Readit News logoReadit News
Barrera commented on Commenting on Hacker News   superbowl.substack.com/p/... · Posted by u/superb-owl
Barrera · 4 years ago
> Choosing to post anonymously, rather than using my real name, made things much easier. I’ve occasionally commented under my real name, and am embarrassed looking back at my post history. There’s nothing terrible, but I’m sure some of my colleagues and friends have stumbled upon it and smirked. This might be projection or paranoia, but it causes enough anxiety to deter me from posting regularly.

One thing that pseudonymity will do is allow you support positions you don't actually hold. To steel man them. To really stretch your brain to find the best way to present and argue in favor of them. Doing so pseudonymously means never having to explain yourself to friends, family, employers, or three-letter organizations later.

This also works really well for positions you're leaning toward but don't know why. Or half-baked ideas you'd like someone to respond to. Or just questions that you're embarrassed to ask.

This may not fit with the letter of the HN guidelines, depending on the distinctions between "throwaway," "pseudonym," and "temporary pseudonym":

> Throwaway accounts are ok for sensitive information, but please don't create accounts routinely. HN is a community—users should have an identity that others can relate to.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

But I think it fits with the spirit. From "What to Post?":

> On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity.

Barrera commented on Real peer review has never been tried   worksinprogress.co/issue/... · Posted by u/bilsbie
Barrera · 4 years ago
I was expecting the author to define "real peer review," but didn't see that. The best approximation is probably gleaned from the conclusion:

- integration of preprint servers and alt metrics

- tweaking incentives to review

- making comments on papers public

- use of software to detect fraud

- directing resources specifically to improving peer review

The bigger problem is that the author doesn't seem to actually zero in on the problem peer review is supposed to solve today. The author notes that peer review really got going in the 1970s as a way to filter content flowing to overwhelmed editors. But the emergence of the internet largely nullifies that problem. Wide distribution of scientific information no longer requires scientific publishers.

The real problem is the ways in which science funding, journals, and peer review have become intertwined, with publishers playing the role of bankers in this economy. This problem is cultural, not technical. It's a historical relic and it increasingly does not serve science well.

So, what is the actual problem that journal-supervised peer review is supposed to solve in the age of the internet?

Barrera commented on Carbon Language: An experimental successor to C++   github.com/carbon-languag... · Posted by u/emidoots
Barrera · 4 years ago
From the README:

> Interoperate with your existing C++ code, from inheritance to templates

Somewhere in the docs (can't remember where) is a link to a Rust/C++ interop project sponsored by Google, Crubit:

https://github.com/google/crubit/blob/main/docs/design.md

In case it's not clear, Carbon is also at the moment a Google project.

There's not much in the Crubit README (although there is a warning not to use it), but the docs directory has some interesting stuff:

> The primary goal of C++/Rust interop tooling is to enable Rust to be used side-by-side with C++ in large existing codebases.

https://github.com/google/crubit/blob/main/docs/design.md

It's not entirely clear whether this interop is to work as envisioned for Carbon (source level?) or some other approach.

Barrera commented on Ask HN: What's the most powerful skill in software development?    · Posted by u/codingclaws
Barrera · 4 years ago
Knowing the difference between a project that will provide value and one that won't. This is a very hard skill to learn, but delivers massive payoff. Almost everything else can be learned from books. Build the wrong thing and it won't matter how well you did it.
Barrera commented on Runway melts at London Luton airport as temperatures in UK near 40°C   dailytelegraph.com.au/new... · Posted by u/russfink
Barrera · 4 years ago
> The runway also “melted” at the RAF Brize Norton, military air base in Oxfordshire, west of London, on Monday as the UK struggled to cope with the weather.

That word "melted" seems unjustified. CNBC reports:

> The RAF didn’t specify why it suspended flights, but a spokesperson said “the runway has not melted” as early media reports indicated.

https://www.cnbc.com/2022/07/18/london-flights-suspended-aft...

Barrera commented on Germany to Rethink Nuclear Shutdown as Energy Crisis Deepens   climatechangedispatch.com... · Posted by u/notlukesky
Barrera · 4 years ago
> Germany’s nuclear phase-out was prompted by Japan’s Fukushima nuclear power disaster in 2011.

What's interesting here is how Germany's public policy is swaying in the winds of current events. First it was Japan's experience that triggered the country to pull the plug on nuclear. Now it's the Ukraine war triggering them to plug that sucker back in.

Sacrificing the long term for the short was in former times described as a characteristically American problem. I remember reading article after article about how far-sighted the European governments were. How they built consensus across public and private sectors, working on a scale of many years rather than just one quarter. How much better equipped they were to weather bad times.

It turns out all democracies face similar problems (The People want benefits without pain), but good times create illusions to the contrary for a while.

Barrera commented on How did REST come to mean the opposite of REST?   htmx.org/essays/how-did-r... · Posted by u/edofic
Barrera · 4 years ago
Several commenters take the position that the distinction doesn't matter. This is "an old person's battle." What matters is getting things done.

I'm not so sure. For one thing, it's of both theoretical and practical interest to trace the path of how a technical term comes to mean its opposite over time. If you're in the business of creating technical terms (everyone building technologies is), you might learn something by studying the REST story.

For one thing, Fielding's writing is not exactly approachable. REST is described in a PhD dissertation that is dense, packed with jargon and footnotes, and almost devoid of graphics or examples. His scarce later writings on REST were not much better.

Others who thought they understood Fielding, but who could write/speak better than him, came along with different ideas. Their ideas stuck and Fielding's didn't because he wrote like an academic and they did not.

The other thing that happened is that the technological ground shifted. To even begin to understand Fielding requires forgetting much or all of what one knows about modern web technologies. Part of that shift is the timing of Fielding's rediscovery with deep frustration over XML/RPC.

Barrera commented on Ask HN: Is having a personal blog/brand worth it for you?    · Posted by u/zulrah
Barrera · 4 years ago
> Writing up my thoughts in presentable state took too much time/effort.

What you may not realize is how crucial writing is to thinking. You won't really know what you think about a topic until you try to put those thoughts into a persuasive or informative essay. The "time/effort" is an investment in your brain.

This is something I've personally experienced hundreds of times.

It's possible to do as you are doing and not publish written thoughts. However, doing so motivates thinking about the topic from many different perspectives as you try to anticipate objections/questions.

Barrera commented on Bear Blog – A privacy-first, fast blogging platform   bearblog.dev... · Posted by u/janandonly
Barrera · 4 years ago
I like the idea, but to echo another comment, the hardest part of running a blog is not selecting the blogging engine or how to host it. The hardest part is keeping new posts flowing through the engine.

What blogging platforms focus on this side of things? Which ones help solve the "What do I write next?" problem?

u/Barrera

KarmaCake day2191February 28, 2022View Original