Readit News logoReadit News
addcommitpush · 3 years ago
I have some doubts about the data: the government of France has supposedly 1 repos, but for instance the French Statistics Office has 244 repos [0], the "digital" team of the Prime Minister's services has at least 537 repos, and that's what's on top of my head.

[0] https://github.com/orgs/InseeFrLab/repositories + https://github.com/orgs/InseeFr/repositories

[1] https://github.com/orgs/etalab/repositories + https://github.com/betagouv

danthelion · 3 years ago
Thanks for flagging this! These were missing from the initial dataset I used as a starting point, but I can easily extend it myself.
starefossen · 3 years ago
Here is a better list of Norwegian government agencies on GitHub https://github.com/MikAoJk/norwegian-public-organizations/tr...
addcommitpush · 3 years ago
Surely there are many more that are not present in the data set. How do you plan to find them?
tuukkah · 3 years ago
Something broken in the source data, if I compare the organisations with the list that GitHub has crowdsourced: https://github.com/github/government.github.com/blob/gh-page...
stuaxo · 3 years ago
Yep, the amount of UK gov organisations seems very small compared to this list.
prepend · 3 years ago
I don’t think open issues is a very useful metric because an open issue may stick around for 10 years and just stay low priority. So number of open issues doesn’t really mean much. Maybe instead show issue velocity of how many created+closed each period to show activity. Or show commits.
yieldcrv · 3 years ago
they're all useless vanity metrics that cannot offer any comparison to another organization or project

software that is complete also fails every vanity metric

prepend · 3 years ago
It depends on what you’re measuring.

If you just want to see if a project is active then commits is useful.

If you want to see if there are multiple committers, then active people is useful.

I don’t think you should compare repos based on this metric, but knowing if a repo is active or not is something.

danthelion · 3 years ago
Yeah, I definitely agree, more sophisticated metrics are in the pipeline. Wanted to get an MVP out as quickly as possible.
nonameiguess · 3 years ago
No explanation of where this data is coming from or how it's being labeled? Your top table on the right hand side shows seven "countries" but only one of the names in there is actually the name of a country (Norway).

It looks like you're just taking the top-level headers from that "who's using Github" page? Civic Hacker is one of those and is showing up as a "country" in your dataset, but clearly isn't. Looking at the first few tiles, it includes at least a few US cities, some US states, and Romania.

danthelion · 3 years ago
I can see how the "Country" name was confusing; thank you. Renamed it to "Government" for a bit more clarity.
stuaxo · 3 years ago
It's a bit overarching. Central gov is different to stuff that happens in regions. In the croudsourced list for these on GitHub the UK has UK Central Government and UK Councils, things are probably different for the say the ministry of justice Vs some small town.
srvmshr · 3 years ago
I don't quite understand what this dashboard is aiming at. What is the target objective: government participation on FOSS, being mentioned, projects being funded or something else?
danthelion · 3 years ago
I created a dashboard to monitor government activity on GitHub
taubek · 3 years ago
What is the source of your data? How do you define "government activity on GitHub"? Do you look at domain used in contact, affiliation, etc.?
danthelion · 3 years ago
This GitHub page was the starting point: https://government.github.com/community
stuaxo · 3 years ago
What's the aim ?
lotsoweiners · 3 years ago
As a state government employee I don’t understand what the purpose of this is. For example, my organization has hundreds of repositories but they are all hosted internally on TFS. We have zero repositories on GitHub. Is the goal to show what government code looks like, get community help for the code, accountability, showing your tax dollars at work, something else?
starefossen · 3 years ago
Great, but most of the Norwegian governments are missing. Here is a more up to date list https://github.com/MikAoJk/norwegian-public-organizations/tr...