Readit News logoReadit News

Loading parent story...

Loading comment...

xupybd commented on Gut bacteria from amphibians and reptiles achieve tumor elimination in mice   jaist.ac.jp/english/whats... · Posted by u/Xunxi
brailsafe · a day ago
> I'm not against AI summaries being on HN, however, users should verify and cite sources so others can verify.

I don't see how they contribute anything to a discussion. Even a speculative comment organically produced is more worthwhile than feeding a slop machine back into itself. I don't go out for coffee to discuss LLM summaries with friends, and I can't imagine why anyone would want to do that here.

Earlier today I asked Gemini Pro to find information on a person's death that was turning up nothing for me otherwise, and it just imagined finding verbatim Obituary quotes in every source, cobbled together vaguely related names, plausible bits and pieces from wherever, almost like it was 2023 again.

It ain't search, and it ain't worthwhile; I'd much rather someone ask an llm the question and then post a question out of curiosity based on it, but without the summary itself

xupybd · a day ago
It is search if you ask it to produce a list of links.

It does well at filtering information for you.

Going to primary sources is required to verify what it says but it can reduce the leg work rather a lot.

Loading parent story...

Loading comment...

Deleted Comment

xupybd commented on Cancer is surging, bringing a debate about whether to look for it   nytimes.com/2025/12/08/he... · Posted by u/brandonb
kulahan · 10 days ago
There is cancer in your body every single day. Your immune system handles it just fine. There is an explicit difference between cancer that needs treating and cancer that should be ignored because it's a waste of time and resources to treat. You're not a doctor, you're not qualified to tell the difference, you're not trained on cancers, you're not even in the medical field. The monopoly is held for exactly this reason.

We already have an extreme shortage of available healthcare workers. We don't need to stress them further because 20% of the population suddenly decides they need 80 elective surgeries to remove things that would've gone away or stayed benign on their own.

xupybd · 10 days ago
People have a right to make their own medical choices. Saying on people with the correct credentials should have input is offensive.
xupybd commented on I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon   blog.joinmastodon.org/202... · Posted by u/Tomte
xupybd · a month ago
"The fediverse is an island within an increasingly dystopian capitalist hellscape."

This seems like an extreme view to me. It's not so bad

Deleted Comment

xupybd commented on Vacuum bricked after user blocks data collection – user mods it to run anyway   tomshardware.com/tech-ind... · Posted by u/toomanyrichies
charcircuit · a month ago
I suspect this is not the full story. Why would someone waste their time manually disabling a device? That makes me think that this device was doing something malicous to their servers, enough to trip an alert.
xupybd · a month ago
Not really. They probably flagged this as someone modifying the device and thought it could be someone reverse engineering it.
xupybd commented on The longest baseball game took 33 innings to win   mlb.com/news/the-longest-... · Posted by u/mooreds
xupybd · 2 months ago
A test cricket match can last for up to five days and is the longest format of the game, with each team having two innings. Each day consists of about 90 overs and typically lasts for 6-7 hours, including lunch and tea breaks.

Deleted Comment

u/xupybd

KarmaCake day9495July 22, 2013View Original