychotherapy. My mental health directly allows me to spend mental resources resisting all these emotions.
adriano_f · a year ago
My son (11yo) has had this as well for the last 2.5 years. Seeing an Audiologist for treatment.

Can you elaborate a little on "listening to violent noises" approach? When do you do this, for how long? Is it graduated in intensity, like exposure therapy?

Thanks!

adriano_f commented on Bard is now Gemini, and we’re rolling out a mobile app and Gemini Advanced   blog.google/products/gemi... · Posted by u/chamoda
kevinmchugh · 2 years ago
On logic it cannot handle the Dumb Monty Hall problem at all:

https://g.co/gemini/share/33c5fb45738f

adriano_f · 2 years ago
Hilarious!

(For comparison, here's GPT-4 getting it on first try: https://chat.openai.com/share/9e17ed25-d9ea-4e72-a9d8-a139ca... )

adriano_f commented on Blender 4.0 release notes   wiki.blender.org/wiki/Ref... · Posted by u/TangerineDream
lvl102 · 2 years ago
I will go one step further and say they should teach kids Python using Blender. Such a powerful tool and so many learning possibilities.
adriano_f · 2 years ago
I've started teaching my (homeschooled, 10yo) son Python, and he's been briefly exposed to some 3D software (including Blender).

I'm curious: how do you imagine this working? Can you name a few examples of the learning possibilities that you have in mind?

adriano_f commented on Show HN: Nulis – Open Source Tree Editor for Writers   github.com/raymestalez/nu... · Posted by u/rayalez
ajford · 8 years ago
It's in like the first sentence of the Readme.

> Nulis is an open source tree editor for writers, inspired by Gingko.

I will say that it's not mentioned anywhere on nulis.io however.

adriano_f · 8 years ago
Ok, glad it's mentioned somewhere.

Couldn't find any mention first time I checked it out.

Deleted Comment

adriano_f commented on Show HN: Nulis – Open Source Tree Editor for Writers   github.com/raymestalez/nu... · Posted by u/rayalez
adriano_f · 8 years ago
I'm the creator of the app that inspired this one, http://gingkoapp.com

They say imitation is the best form of flattery, but I'm surprised Ray that you didn't credit Gingko at all. It's practically identical.

Thoughts?

---

Edit: My bad... it's not on the website, but I see Gingko mentioned and linked in the Readme. Thanks Ray.

u/adriano_f

KarmaCake day209April 4, 2011
About
Founder of gingkowriter.com CTO of structi.ca
View Original