Readit News logoReadit News
GarnetFloride · 6 months ago
Pilot had been reporting things like that for years but nobody would believe them because they weren't "trained observers", until a pilot caught it on film in the 80's.

Same with sailors, who've been repairing rogue waves for centuries, but it wasn't until it was recorded scientifically on an oil rig that scientists took it seriously.

Still an awesome picture.

dkga · 6 months ago
In 1995 or 1997, can't remember which, I flew from Belo Horizonte to Miami (if the former) or NYC (latter). When we were flying over what I think is the Caribbean, I recall seeing "upward lightnings". They were absolutely majestic. I was absolutely awaken. I don't remember much else as I was a kid but seeing this text made me come back to this beautiful memory.
jacquesm · 6 months ago
Upward lightnings happen frequently enough, there is a guy called Tom Warner that has done pretty extensive research into this including high speed photography.
roughly · 6 months ago
My favorite variant of that kind of story: https://blog.nature.org/2018/01/12/australian-firehawk-rapto...
zamadatix · 6 months ago
As Adam Savage famously said (though I'm sure he was far from the first):

  "Remember kids, the only difference between screwing around and science is writing it down."
The quote is a bit of an oversimplification, i.e. "writing it down" isn't all there is to the scientific method, but the core idea something wasn't science until the scientific method was applied is both a tautology and a good thing.

soupfordummies · 6 months ago
I saw something weird on a red-eye recently that maybe someone can explain:

We were going over a pretty rural area. I saw what looked like the fan of headlights but in these large marbleized shapes like large lightning-crackles. They just sort of moved across the ground and then fizzled out. The movement patterns would be kind of like clouds dissipating but it definitely looked like lights? Very weird.

bufbupa · 6 months ago
Something like ball lightning? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_lightning
moi2388 · 6 months ago
You have a small typo: repairing instead of reporting
N2yhWNXQN3k9 · 6 months ago
wfme · 6 months ago
> In ensuing decades, high altitude electrical discharges were reported by aircraft pilots and discounted by meteorologists until the first direct visual evidence was documented in 1989.

From your link.

jfjfitttjtmt · 6 months ago
I feel you are undermining the Science!

Just because some common folks think they seen something, it does not mean it exists! It was probanly gas leak explosion, or something!

zoeysmithe · 6 months ago
Classism in higher education, science, etc is sadly all too common. Even those in the 'correct' class have uphill battles as science very much is vulnerable to ego, politics, etc and reform can be difficult, or in some cases impossible, regardless of merit.

It makes you wonder what obvious thing is being ignored right now due to these politics. I would not be 100% surprised if people in the future accepted things like 'ghost experiences' as normal things. There's just way too many stories and experiences to entirely write it off, but who knows. I feel like hand wavey excuses like third-man, carbon monoxide suddenly everywhere, thought experiments about brains releasing chemicals, calling everything a hallucination, intuition impossible to know conventionally just called luck, etc is the system trying hard to deny this.

N2yhWNXQN3k9 · 6 months ago
> It makes you wonder what obvious thing is being ignored right now

Not really, 40% of the US believes they were created (or are descendant of) by a divine being (creationism), in spite of all evidence, so pass that hurdle first

> I would not be 100% surprised if people in the future accepted things like 'ghost experiences' as normal things.

Like 20%-66% of the US believes this today? No one is experiencing the reality you are, ever, something to keep in mind, IMO.

joules77 · 6 months ago
Reminds me. On a Greyhound cross country trip, I got seated next to this pretty, well dressed, middle aged lady, that poor college student me, hardly ever saw on such trips. We start chatting and she tells me she is a Ghost Hunter. I took her at face value due previous experiences with real freaky characters on Greyhound, and was thinking oh great here we go again, thank you Greyhound, going to be stuck for hours next to another very strange kook. That kind of put me off further conversation. Then she starts taking out her papers to read, and says - want to see something weird? Shows me all sorts of stuff about different haunted houses. And I was just blown away by how well organized and detailed everything was. Later on she told me she was a PI doing investigations for real estate companies. But for a while it felt like I was sitting next to Scully reading X-Files.
graemep · 6 months ago
> I would not be 100% surprised if people in the future accepted things like 'ghost experiences' as normal things.

Even if the experiences becomes accepted (although i think it unlikely) but not necessarily as really being what people who believe in ghosts think them to be.

it is quite common for things to turn out to be real observations but not to be what the observers thought they were (e.g. flying saucers).

arethuza · 6 months ago
"Science advances one funeral at a time.”

Max Planck

stavros · 6 months ago
If people in the "correct" class are having trouble, that means it's not entirely classism. Only the additional trouble the people in the "wrong" class have is because of classism.
tim333 · 6 months ago
Dunno if it's classism so much that if you look at reports of odd waves or lights it's going to be really hard to filter the signal from the noise of people saying odd stuff. Photos are much better.
ericwood · 6 months ago
All of this and the only image linked is a collage clocking in at a whopping 512x218px...anyone know where we can see the full resolution? It looks spectacular from the thumbnail!
diggernet · 6 months ago
the_arun · 6 months ago
These are cool too, but sprites over himalayas - https://x.com/DarshanRajguru5/status/1940829392269463943
benjiro · 6 months ago
What amazes me more then the jet, is the amount of light pollution from the cities.
NKosmatos · 6 months ago
Looks like a scene from a sci-fi movie, where earth is being attacked ;-)
arghnoname · 6 months ago
Thanks, that's a much better photo. You can really see the effects of light pollution well in that one too.
jgord · 6 months ago
that is spectacular .. thx for link.
zoeysmithe · 6 months ago
Imagine, say, Yuri Gagarin seeing this and coming down to explain this in 1961. The ISS is only 50 miles higher than Gagarin's flight.
amelius · 6 months ago
Looks like the PR team didn't care much about the whole thing.
NoSalt · 6 months ago
What is that, an image for ants???

I absolutely cannot stand it when a site, especially a government site, doesn't post the original, high resolution, images. However, it seems like it's an archeological expedition to find the high resolution, high quality image.

frereubu · 6 months ago
js2 · 6 months ago
bilekas · 6 months ago
Thank you, I don't think it's too unreasonable when talking about an amazing image to link to the image in the article to be fair.
araes · 6 months ago
From lfaw explanation linked below: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44939514

"The phenomenon took place at roughly 29°N 101.5°W over Coahuila, Mexico." That's ~50 miles from the Ciudad Acuña / Del Rio border crossing with Texas.

th0ma5 · 6 months ago
Surely X isn't the sole source for this?
waltwalther · 6 months ago
Thank you!
porphyra · 6 months ago
Also all the social media links are wrong lol. I clicked on the instagram link to "nasascience" expecting to find a higher quality photo and it turned out to be some random Turkish dude with 3 posts and 1 follower.
userbinator · 6 months ago
Took me a bit of time to realise this wasn't about spotting a plane from the ISS... which is apparently possible but difficult:

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-3243916/Can-...

rehevkor5 · 6 months ago
+1 thought they had caught an image of a Spirit airlines plane...
lfaw · 6 months ago
1970-01-01 · 6 months ago
That title made me think someone snapped a picture of something like a Spirit A320 cruising at max altitude. They are bright yellow and would stand out in a photo.
mkl · 6 months ago
Some discussion in a thread about a topically related article a few weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44480363