Readit News logoReadit News
nekusar commented on A new documentary about the history of forced psychiatric treatment in Spain   bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c... · Posted by u/binning
dang · 3 months ago
> Christians are more concerned about *causing* extreme child abuse

> religion itself is the problem

Religious flamewar isn't allowed here, so please don't post like this.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

---

Edit:

It also looks like your account has been using HN primarily for ideological/political/religious battle. That's not allowed here (see https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme... for more explanation), and we ban accounts that do it.

If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and use HN as intended, we'd appreciate it.

nekusar · 3 months ago
So we're supposed to simultaneously discuss the article (General Franco's extremist Catholic task forces), but not identify the religious tropes behind this?

I read the article, and discussing the article. And as hackers, im curious as how to fix the problems.

nekusar commented on A new documentary about the history of forced psychiatric treatment in Spain   bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c... · Posted by u/binning
graemep · 3 months ago
So, you can find a few isolated quotes in a series of documents written over thousands of years that support the idea that religion is the problem.

Have you read these works considering historical and cultural context? Can you find anything in the New testament that supports this? Do you know about the history of how Christianity shaped European culture? There are excellent books on the subjects (Dominion by Tom Holland is brilliant on the lats of these).

nekusar · 3 months ago
I work in IT, but I also do stuff in historical studies. I dont want to dox myself, cause I just want to chat here anonymously.

In the Americas and Europe, Christianity is the fundamentalist scourge. We all know of Israel, of fundamentalist Judaism. Middle East? You guessed it, 4 of the 5 major sects of Islam are fundamentalist. And moving further East, we see extreme caste-ism and Fundamentalist Hinduism.

China rooted out Fundamentalist Buddhism with Tibet. In 1953, 700,000 of an estimated total population of 1,250,000 were serfs - effectively enslaved peoples on the land attached to the land-lord. Usually a lama, or a priest in Buddhism. This is a case where an oppressive fundamentalist religion was rooted out, and almost a million people were freed.

Im also well aware of all the damage Christianity and Islam did through the millennia in Europe. The priesthood collectively held back science, arts, literature, and countless other things because of "demons, devils, satan". And that only got worse with Dante's Inferno, which somehow got collapsed as bible stories, but really is a fanfiction.

We also see fundamentalist christian hatred flood everywhere with <GASP> more anti-woman sentiment with Witch Trials held basically everywhere. Even had executions up in Holmavik Iceland, to of which a museum was made to commemorate their witch trials. And everyone knows of Salem Massachusetts. Estimates of 30-60000 women were executed in these sham trials, and was predominantly women targeted here.

Perhaps it was too narrow to just blame christians, although the USA is a "christian nation" and what I'm most exposed against my will. No, the problem is fanaticism and fundamentalism. Its one thing to say "My religion says I cant do (action)." and a whole different thing to say "My religion says YOU cant do (action)". All the fundamentalists demand both.

nekusar commented on A new documentary about the history of forced psychiatric treatment in Spain   bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c... · Posted by u/binning
nekusar · 3 months ago
> Whenever you try to remove religion the void fills up with something, and that something is demonic.

I've heard that exact type of comparison before, and it's from those fundamentalist christians. You find out quickly, that "everything is the devil or demonic" that wasn't written down in a bronze-age book and interpreted and translated the snot out of, over a game of telephone played over 2000 years. Most of which was done by illiterates.

Better yet, lets look at what the opposite of this demonic is - judeo-christian values.

1 Samuel 15:3 "Now go, attack Amalek, and proscribe [kill and dedicate to YHWH] all that belongs to him. Spare no one, but kill alike men and women, infants and sucklings, oxen and sheep, camels and asses!"

That god sounds like a petty tribal warlord. Really? Genocide? Even kill the infants and animals?!? And this is what's being accepted as good and holy? And when Saul (king) spared the Amalekite king and some animals, even that benevolence was rewarded with destroying Saul.

Petty. Tribal. Warlord.

And yeah, I've actually read the Torah and New Testament and Koran. I know what I disagree in, and I see how our culture are still afflicted by all this historical religious baggage.

nekusar commented on A new documentary about the history of forced psychiatric treatment in Spain   bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c... · Posted by u/binning
zoklet-enjoyer · 3 months ago
Great comic and there's a documentary about that place. Very messed up that's it's a whole child abuse industry.
nekusar · 3 months ago
Might take a karma hit for this, but whatever. Its the truth.

Christians are more concerned about *causing* extreme child abuse, and then turning around and claiming its to "save them", so the abuse isnt reallllly abuse.

Most of these camps cited are christian. And the people running them? Dogmatic christian fundamentalists. And these are the same types that run "pray the gay away" camps too.

And my inflammatory, albeit true comment also goes right back to the heart of the article:

"Reformatories were institutions where girls and young women who refused to conform to the Franco regime's Catholic values were detained - single mothers, girls with boyfriends, lesbians. Girls who'd been sexually assaulted were incarcerated, assuming the blame for their own abuse. Orphans and abandoned girls might also find themselves living behind convent walls."

Extremist Roman Catholic "values", demonization and imprisonment of 'unruly women', anti-LGBTQ. Same damned thing, again and again.

When are we going to actually look at these issues dispassionately and realize that religion itself is the problem?

nekusar commented on Maestro Technology Sells Used SSD Drives as New   kozubik.com/items/Maestro... · Posted by u/walterbell
Syzygies · 3 months ago
"Other than returning the four parts for a refund (which we did) and documenting this behavior here, our only other recourse was to guarantee that these four specific parts were never sold as new again:"

Alas, one can completely remove Sharpie writing from metal with 99% isopropyl alcohol. Did they make a better choice? This looks like Sharpie writing to me.

nekusar · 3 months ago
nekusar commented on A.I. and Social Media Contribute to 'Brain Rot'   nytimes.com/2025/11/06/te... · Posted by u/pretext
anukin · 3 months ago
The biggest problem is that Lemmy is no substitute for Reddit. Majority of it is run by tankies and people professing extreme left views.
nekusar · 3 months ago
"Extreme left" said by someone likely from the USA is slightly left-of-center basically anywhere else.

The USA democrats and "left" have been overton window'ed so hard that a actual democratic socialist, Mamdani, is compared to being a communist. https://nypost.com/cover/november-5-2025/

There's also hundreds of Lemmy federated servers. I'm sure some are actual communist. But there's plenty for all walks of life. And it's like Mastodon in that regard.

And honestly, if "killing SNAP and other public benefits for poor people" is capitalist, I want nothing to do with that. That is completely ethically bankrupt. Doubly so being one of the richest countries in the world. Absolutely 0 people should be starving. And I'd also say that 0 people should be involuntarily homeless. (some may want to, and choose to be vagabonds and travel. they should have that right! but they should also be able to choose to have a home.)

nekusar commented on Internet Archive's legal fights are over, but its founder mourns what was lost   arstechnica.com/tech-poli... · Posted by u/thinkcontext
throwanem · 3 months ago
What I hear you say is that Brewster's time would be more wisely spent making friends of billionaires.
nekusar · 3 months ago
Possibly, yeah. Make a "Deal" <spit> with AI companies to have back-end access to all the Archive org's content. Get 'permission' to copy EVERYTHING and have billionaires run interference.

The AI companies already got blank checks to do that. Anthropic is paying what, like $3000 per book? I remember when the fucks at the RIAA were suing 12 year olds for $10000 for Britney Spears albums.

Or better yet, if it's just $3k a book, can we license every book and have that added into Archive.org? Oh wait, deals for thee, not for me.

nekusar commented on Internet Archive's legal fights are over, but its founder mourns what was lost   arstechnica.com/tech-poli... · Posted by u/thinkcontext
nekusar · 3 months ago
What capitalism continues to show us: proof that public libraries, if created in the last 10 years, would be deemed illegal and sued out of existence.

It's only because the late 1800's billionaires wanted to leave legacies and made pay-to-enter and free libraries, and migrated them to free, or public libraries. Thats why so many of them are (John) Carnegie Libraries.

Only legal when billionaires do it.

nekusar commented on No Socials November   bjhess.com/posts/no-socia... · Posted by u/speckx
nekusar · 3 months ago
I'd argue that "No Socials November" should be "No corporate Socials November".

Places like the Fediverse (Mastodon, Peertube, Lemmy, pixelfed, etc) are that non-corporate non-gamified breath of fresh air.

Sure, there's less people on those networks, but that too is a great benefit - less bots and less "temperature". And 10 years ago, in 2015, we already saw videos analyzing social media hatred with CGP Grey's "This video will make you angry" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rE3j_RHkqJc

But why anger? Because anger and screaming at people is a guaranteed way to make "engagement", which seems to be the predominant way to prove to advertisers of "people per month". But is it good? Absolutely not. Its poison, slowly but surely. But how do we avoid the poison? The root cause here is money from advertising, which is from engagement.

But you cut out the profit motive, you also cut out advertisers, and you also cut out arbitrary and forced anger-gagement. And that, is the Fediverse.

The opposite is your Facebook, Instagram, Tiktok, Reddit. And they're full of bots, quazi and directly hateful content posted for "engagement", and the same set of hate memes populated froom 1 site to all the rest by bots. No wonder people hate this type of social media. It's wholly toxic and poisonous.

nekusar commented on Addiction Markets   thebignewsletter.com/p/ad... · Posted by u/toomuchtodo
nekusar · 3 months ago
People are also leaving out stuff like Pokemon, Yu Gi Oh, and Magic The Gathering.

All of them also introduce rarities (arbitrary exclusiveness), hidden cards in a pack, and extreme gambling gamification.

The only non-gambling MtG packs are the preconstructed commander decks. All 100 cards are published. But the packs and boxes? Pure gambling, especially for the chase rare cards.

And before anyone asks, yes, my username is based after this $2 card. https://edhrec.com/commanders/nekusar-the-mindrazer

u/nekusar

KarmaCake day142October 2, 2025View Original