Readit News logoReadit News
pmlnr commented on Google confirms 'high-friction' sideloading flow is coming to Android   androidauthority.com/goog... · Posted by u/_____k
juliie · 16 days ago
Can I install my banking apps? Is there a Google pay equivalent?

As much as I want open source, I really don't think it's there yet for most people.

pmlnr · 16 days ago
> Can I install my banking apps?

Choose a bank with viable web banking.

> Is there a Google pay equivalent?

It's called a debit/credit card.

pmlnr commented on Why We Abandoned Matrix (2024)   forum.hackliberty.org/t/w... · Posted by u/Flere-Imsaho
foresto · 2 months ago
I've been on Matrix for 6 years or so. Some of that time was painful (especially when the largest public server was overloaded by a surge of new users in 2020). It's better now. I can't remember the last time I saw a decryption failure.

I still have gripes about it. Improvements to the spec and software have been slow lately, due to funding issues. But they are still arriving. The official desktop client remains buggy, bloated, and cluttered. But there are lighter alternatives that do what I need 99% of the time. Much of the meta-data is not yet end-to-end encrypted. But that's still planned, and since it's not as important in my day-to-day chats as it might be if I were whistleblowing, I'm willing to wait.

I continue to use Matrix because there is nothing else offering the combination of features that I most value in it. Notably:

- decentralized

- 1:1 and group chats

- offline message delivery

- multi-device support

- end-to-end message encryption with well-understood ciphers and protocols

- easy enough that I have brought in non-tech-savvy contacts with very little assistance

- cross-platform, on every major desktop and mobile OS

- not tied to google services or libraries

- open-source

- free (in both senses)

- self-hostable

- reasonably anonymous; no need for a real name, phone number, or (depending on homeserver) even an email address

- (in development) scalable audio/video chat that looks very promising

Harder to quantify, but also worth acknowledging: The project lead seems very level-headed, demonstrating good judgment and tremendous patience, and consistently makes himself and the inner workings of this difficult project accessible to the public. This gives me the sense that Matrix continues to develop with sound guidance. Thanks, Arathorn!

pmlnr · 2 months ago
XMPP can do everything you listed at a fraction of the resources. It'll also need stub/turn, like everything else for video and voice, but it works.
pmlnr commented on Why We Abandoned Matrix (2024)   forum.hackliberty.org/t/w... · Posted by u/Flere-Imsaho
tptacek · 2 months ago
And the worst available secure messaging system.
pmlnr · 2 months ago
And it's the best widely available, accessible, battle hardened, omnipresent messasing system.
pmlnr commented on Why We Abandoned Matrix (2024)   forum.hackliberty.org/t/w... · Posted by u/Flere-Imsaho
ezst · 2 months ago
> [federation] offers a degree of censorship resistance, as the messages or images are replicated across multiple servers, making it difficult for any single entity to censor or control the content.

That's the way Matrix goes, but that's not an inherent property of federation (XMPP doesn't leak nearly as much metadata as Matrix does, for instance)

Also, there is no free lunch in this space: p2p is slow and inefficient (bandwidth as much as battery) for modern mobile usecases, the workarounds generally consist of having edge servers to act as caches or preferred routing points, and that brings us back to the exact same set of tradeoffs found in the federation model, except with less control.

In short, I agree with the premise that Matrix is terrible, but not that federation is necessarily bad, nor that P2P is clearly superior.

pmlnr · 2 months ago
Email itself is federated. Sort of the original federated messaging.

Deleted Comment

pmlnr commented on I'm tired of Hacker News slop   blog.absurdpirate.com/im-... · Posted by u/speckx
kylehotchkiss · 2 months ago
Did you miss the Cryptocurrency slop? Or the social graph slop?
pmlnr · 2 months ago
Web 2.0 slop, das good shit.
pmlnr commented on I announced my divorce on Instagram and then AI impersonated me   eiratansey.com/2025/12/20... · Posted by u/robin_reala
jwr · 2 months ago
If we write content for closed platforms known to do terrible things, I guess we should not be surprised when said platforms do terrible things.

I keep trying to convince people not to use Instagram, WhatsApp, Facebook, Twitter/X, but I'm not getting anywhere.

Write your own content and post it on your own terms using services that you either own or that can't be overtaken by corporate greed (like Mastodon).

pmlnr · 2 months ago
So many thoughts on this...

The platforms and their convenience that one "only" has to write the post yet the internet needs so much metadata, so it tried to autogenerate it, instead of asking for it. People are put off by need to write a bloody subject for an email already, imagine if they were shown what's actually the "content" is.

About convincing: get the few that matters on deltachat, so they don't need anything new or extra - it's just email on steroids.

As for Mastodon: it's still someone else's system, there's nothing stopping them from adding AI metadata either on those nodes.

pmlnr commented on Cloudflare Global Network experiencing issues   cloudflarestatus.com/inci... · Posted by u/imdsm
chistev · 3 months ago
How come HN is never down with all these outages?
pmlnr · 3 months ago
There are things out there which are running from a bare metal host, without relying on someone else's computer (aka the cloud). HN is one of them.
pmlnr commented on AI is killing privacy. We can't let that happen   fastcompany.com/91435189/... · Posted by u/johnshades
gnarlouse · 3 months ago
> We’ve got OpenAI’s CEO dreaming of a day when “every conversation you’ve ever had in your life, every book you’ve ever read, every email you’ve ever read, everything you’ve ever looked at is in there, plus connected to all your data from other sources. And your life just keeps appending to the context.”

This isn't an inherently bad thing. If an AI could theoretically help you live your life better, nudge you in ways that stabilize your psychology and behaviors for the better of yourself, that's good.

The danger is an AI that decides to re-perpetrate the class division that our existing system does. Lesser fortunate people lose their upward mobility while being guided into subtle traps.

pmlnr · 3 months ago
It is, unless it's absolutely strictly local only to your devices.

It WILL be turned against you at one point, may it be a decline of insurance in the US, political imprisonment on visiting a non-democratic system, and so on.

Deleted Comment

u/pmlnr

KarmaCake day11477October 13, 2014
About
Junior web dinosaur.
View Original