Readit News logoReadit News
Doches commented on A Complete Guide to Meta Prompting   prompthub.us/blog/a-compl... · Posted by u/saikatsg
ivape · 3 months ago
I'm on hot-take fire today, so may as well keep it going. I'm of the opinion this is the new field of programming. Think of it like Game Engine scripting. The engine is made, but all the level design is going to have to be done with scripting. People that know how to design innovative and practical prompt solutions are going to be quite valuable. In fact, Prompt Engineering is all that's left. Don't even try to out-hot-take me on this one.
Doches · 3 months ago
I'll take that challenge.

Even if you're 100% accurate that the advent of LLMs means that the field of software engineering has effectively devolved into prompt engineering and AI-wrangling, that is a change that we should fight with full-throated, actual-Luddite levels of defense. Your own analogy – the way a tiny, tiny core of 'real' engineers develop game engines, and then the entire field of game development just 'scripts' those engines – sends up a ton of red flags for me.

(Aside: as an erstwhile game developer 'just scripting game engines' is...underselling the craft of programming in game development, but whatever).

For a long time game development has been a weird shadow version of the rest of the tech industry. We're influenced by the same macro trends (e.g. ZIRP, VC fads) and the mood and zeitgeist generally rhyme as a result. But if you look at the drive to unionise game developers vs. same impulse in the mainstream tech industry the feeling is COMPLETELY different.

What's the incentive to unionise if you're a SWE at Meta, Palantir, or Google? Your job is pretty great, your work-life balance is at least not fundamentally out of control, and your STARTING salary puts you in the top 10% of US households. It is probably the last remaining holdout of the 1970s upper-middle-class dream jobs.

And if you're the equivalent engineer at EA, Activision, or Ubisoft? You can expect seasonal layoffs, a good work-life balance means you sleep at home instead of under your desk at least once a week, and your take-home pay is just sufficient to let you split the rent on an outer LA apartment that's just inside tolerable commuting range. Equity? What's that? Management treats you like a disposable cog AND BRAGS ABOUT IT, like they have for the last thirty years.

This is what we want to become? This is the future we're embracing?

Doches commented on My Engineering Craft Regressed   lemmy.ml/post/30100312... · Posted by u/OsrsNeedsf2P
Doches · 3 months ago
> I’ll collect some money and retire in a couple years. Hopefully the open source world stays the same until then.

As someone who explicitly did this and is now out the other side: can confirm, this is the way.

Doches commented on Show HN: Particle - News, Organized   apps.apple.com/us/app/par... · Posted by u/enduser
tomcam · 4 months ago
Downloaded it and am delighted. It feels like a mature product out of the gate. UI for determining the desired news mix is pure genius.

Uh how will it make money?

Doches · 4 months ago
I hereby propose "Tomcam's Iron Law of Revenue": if you have to ask how a product will make money, the answer is "Advertising."
Doches commented on JetBrains IDEs Go AI: Coding Agent, Smarter Assistance, Free Tier   blog.jetbrains.com/blog/2... · Posted by u/crummy
mystified5016 · 4 months ago
I'd be a lot more excited about this if I weren't paying for a crappy VSCode clone.
Doches · 4 months ago
Visual Studio Code was first released in 2015; Intellij (the original JetBrains IDE) was first released in 2001. Even Atom -- the editor that Microsoft forked to make VSCode -- had its first public release in 2014.

It's safe to say that JetBrains IDEs are something other than "crappy VSCode clones."

Doches commented on Trump exempts phones, computers, chips from ‘reciprocal’ tariffs   bloomberg.com/news/articl... · Posted by u/tosh
re-thc · 4 months ago
> Consumer version: expect to see some empty shelves, rejected orders, and higher prices for the next few weeks.

Make that the next few years at this rate.

> Customs and Border Protection is trying to keep up.

There are still people there? DOGE hasn't hit them up?

Doches · 4 months ago
Why would they? If there’s one agency that’s spiritually aligned with DOGE — in terms of incompetence, malice, and sheer cruelty — it’s ICE/CBP.
Doches commented on The Soft Skills Renaissance   sourcetms.com/posts/outso... · Posted by u/sourcetms
Doches · 5 months ago
> Builders can leverage their soft skills like taste, intuition and empathy into their product design.

If you're 'vibe coding' are you really...building something? Kinda sorta devalues the term "builder", in my opinion. At most I'd concede that if you're micro-managing an AI to generate code for you we should call you a "manager".

Is the guy talking about his ideal building design an architect? Is an armchair general _actually_ a general? So why should someone who 'builds' a piece of software by talking to an AI about it a 'builder'?

u/Doches

KarmaCake day2208January 12, 2012
About
Founder at Quail (https://quailhq.com), a store management platform for antique stores. Previously an engineering lead at Palantir, co-founder of an indie games studio, and a publisher of digital magazines.

Email me at trevor@texasexpat.net

View Original