Readit News logoReadit News
asats commented on Why language models hallucinate   openai.com/index/why-lang... · Posted by u/simianwords
rhubarbtree · 4 days ago
I find this rather oddly phrased.

LLMs hallucinate because they are language models. They are stochastic models of language. They model language, not truth.

If the “truthy” responses are common in their training set for a given prompt, you might be more likely to get something useful as output. Feels like we fell into that idea and said - ok this is useful as an information retrieval tool. And now we use RL to reinforce that useful behaviour. But still, it’s a (biased) language model.

I don’t think that’s how humans work. There’s more to it. We need a model of language, but it’s not sufficient to explain our mental mechanisms. We have other ways of thinking than generating language fragments.

Trying to eliminate cases where a stochastic model the size of an LLM gives “undesirable” or “untrue” responses seems rather odd.

asats · 4 days ago
Exactly. I always found it strange when people assume that "hallucinations" are just some sort of a bug in the system, as if by you tweaking some code or training modality will produce an oracle of absolute truth incapable of making mistakes.
asats commented on Tesla changes meaning of 'Full Self-Driving', gives up on promise of autonomy   electrek.co/2025/09/05/te... · Posted by u/MilnerRoute
lukeschlather · 4 days ago
I had taken for granted that the cameras in the Tesla might be equivalent to human vision, but now I'm realizing that's probably laughable. I'm reading it's 8 cameras at 30fps and it sounds like the car's bus can only process about 36fps (so a total of 36fps, not 8x30 = 240fps theoretically available from the cameras, if they had a better memory bus.) It also seems plausible you would need at least 10,000 FPS to fully match human vision (especially taking into account that humans turn their heads which in a CV situation could be analogous to the CV algorithm having 32x30 = 960 FPS, but typically only processing 140 frames this second from cameras pointing in a specific direction.

So maybe LIDAR isn't necessary but also if Tesla were actually investing in cameras with a memory bus that could approximate the speed of human vision I doubt it would be cheaper than LIDAR to get the same result.

asats · 4 days ago
Also the human vision is backed by the general intelligence, which those cameras are very much not.
asats commented on Stripe Launches L1 Blockchain: Tempo   tempo.xyz... · Posted by u/_nvs
boringg · 6 days ago
So then by using this product you are de facto buying short term US debt lowering the debt costs in a way? Is that what you are describing? And Stripe makes money on that short term carry.
asats · 6 days ago
Still doesn't answer why you would need any crypto here. Why can't the USD transferred to stripe just be a record in an SQL database saying customer X has N USD in the account, and transferring that around could be done instantly at zero cost by changing an sql row.
asats commented on We already live in social credit, we just don't call it that   thenexus.media/your-phone... · Posted by u/natalie3p
christina97 · 7 days ago
This thread is largely about college educated folks who represent a small minority of diversity lottery applicants. As to why the DV lottery has grown, I suspect it has a lot to do with it just having become more visible and known, growing hand in hand with increased access to internet and ability to apply.
asats · 7 days ago
Sure, if we are talking about the top end we can check the O-visas, the "extraordinary ability in the sciences, arts, education, business, or athletics" ones, both the applications and the issuance of those went up even more than the DV applications:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/O_visa#Number_of_visas_issued_...

asats commented on We already live in social credit, we just don't call it that   thenexus.media/your-phone... · Posted by u/natalie3p
nanliu · 7 days ago
The desire to come and immigrate to the US has greatly diminished. This use to be a easy decision for foreign students to stay in the US for work opportunities. Nowadays, a US degree isn't considered prestigious outside of a few elite schools and the cost has completely spiraled out of control. I've talked to numerous colleagues who abandoned waiting for a green card because it's no longer a clear cut decision. Opportunities and quality of life in other countries have either caught up or surpassed the US in certain areas. This would of been unthinkable 10-20 years ago.
asats · 7 days ago
>The desire to come and immigrate to the US has greatly diminished

Do you have any data to back up that claim?

E.g. the number of diversity lottery applicants (one of the easiest proxies to judge how many people express their interest in moving to the US) went up from 12 million in 2011 to almost 20 million last year.

asats commented on We already live in social credit, we just don't call it that   thenexus.media/your-phone... · Posted by u/natalie3p
Bukhmanizer · 8 days ago
The issue is that American media/discourse paints a very distorted view of what life under authoritarian rule is like. The truth is in many countries, unless you’re some kind of minority, politically active, or in legal trouble, day-to-day life is mostly similar to life in the west. But people don’t want to hear that, because we want to feel better than them. Like we wouldn’t tolerate that kind of life.

Of course the most frustrating part about that is as the US and other western countries start sliding into authoritarianism, people deny it because they don’t feel like it’s authoritarian.

Edit: To clarify, I don’t think life is exactly the same - just that the consequences of authoritarianism are much more insidious than they’re portrayed.

asats · 7 days ago
>day-to-day life is mostly similar to life in the west

The "happy path" is, the major differences start when you have any kind of a problem, then not having any functional institutions makes the experience _very_ different from the west.

asats commented on The web does not need gatekeepers: Cloudflare’s new “signed agents” pitch   positiveblue.substack.com... · Posted by u/positiveblue
immibis · 11 days ago
So, under the free traffic tier of any decent provider.
asats · 11 days ago
The pages are not static and require computation to serve, and there's more than one app on that same bare metal server, so it was negatively affecting the performance of a lot of my other stuff.

If I couldn't easily cut off the majority of that bot volume I probably would've shut down the app entirely.

asats commented on The web does not need gatekeepers: Cloudflare’s new “signed agents” pitch   positiveblue.substack.com... · Posted by u/positiveblue
matt-p · 12 days ago
I have zero issue with Ai Agents, if there's a real user behind there somewhere. I DO have a major issue with my sites being crawled extremely aggressively by offenders including Meta, Perplexity and OpenAI - it's really annoying realising that we're tying up several cpu cores on AI crawling. Less than on real users and google et al.
asats · 12 days ago
I've some personal apps online and I had to turn the cloudflare ai bot protection on because one of them got 1.6TB of data accessed by the bots in the last month, 1.3 million requests per day, just non stop hammering it with no limits.
asats commented on Show HN: I built an app to block Shorts and Reels   scrollguard.app/... · Posted by u/adrianhacar
TheCapeGreek · 23 days ago
I keep Instagram to keep in touch with friends abroad.

I keep Facebook because certain communities and events only happen there.

For some of us, it is plain better to only block short form video.

asats · 23 days ago
Both of those things could be solved by just talking to people, and talking to people does not require you to use addiction machines.

I keep in touch with my friends abroad by emailing them when I think about them, and I get long form responses on what they are up to, not whatever is the public image filtered stuff that they may or may not be posting somewhere.

asats commented on Telo MT1   telotrucks.com/... · Posted by u/turtleyacht
01100011 · a month ago
It's getting harder to find good online discussions devoid of bias and emotions. With user moderation, control goes to those with the most time to waste online, meaning the least happy, productive and social.
asats · a month ago
And it's a self reinforcing downward loop as those deteriorating online spaces then completely drive away everyone with anything better to do

u/asats

KarmaCake day730September 15, 2020View Original