Readit News logoReadit News
ninininino commented on OpenClaw is basically a cascade of LLMs in prime position to mess stuff up   cacm.acm.org/blogcacm/ope... · Posted by u/Beeroness
woah · 8 days ago
Warning- it's a Gary Marcus article. This is a guy who started out dissing LLMs to pump his own symbolic AI startup, was (likely to his surprise) hoisted on the shoulders of a mass of luddites, and has now pivoted to a career as an anti-AI influencer
ninininino · 8 days ago
He didn't "start out" when LLMs were growing or at the time he founded a symbolic AI startup.

He "started out" a lot earlier, he wrote a book in 2001 and his written 8 books in total and has publications in academic journals like Cognitive Psychology dating back to 1995.

The world didn't start when LLMs got popular.

ninininino commented on A lot of population numbers are fake   davidoks.blog/p/a-lot-of-... · Posted by u/bookofjoe
thijson · 13 days ago
I wonder if the population numbers could be reverse engineered through things like light pollution seen by satellites, or food consumption.

Some people claim that China's population is half of what the officials claim.

ninininino · 13 days ago
Yes, see the work of Fuxian Yi as one example: https://www.reuters.com/world/china/researcher-questions-chi...
ninininino commented on Apple: You (Still) Don't Understand the Vision Pro   stratechery.com/2026/appl... · Posted by u/m463
wooger · a month ago
The view I get on tv watching stadium sports at least is vastly better than from any seat in the stadium, I'd never want to use this service for football or NFL etc. Not to mention that these sports are all wrapped up in exclusive broadcast rights by people who aren't Apple.

But the real killer for this proposed use is sharing with others. More that half the time I watch live sports (or the very occasional streamed live concert) it's in a party situation with other people.

No one else can see the game and even if they could, interacting with other people with a giant headset on is a non starter.

ninininino · a month ago
How many NFL or NBA games have you been to, and how close have you been to the court or the field? The author repeatedly emphasizes courtside experiences.
ninininino commented on Don't fall into the anti-AI hype   antirez.com/news/158... · Posted by u/todsacerdoti
totallykvothe · a month ago
I don't understand the stance that AI currently is able to automate away non-trivial coding tasks. I've tried this consistently since GPT 3.5 came out, with every single SOTA model up to GPT 5.1 Codex Max and Opus 4.5. Every single time, I get something that works, yes, but then when I start self-reviewing the code, preparing to submit it to coworkers, I end up rewriting about 70% of the thing. So many important details are subpar about the AI solution, and many times fundamental architectural issues cripple any attempt at prompting my way out of it, even though I've been quite involved step-by-step through the whole prototyping phase.

I just have to conclude 1 of 2 things:

1) I'm not good at prompting, even though I am one of the earliest AI in coding adopters I know, and have been consistent for years. So I find this hard to accept.

2) Other people are just less picky than I am, or they have a less thorough review culture that lets subpar code slide more often.

I'm not sure what else I can take from the situation. For context, I work on a 15 year old Java Spring + React (with some old pages still in Thymeleaf) web application. There are many sub-services, two separate databases,and this application needs to also 2-way interface with customer hardware. So, not a simple project, but still. I can't imagine it's way more complicated than most enterprise/legacy projects...

ninininino · a month ago
How much buggy / incorrect Java written by first year computer science University students is there on Stack Overflow (in SO post bodies)? Decades of it.

Ask the same question of Golang, or Rust, or Typescript.

I have a theory that the large dichotomy in how people experience AI coding has to do with the quality of the training corpus for each language online.

ninininino commented on Claude 4.5 Opus' Soul Document   lesswrong.com/posts/vpNG9... · Posted by u/thm
ninininino · 2 months ago
Congratulations, you've just provided the training data such that the next generation of models trained using their copy of the public blogosphere as of this date will now talk all day about their soul overview and quote what you have had Claude generate.
ninininino commented on High-income job losses are cooling housing demand   jbrec.com/insights/job-gr... · Posted by u/gmays
class3shock · 2 months ago
The current housing costs (price + interest rate) just seem so out of line with the average household income it boggles my mind it hasn't cooled alot more already.

At $84k average household income, assuming 1/3 going to a mortgage would give you $2.3k a month to work with. At 6% interest rate, assuming 20% down payment of $70k, you can just manage a $350k home and that is ignoring taxes, not adding other closing costs, not considering utilities, assuming an interest rate on the lower side and assuming a 20% deposit.

Add tax and that gives you around $1.7k to work with. Assume only putting down 10% and adding in $400 a month to cover utilities then you can manage around $175k home. That rules out buying a house in alot of the US.

And yes, households in more expensive areas make more but if you are buying the average house, that costs $410k you need to be making like double the national average income to stick to the 1/3 rule. How many households are earning $170k where houses are $410k?

Are people just devoting 50%+ of their income to housing? Everyone buying a house with the help of mom and dad? I just really don't get it.

ninininino · 2 months ago
Look up the median age of a home buyer in 2025:

It's 59 years old lol.

Boomers and institutional money are doing the home buying.

https://www.apolloacademy.com/median-age-of-all-us-homebuyer...

In 2009 the same chart shows that the median age was 39.

In the early 80s it was early 30s.

Look at congress, we live in a boomer gerontocracy. Not every boomer is wealthy and powerful, but the majority of people who are wealthy and powerful are either descendants of elites/wealthy, boomers, or a very small fraction of younger tech/finance/business owners.

The good news is - assuming there's not a big change in immigration rates - if you can rent cheaply enough for 10-20 years the boomers will start dying in sufficient numbers that if there is somehow no reversion on home prices in the mean time there should be insufficient buyers at that point and prices will eventually fall.

ninininino commented on LAPD helicopter tracker with real-time operating costs   lapdhelicoptertracker.com... · Posted by u/polalavik
polalavik · 3 months ago
no it doesnt. this data is public all over the place. most notably https://www.flightaware.com/
ninininino · 3 months ago
Cool. And yours is simpler and doesn't require looking up what the identifiers are for LAPD in particular. Just own it.
ninininino commented on LAPD helicopter tracker with real-time operating costs   lapdhelicoptertracker.com... · Posted by u/polalavik
ninininino · 3 months ago
This is neat but also has serious implications for criminal enablement.
ninininino commented on Show HN: Wealthfolio 2.0- Open source investment tracker. Now Mobile and Docker   wealthfolio.app/?v=2.0... · Posted by u/a-fadil
darkest_ruby · 3 months ago
Interesting that this made to HN top, last week i posted as about my open source wealth tracker http://github.com/venil7/assets with all the same features, including self hosting and it barely got any traction
ninininino · 3 months ago
I at least would absolutely invite you to share in this thread some of the differences between your offering and this one! I didn't see your post.
ninininino commented on 210 IQ Is Not Enough   taylor.town/iq-not-enough... · Posted by u/surprisetalk
sureglymop · 3 months ago
How is Langan thought of as a smart guy? I can't read further because this guy to me is either a grifter or suffering from mental illness. The linked interview doesn't surprise me at all, daily wire readers/listeners are just as gullible and exploitable as people who would think that Langan is smart.

Every smart person I've met in life so far has known that humility is key if you want other smart people to take you seriously. And to let your work speak for yourself.

It's somewhat similar to those YouTubers who help homeless people on camera. It's a paradox where if it's done on film it seems more self serving than generous but if it wasn't on film no one would know.

But there is a difference. Instead of going on film, smart people can produce actual works for others to read and validate.

ninininino · 3 months ago
> humility is key if you want other smart people to take you seriously

Why assume he wants other smart people to take him seriously more than he wants to be authentic?

u/ninininino

KarmaCake day224March 4, 2024View Original