Readit News logoReadit News
gpvos commented on Are Apple gift cards safe to redeem?   daringfireball.net/linked... · Posted by u/tosh
miki123211 · 2 days ago
To put this as plainly as I possibly can:

1. It is objectively true that Apple and Google accounts are extremely important to many people.

2. It is also objectively true that most users will only need one of each, a few at most. Fraudsters have no such limitations, and may want to create thousands of them per day if the possibility arises.

3. Therefore, it's likely that a significant percentage of all accounts ever created are fraudulent, even if the actual number of fraudsters is much lower. This is the crucial observation many people miss in this debate.

4. Real users do not want constant iMessage spam and other problems resulting from fraudulent accounts remaining open. Therefore, normal users care deeply about fraudulent accounts being closed promptly (and so do money-laundering regulators, but that's another discussion).

5. Normal users also care about their accounts remaining open. Apple has to balance these two problems.

6. If we force Apple (by regulation, PR crisis or any other method) to be softer on closures, the only way to do that without exacerbating #4 is to make opening fraudulent accounts harder.

7. The only reliable way of preventing fraudsters from opening accounts is strict and invasive identity verification.

8. Therefore, if we're asking Apple / Google to keep more accounts open, we're also asking for more surveillance.

This may actually be the right tradeoff to make, but it is important to point out that there is a tradeoff here, and that no decision in this regard goes without consequences.

gpvos · 14 hours ago
Or we could, you know, restructure our economy so that we don't have huge semi-monopolies anymore. I know, not going to happen, but one can dream.
gpvos commented on Japan to revise romanization rules for first time in 70 years   japantimes.co.jp/news/202... · Posted by u/rgovostes
bitwize · 4 days ago
Compose o dash. Windows doesn't have an easy way to map in the compose key (usually ralt)?

big if true, jesus christ microsoft

gpvos · 3 days ago
Nope. When on Windows I tend to use one of the US International or the Pseudo VT320 layout from https://keyboards.jargon-file.org/ .
gpvos commented on JetBlue flight averts mid-air collision with US Air Force jet   reuters.com/world/america... · Posted by u/divbzero
behnamoh · 4 days ago
the bigger question is: what business does the Netherlands have all the way across the ocean in an island? Who gave them the "right" to own it?
gpvos · 4 days ago
We didn't have the right, obviously, but it has happened and we need to deal with the current situation. And the Netherlands has offered them sovereignty multiple times in the last fifty years, they can leave anytime they want. But nowadays they want to stay in the kingdom, mostly because it offers them some security and stability.
gpvos commented on JetBlue flight averts mid-air collision with US Air Force jet   reuters.com/world/america... · Posted by u/divbzero
t0mas88 · 4 days ago
It's expected for military operations to fly without transponder, they don't want to have their location visible. But it's crazy that they're also doing it in Curacao controlled airspace without agreeing a restricted area.

Even for training they set up restricted/military areas in airspace all the time. Not doing it here, in allied (Curacao is part of the kingdom of the Netherlands) airspace is unacceptable. They could have coordinated this in the normal ways so ATC would route civilian traffic around the military operations or talk to the military controllers (who can see both types of traffic) before sending an aircraft through the shared airspace.

This isn't new, it's how military operations are done all the time.

gpvos · 4 days ago
Trump doesn't understand the word "allied".
gpvos commented on The inefficiency of RL, and implications for RLVR progress   dwarkesh.com/p/bits-per-s... · Posted by u/cubefox
gpvos · 18 days ago
That's the normal way to introduce an acronym in an article.

Anyway, I was just saying that however irritating, it's likely just an omission out of forgetfulness, not deliberate clickbait. A minor application of Hanlon's razor.

Seeing the downvotes and even a flag, it appears I'll have to lower my expectation of people's cultural baggage here.

gpvos · 5 days ago
Additionally, replying to "in the field" in GP: this is about the article title. You first have to know which field the article is in, which simply is not clear if you are an HN reader that happens to not be in that field.
gpvos commented on Apple has locked my Apple ID, and I have no recourse. A plea for help   hey.paris/posts/appleid/... · Posted by u/parisidau
pflenker · 7 days ago
I don’t mean to defend this, but I know from experience that gift cards are frequently used for money laundring. The laws against that are very strict, incentivizing companies to overshoot and block false positives.

At the same time, AML solutions tend to be a closely guarded black box which simply tells you to block a customer, finding out why is pretty difficult.

To add more to the problem, some anti money Landry solutions are … AI powered.

gpvos · 7 days ago
AML = ?

(edit) Ah, right, anti-money-laundering, found it in your last sentence.

gpvos commented on The inefficiency of RL, and implications for RLVR progress   dwarkesh.com/p/bits-per-s... · Posted by u/cubefox
sidibe · 20 days ago
Ok so now it's stupid or malicious to use RL as reinforcement learning on a blog about AI where everyone in the field has been referring to it as RL forever? Even wikipedia puts (RL) after reinforcement learning.
gpvos · 18 days ago
That's the normal way to introduce an acronym in an article.

Anyway, I was just saying that however irritating, it's likely just an omission out of forgetfulness, not deliberate clickbait. A minor application of Hanlon's razor.

Seeing the downvotes and even a flag, it appears I'll have to lower my expectation of people's cultural baggage here.

gpvos commented on The inefficiency of RL, and implications for RLVR progress   dwarkesh.com/p/bits-per-s... · Posted by u/cubefox
on_the_train · 20 days ago
[flagged]
gpvos · 20 days ago
[flagged]
gpvos commented on Molly: An Improved Signal App   molly.im/... · Posted by u/dtj1123
grishka · 22 days ago
> What "proprietary blobs" does Signal have?

As they say in the Github readme, FCM and Google Maps.

FCM doesn't technically require a blob — it's just that Google wants you to think it does. I reverse engineered their library and it turned out to be a criminally over-engineered wrapper around two broadcast receivers. So, the Mastodon app is proudly the first app ever to both support FCM push notifications, and be 100% open-source.

gpvos · 21 days ago
FCM = Firebase Cloud Messaging, a messaging and notification service run by Google. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firebase_Cloud_Messaging
gpvos commented on EXIF orientation info in PNGs isn't used for image-orientation: from-image   bugzilla.mozilla.org/show... · Posted by u/justin-reeves
donatj · a month ago
Interesting. I was not aware that was a thing. Orientation info seems way less useful in a lossless format like PNG. It makes sense in JPEG for instance because rotating and re-encoding would be lossy and slightly degrade the image.
gpvos · a month ago
JPEGs can be rotated losslessly as long as their size is a multiple of eight (or to be pedantic, the block size, which is usually eight).

u/gpvos

KarmaCake day7944June 30, 2011View Original