Readit News logoReadit News
JustFinishedBSG commented on If AI writes code, should the session be part of the commit?   github.com/mandel-macaque... · Posted by u/mandel_x
rzerowan · 10 days ago
This is a central problem that weve already seen proliferate wildly in Scientific research , and currently if the same is allowed to be embedded in foundational code. The future outlook would be grim.

Replication crisis[1].

Given initial conditions and even accounting for 'noise' would a LLm arrive at the same output.It should , for the same reason math problems require one to show their working. Scientific papers require the methods and pseudocode while also requireing limitations to be stated.

Without similar guardrails , maintainance and extension of future code becomes a choose your own adventure.Where you have to guess at the intent and conditions of the LLM used.

[1] https://www.ipr.northwestern.edu/news/2024/an-existential-cr...

JustFinishedBSG · 10 days ago
> for the same reason math problems require one to show their working.

We don't put our transitional proofs in papers, only the final best one we have. So that analogy doesn't work.

For every proof in a paper there is probably 100 non-working / ugly sketches or just snippets of proofs that exist somewhere in a notebook or erased on a blackboard.

JustFinishedBSG commented on If AI writes code, should the session be part of the commit?   github.com/mandel-macaque... · Posted by u/mandel_x
arppacket · 10 days ago
While it's noisy and complicated for humans to read through, this session info is primarily for future AI to read and use as additional input for their tasks.

We could have LLMs ingest all these historical sessions, and use them as context for the current session. Basically treat the current session as an extension of a much, much longer previous session.

Plus, future models might be able to "understand" the limitations of current models, and use the historical session info to identity where the generated code could have deviated from user intention. That might be useful for generating code, or just more efficient analysis by focusing on possible "hotspots", etc.

Basically, it's high time we start capturing any and all human input for future models, especially open source model development, because I'm sure the companies already have a bunch of this kind of data.

JustFinishedBSG · 10 days ago
> While it's noisy and complicated for humans to read through, this session info is primarily for future AI to read and use as additional input for their tasks.

Context rot is very much a thing. May still be for future agents. Dumping tens/hundreds of thousand of trash tokens into context very much worsen the performance of the agent

JustFinishedBSG commented on If AI writes code, should the session be part of the commit?   github.com/mandel-macaque... · Posted by u/mandel_x
JustFinishedBSG · 10 days ago
I understand the idea but the way I work, a commit isn't "a" session, it's potentially tens of sessions with branching in each session.

I honestly don't know if I'm doing something very wrong or if I have a very different working style than many people, but for me "just give the prompt/session" isn't a possibility because there isn't one.

I'm probably incredibly inefficient, because even when I don't use AI it is the same, a single commit is usually many different working states / ideas / branches of things I tried and explored that have been amended / squashed.

JustFinishedBSG commented on Just-bash: Bash for Agents   github.com/vercel-labs/ju... · Posted by u/tosh
jeffchuber · 14 days ago
last weekend I vibe-coded a project called `openfs` that plugs into just-bash

https://github.com/jeffchuber/just-bash-openfs

it puts a bash interface in front of s3, filesystem (real and in-memory), postgres, and chroma.

still very much alpha - but curious what people think about it.

see an example app here: https://github.com/jeffchuber/openfs-incident-app

JustFinishedBSG · 14 days ago
What problem were you trying to solve ? ( not that you need to solve one. I’m just curious )
JustFinishedBSG commented on An ARM Homelab Server, or a Minisforum MS-R1 Review   sour.coffee/2026/02/20/an... · Posted by u/neelc
ninth_ant · 20 days ago
And despite their broadly similar performance, the RK3588s have significantly better power draw.

However I’m not sure of any of the rk3588 vendors that support both UEFI and have a full-size PCIe slot like the MS-R1 has.

JustFinishedBSG commented on €5k Swiss cameras with zero electronics   alpa.swiss... · Posted by u/reconnecting
JustFinishedBSG · 2 months ago
Well according to the website you cannot buy a fully mechanical lens anymore so it doesn’t appear to be true that they sell cameras with zero electronic anymore
JustFinishedBSG commented on Raspberry Pi's New AI Hat Adds 8GB of RAM for Local LLMs   jeffgeerling.com/blog/202... · Posted by u/ingve
JustFinishedBSG · 2 months ago
It's useless for LLMs and it's actually slower than Hailo 8H for standard vision tasks, so, why ?
JustFinishedBSG commented on AWS raises GPU prices 15% on a Saturday, hopes you weren't paying attention   theregister.com/2026/01/0... · Posted by u/Brajeshwar
aurareturn · 2 months ago

  Are we looking at a future where home computers are replaced by thin clients and all the power lies in subscription services?
No if we're in a working free market. Companies will see the rising prices and start making more of those things, bringing prices back down.

JustFinishedBSG · 2 months ago
How, when foundries are a natural monopoly? How can you realistically create a startup to build a multibillion / multi year fab ?
JustFinishedBSG commented on Pricing Changes for GitHub Actions   resources.github.com/acti... · Posted by u/kevin-david
BugsJustFindMe · 3 months ago
Everyone in this thread has gone absolutely insane. $5/month gets you 41 fucking _hours_ of continuous operation. If you're not utterly abusing the platform, this falls extremely below the threshold of caring. And if not, what the fuck are you even doing with all those hours? The new per-minute charge is less than one millisecond of engineer labor cost.
JustFinishedBSG · 3 months ago
It could be 1 dollar a month, I'm still not paying to use my own ressources
JustFinishedBSG commented on Mistral 3 family of models released   mistral.ai/news/mistral-3... · Posted by u/pember
uejfiweun · 3 months ago
Wow. If all the trillions only produces that small of a diff... that's shocking. That's the sort of knowledge that could pop the bubble.
JustFinishedBSG · 3 months ago
I wouldn't trust LMArena results much. They measure user preference and users are highly skewed by style, tone etc.

You can litteraly "improve" your model on LMArena by just adding a bunch of emojis.

u/JustFinishedBSG

KarmaCake day1312March 24, 2016View Original