Readit News logoReadit News
frodetb commented on Only one pair of distinct positive integers satisfy the equation m^n = n^m   keith-mcnulty.medium.com/... · Posted by u/keithmcnulty
eru · 2 years ago
Maybe. I do appreciate seeing both approaches, though.
frodetb · 2 years ago
Agreed! I'm realizing that my comment came across as negative, but I did appreciate seeing a second path to the same place. I also agree that the expression x^(1/x) feels like a more natural place to start.

You often see this I think, in "pretty" proofs compared with the more direct approach. A clever early step or some bit of startling insight.

frodetb commented on Only one pair of distinct positive integers satisfy the equation m^n = n^m   keith-mcnulty.medium.com/... · Posted by u/keithmcnulty
OscarCunningham · 2 years ago
I think taking logs is an unnecessary indirection in the given proof. If n^m = m^n then raising both sides to the power of 1/(nm) gives us n^(1/n) = m^(1/m). So we are looking for two distinct positive integers at which the function x ↦ x^(1/x) takes the same value. The rest of the proof then goes as before.

Differentiating the above function yields (1/x^2)(1-log(x))x^(1/x), which is positive when log(x) < 1 and negative when log(x) > 1. So the function has a maximum at e and decreases on either side of it. Therefore one of our integers must be less than e, and the other greater than it. For the smaller integer there are only two possibilities, 1 and 2. Using 1 doesn't give a solution since the equation x^(1/x) = 1 only has the solution 1. So the only remaining possibility for the smaller number is 2, which does yield the solution 2^4 = 4^2. Since x^(1/x) is strictly decreasing when x > e, there can't be any other solutions with the same value.

frodetb · 2 years ago
Logs will appear no matter what, at some point in the line of reasoning. They are only held back until differentiating in this approach. I think the expression for the derivative of logn/n was much nicer to grapple with.
frodetb commented on Requiem for a Great Cat   newyorker.com/culture/cul... · Posted by u/Hooke
wskish · 2 years ago
There really should be a word for “personality” as applied to a cat. “Catitude” is the one that comes to mind for me.
frodetb · 2 years ago
"Catitude" is a good one. One might also say "felinity". Or "kittyhood". Or "purrsonality"!

I've only watched the movie version, but all these feel like they were words spoken by a character in CATS the musical.

frodetb commented on Generative Agents: Interactive Simulacra of Human Behavior   arxiv.org/abs/2304.03442... · Posted by u/mmq
Jeff_Brown · 2 years ago
People on Twitter are speculating breathlessly about using this for social science. I don't immediately see uses for it outside of fiction, esp. video games.

It would be cool if some kind of law of large numbers (an LLN for LLMs) implied that the decisions made by a thing trained on the internet will be distributed like human decisions. But the internet seems a very biased sample. Reporters (rightly) mostly write about problems. People argue endlessly about dumb things. Fiction is driven by unreasonably evil characters and unusually intense problems. Few people elaborate the logic of ordinary common sense, because why would they? The edge cases are what deserve attention.

A close model of a society will need a close model of beliefs, preferences and material conditions. Closely modeling any one of those is far, far beyond us.

frodetb · 2 years ago
Hey now, I turned out all right.
frodetb commented on Are We <Thing> Yet?   wiki.mozilla.org/Areweyet... · Posted by u/xeonmc
frodetb · 2 years ago
For the past decade there has here in Norway been a recurring news sensation surrounding the mountain Mannen[1] (literally "the man") located in Romsdal in the northernmost part of Western Norway. Geologists have found Mannen to be at high risk of a sudden and large-scale landslide, placing the local population at the base of the mountain at great peril. There have been several abrupt evacuations of the place over the years, whenever measurements indicate a sudden increase in risk, with great media exposure and public interest. However, The Man has still yet to fall as predicted.

A website was soon set up: "HarMannenFalt.no"[2] (Has the Man fallen?), displaying no more than the word "NEI" (No). The sentiment of the joke was felt by all, as many had grown tired of all this attention being directed at what was essentially, on its surface, just a mountain, standing there, doing nothing.

I was a student at the time, and remember many idle screens around campus set to this page, reeking of that sarcastic mock-worry only a student body could put on. But I suspect a lot of us were secretly waiting for the moment when the text would change into "JA".

And soon enough, something did in fact happen. A neighbouring mountain, Veslemannen (The Little Man), saw a considerable increase in daily movement in 2018, before finally there was a minor landslide in 2019. But this was not the landslide we had been promised and waited for, as The Man himself was still standing tall as ever. A "JA" was not really in order, but then perhaps neither was really a "NEI".

Instead, the website was updated to show "TJA", a Norwegian word somewhere between yes and no, with meaning closer to "Well, perhaps".

As an aside: A second website with identical design was also created: "HarDovreFalt.no"[3]. A play on the concept with allusion to the vow of our founding fathers: "Enige og tro inntil Dovre faller" (Agreeing and true until Dovre falls)[4]. The "NO" on this second site, I think, is far less likely to change any time soon.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mannen

[2] https://harmannenfalt.no

[3] https://hardovrefalt.no

[4] https://no.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enige_og_tro_inntil_Dovre_fall...

frodetb commented on Rational Dress Society   en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat... · Posted by u/samclemens
Arrath · 2 years ago
Same here. A youth of track, soccer and skiing has bequeathed me a rear that most of the women in my life are jealous of, and yet it is a curse. Nothing fuckin fits right!
frodetb · 2 years ago
Right on point, "a blessing and a curse".
frodetb commented on Rational Dress Society   en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat... · Posted by u/samclemens
user_named · 2 years ago
Why do you need suspenders if you've had the pants tailored? What's your bmi?
frodetb · 2 years ago
The tailoring was just for taper and length. The waist I didn't do much with so it's pretty loose. Besides, the pants are simply supposed to be worn with suspenders. I'm not sure as I haven't tried fitted high-rise trousers, but I think it would be hard to keep them in place otherwise.

As for my BMI, I'm 183cm at 85kg, which I understand nudges me just inside of "overweight".

frodetb commented on Rational Dress Society   en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat... · Posted by u/samclemens
masklinn · 2 years ago
> My thighs and butt are huge, compared to other guys of similar proportions

Have you considered looking at the women’s? Might be no better in the end, but this reads like what’s conventionally a feminine anatomy, and garment designers will generally go with conventional anatomy, if not outright prescribe completely imaginary ones you have to conform to.

frodetb · 2 years ago
I absolutely have! Didn't think it was worth the tangent so I'm glad you're bringing it up. Women's fashion is so much more varied in shape, size, style, and fit, and some of it even looks comfortable. As a matter of fact, if you search for high-rise trousers online, most of the results are precisely in the women's section. I think that will have to be my next stop, though it's a line to cross and somewhat of pill to swallow.

As an aside, I have said for a long time that I wish it was socially uncontroversial for a guy to wear a loose skirt or dress in public, and that if I found one I liked I would wear it all the time.

frodetb commented on Rational Dress Society   en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat... · Posted by u/samclemens
frodetb · 2 years ago
This is a premise I can get behind.

One of the silliest battles I have found myself fighting against society has been my search for comfortable yet attractive men's pants. I deeply dislike the restricting fit of modern pants, especially tighter fitting jeans, but also the semi-current fashion in suits and pants in general.

It may be that a catalyst for this conflict has been my anatomy. My thighs and butt are huge, compared to other guys of similar proportions, and so apparently they cannot be contained by modern fashions. Every time I try to put on a pair, they're either too loose in the waist, or too tight in the thighs, and always sit too low for my liking, digging into my groin if I force the belt to sit at my waist. And should i find a pair that feels acceptable at first, my optimism only lasts until I have to sit down and feel the edge of these clothes digging uncomfortably into my flesh, rekindling my hatred for these trends and their designers.

The current resolution to my woes has been Darcy Clothing's line of suspender pants[1], which I have had tailored after purchase to taper and fit my height. However, this look is quite jarring in a modern environment, so I tend to wear a sweater over the suspenders. Still, I sometimes need to take it off, and wearing something like this day in and out puts quite a label on you.

Still to this day I keep my eyes open, hoping that the pants of my desires will appear in a shop somewhere, or that trends will change, and we get style in service of comfort, instead of discomfort in service of style.

[1] https://www.darcyclothing.com/collections/mens-trousers

frodetb commented on I don’t want a new phone, but I’m probably buying one   kooslooijesteijn.net/blog... · Posted by u/janvdberg
janandonly · 2 years ago
This hit home hard for me:

> You decided that you wanted to use some framework/feature/API and save developer time. Which is odd. Because consider how much time you spend trying to not harm the environment in your free time: shopping for sustainable products, bringing your reusable cup, recycling. And then think of the minutes you save with new programming stuff compared to the number of iPhones discarded because of that.

frodetb · 2 years ago
Me too, and I was disappointed to see this comment section mostly full of people either blaming the author or explaining why their experience actually makes sense.

It's like a positive feedback-loop (though I guess morally negative) between manufacturers, developers, and users, all three dragging/pushing on the other to roll down the hill of faster hardware and heavier apps, none of them really in control or able to stop, and therefore also not directly to blame. The upgrade-train to Waste City has no breaks. Still, it seems to me at least that the manufacturers are the only ones strictly happy about the situation.

u/frodetb

KarmaCake day214June 22, 2020View Original