Readit News logoReadit News
Zigurd · a month ago
Red Bull athletes list: https://www.redbull.com/us-en/athletes

The dead ones appear to have been removed from the list, and from all other mentions on the website. Quickly, too. Somebody's got that in their job description.

I no longer find it entertaining to watch sports where there is such a high risk of death, or lifelong impairment, from brain injuries, for example. I used to love ski movies. But too many of the people in the credits are dead now.

Apart from things like unconscionable contracts, I wouldn't restrain people from extreme sports. I'm sure a lot of of them die in their beds. I just don't find it entertaining to watch.

Waterluvian · a month ago
I feel that Penn explained this incredibly well in one of my favourite magic tricks:

https://youtu.be/Jko5BGhc-Ys?si=Uz6jvQ5voEYAxg8W

We have such a weird relationship with the spectacle of risk. As he says, a tightrope act is just as difficult at any height. The only need to make it dangerous is because the audience wants the circus.

And I think somewhat implicit in the point he’s making is that he believes that while the audience wants the spectacle, the performers have a responsibility not to give it to them.

xanderlewis · a month ago
> a tightrope act is just as difficult at any height

Well, sort of. But surely part of the feat is overcoming the natural fear of heights.

mtalantikite · a month ago
This reminded me of an old Dave Chappelle joke about the Siegfried & Roy tiger show (around 1:10 min mark): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kth0UOU5a_M

Deleted Comment

Aeolun · a month ago
Personally I much prefer watching a tightrope act when I’m not constantly worried about the performers dying.
watwut · a month ago
> As he says, a tightrope act is just as difficult at any height. The only need to make it dangerous is because the audience wants the circus.

Tho, only a few of the people who engage in these dangerous sports are famous or earn money on that. As in, if you look at those sports, there are always people who seek the danger and possible self destruction. They do it, because they want to do them. Not because of the audience.

Deleted Comment

Dead Comment

gdbsjjdn · a month ago
There's a level of economic coercion involved though as well - "going pro" is only possible by pushing for riskier and riskier stunts. If you want to get paid to ski, skateboard, etc you need to be doing increasingly extreme things to risk your own health and safety. The companies do lots of risk mitigation once you're filming a TV spot, but to get to that level you already had to be putting your body on the line for years.
perilunar · a month ago
The ethical thing is to refuse to be complicit by refusing to watch.
ProAm · a month ago
Everyone knows the risk. Especially if you get to the level of Redbull Athlete. We all accept it. We'd rather live a full life doing what we want vs the inverse. You dont have to support it but don't demean the people that choose that path. Everyone is the manifest of their own destiny. These folks are stewards of the sports and the potential that is there.
stef25 · a month ago
> We'd rather live a full life doing what we want vs the inverse

Except these people have families that care about them, you could even say kids need a parent in their life.

The day Honnold falls to his death the world will applaud all his achievements but his kid probably wish his dad never climbed at all.

The day I became a father is the day I stopped riding a motorbike.

Zigurd · a month ago
Money affects these decisions. Same as it does for prostitutes. Regulate accordingly.
chistev · a month ago
Does MMA or boxing count to you? They are violent sports with risk of brain damage.
Zigurd · a month ago
Boxing should be illegal. There are fighting arts that don't include full contact much less knocking your opponent out or otherwise damaging them, often leaving residual permanent damage. I've never found boxing entertaining at all.
herbst · a month ago
Risk? Are there are known professional fighters without brain damage at the end of their carrier?

Afaik not even bob-racers have that luxury

Deleted Comment

fuzzythinker · a month ago
Slightly misleading title. He's famous for first to jump from the stratosphere, breaking the sound barrier. That wasn't the cause of his death. More on him https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Felix_Baumgartner .

Maybe a more interesting and impressive fact from the wiki is learning about Alan Eustace, who was a senior VP of engineering at Google. Just before retiring, on October 24, 2014 *at age 57*, he made a free-fall jump from the stratosphere, breaking Felix Baumgartner's world record. He won the Laureus World Action Sportsperson of the Year in 2015.

Graziano_M · a month ago
At the Air & Space Museum in DC there's a little exhibit for each of them right across from each other.
fuzzythinker · a month ago
Found HN post (236 comments) on Alan Eustace breaking the record: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8504931
ProAm · a month ago
He only did it once he knew it was possible. And different mechanism (that most people wont understand). While yes he beat the record. Felix did it first.
ProAm · a month ago
He is a legend in the sport. He deserves that title.
lordnacho · a month ago
If you die on your first parachute jump, you're unlucky.

If you live your entire life doing these "small chance each time" stunts, maybe we should not be so surprised that your eventual demise was this kind of thing.

Was an interesting character, RIP.

Simon_O_Rourke · a month ago
There's a concept I read about before called micromorts, where activities are given a danger rating something like the expected number of fatalities per million events.

So riding a motorbike 100 miles is 8 micromorts.

Hang-gliding is 9 micromorts.

Base jumping is 430 micromorts.

And summiting Everest is 37,000 micromorts.

Incidentally, of those - I know of two guys who died either on Everest or at base camp there over the past 15 years. First guy fell on the descent, and the second guy developed health issues at altitude (apparently related to an Israeli team immediately prior stealing their oxygen bottles).

d_e_solomon · a month ago
I try to calibrate risk based on the likelihood of dying during my commute. I'm glad that there is a more standardized scale!
vladgur · a month ago
A lot more than 2 people die on Everest per year according to Wikipedia and I’m sure oxygen bottle theft plays a role but I haven’t read anything attributing deaths to “Israeli team stealing oxygen bottles”.

Mind sharing where you got these news from?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_who_died_climbi...

hhmc · a month ago
I feel like you want some higher moments on these. At least the standard deviation would be useful on top of the expectation.
bubblyworld · a month ago
Wild, is that really accurate for base jumping? I've met a number of base jumpers (there's some overlap with the climbing community where I live) and several of them have subsequently died jumping. I guess they probably jump a lot more than I think?
perilunar · a month ago
> summiting Everest is 37,000 micromorts

That's only 3.7 % — I imagined it was higher.

Does the death rate of 'summiting' include those who die before they reach the top? or those that abandon an attempt and survive?

Dead Comment

gdiamos · a month ago
probability is memoryless.

If you have been base jumping for 20 years, you have the same risk on your next jump as someone trying it for the first time.

kylecazar · a month ago
Definitely a true statement, but reports are saying he was already unconscious as he fell, so some open questions remain
ngruhn · a month ago
Well if "unconscious" happens to you in a restaurant you don't fall out of the sky.
Simon_O_Rourke · a month ago
Not that I doubt the reports, but how could anyone possibly make that call?
lazyant · a month ago
also with time they get more cocky? While new drivers have a higher crash rate in their first year of driving, the fatality rate is actually highest in their second year, not their first.
jboggan · a month ago
My 4-year-old daughter asks to watch his Red Bull Stratos jump almost every night before bed. She's obsessed with space because of him and says "Felix is my favorite astronaut." May he continue to inspire.
laurent_du · a month ago
My son was literally asking me about him yesterday. Wonder how many kids think about him every day.
jjcob · a month ago
Austrian newspaper Der Standard [1] is reporting that he was using a camera attached with a string, and authorities are considering the possiblity that it got caught in the propellor, leading to a collapse of the parachute.

Allegedly he tried to open the emergency chute, but was already too low.

[1]: https://www.derstandard.at/story/3000000280134/justiz-in-ita...

MarkMarine · a month ago
I’m the a moon’s distance away from a being a pro athlete or pushing any adventure sports field I participate in, but I do things for fun that some people think are insanely dangerous. I’ve toned it back now that I have kids (which changed my thinking) but for a long time I would have been quite happy with that exit from life. Doing something I loved, never put through indignity of advanced age, dying quickly and without suffering.

God speed Felix

tetris11 · a month ago
I used to walk across pitched roofs 3-floors up as a teen, and squeeze between cars and busses on my bike in narrow london roads (back before bike lanes were a thing) to the point that I would routinely get to my job with bloodied knuckles.

At the time I was clearly just vibing off the adrenaline, but looking back on it all as mature adult... I get heart palpatations.

There are many parallel worlds where I am not alive, and I think of those other selves often.

Aeolun · a month ago
I feel like humans must be naturally better at surviving these things when young. I see kids doing this stuff every day. Not walking on pitched roofs, but plenty of other stuff that could get them killed if something goes wrong.
usrusr · a month ago
My risk habits have a rather low chance of dying per injury event, but life changing injury isn't all that rare. I do occasionally see myself envying those with a risk profile that's more on the binary end of the spectrum: where it's either a clean end or everything is fine.
gsf_emergency_2 · a month ago
>Illness

Unreviewed translation of "Unwohlseins"

Other media hint at seizure/cardiac arrest.

pantalaimon · a month ago
"feeling unwell" would be the more direct and more correct translation
mithras · a month ago
I wouldn't agree, it's a big step beyond just feeling unwell. With this word I would think someone might need medical assistance.
eviks · a month ago
Thanks, also got confused by this