Readit News logoReadit News
woliveirajr commented on A non-anthropomorphized view of LLMs   addxorrol.blogspot.com/20... · Posted by u/zdw
Al-Khwarizmi · 2 months ago
I have the technical knowledge to know how LLMs work, but I still find it pointless to not anthropomorphize, at least to an extent.

The language of "generator that stochastically produces the next word" is just not very useful when you're talking about, e.g., an LLM that is answering complex world modeling questions or generating a creative story. It's at the wrong level of abstraction, just as if you were discussing an UI events API and you were talking about zeros and ones, or voltages in transistors. Technically fine but totally useless to reach any conclusion about the high-level system.

We need a higher abstraction level to talk about higher level phenomena in LLMs as well, and the problem is that we have no idea what happens internally at those higher abstraction levels. So, considering that LLMs somehow imitate humans (at least in terms of output), anthropomorphization is the best abstraction we have, hence people naturally resort to it when discussing what LLMs can do.

woliveirajr · 2 months ago
I'd take it in reverse order: the problem isn't that it's possible to have a computer that "stochastically produces the next word" and can fool humans, it's why / how / when humans evolved to have technological complexity when the majority (of people) aren't that different from a stochastic process.
woliveirajr commented on How AI on Microcontrollers Works: Operators and Kernels   danielmangum.com/posts/ai... · Posted by u/hasheddan
Neywiny · 2 months ago
In the same way "embedded" is relative, I appreciate the author's recognition that "edge" is relative. For some, AI at the edge means on-prem server farms. For some it means a mini-pc. For others, maybe an SBC. Here it's a microcontroller. Further still is AI within the sensors a microcontroller would talk to. That's probably just another microcontroller but still.
woliveirajr · 2 months ago
Microcontrollers all the way down
woliveirajr commented on Glucagon-Like Peptide-1 Receptor Agonists and Risk of Macular Degeneration   jamanetwork.com/journals/... · Posted by u/baby-yoda
woliveirajr · 3 months ago
139,000 patients, hazard went from 0.1 to 0.2%. It means that 139 new patients developed Macular Degeneration during 3 years. I would really consider the benefits of GLP-1 versus health gains to diabetic patients (specially regarding quality of life with macular degeneration)
woliveirajr commented on OpenAI slams court order to save all ChatGPT logs, including deleted chats   arstechnica.com/tech-poli... · Posted by u/ColinWright
Wowfunhappy · 3 months ago
> And wrapper-around-ChatGPT startups should double-check their privacy policies, that all the "you have no privacy" language is in place.

If a court orders you to preserve user data, could you be held liable for preserving user data? Regardless of your privacy policy.

woliveirajr · 3 months ago
Yes. If your agreement with the end user says that you won't collect and store data, you're responsible for it. If you can't provide it (even if due to a court order), you have to adjust your contract.

Your users aren't obligated to know that you're using open ai or other provider.

woliveirajr commented on The year I didn't survive   bessstillman.substack.com... · Posted by u/LaurenSerino
tombert · 7 months ago
It's weird how a series of big things happening in a short period of time changes who you are as a person, and not always for the better.

When I failed to stop an acquaintance from killing himself a few years ago [1], it really fucked me up. I barely knew the guy, but I couldn't stop myself from feeling guilty over it, and I still have nightmares about it.

It led to a severe funk of depression that I still haven't gotten over, and it's led to poor sleep, poor performance at work, an increased irritability towards pretty much everyone, and I'm not completely convinced that that will ever stop.

I've seen therapists, taken various medications for depression and PTSD, trauma dumped onto pretty much anyone who will listen, and I think I'm a worse person now than I was in 2021.

I guess the likelihood of an event like this happening approaches 1 as you get older, but it doesn't mean it's not terrible.

[1] Written in some detail here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29185822

woliveirajr · 7 months ago
> not always for the better

Things happen and you adapt to survive it. And survival mode isn't made to make you happy, to become more generous or to expect more loyalty. And once your worldview changes for a pessimistic one, it'll taint everything around you (especially the new interactions with people)

Yes, some people change to be better: and that means (and I say it painfully) that many of them were the ones that caused unnecessary pain in others.

Some reference: https://www.hss.edu/conditions_emotional-impact-pain-experie...

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/341577702_Lacan_on_...

https://europepmc.org/article/med/33126037

woliveirajr commented on Boring tech is mature, not old   rubenerd.com/boring-tech-... · Posted by u/mikece
steveBK123 · 7 months ago
My favorite genre of this is the guys proposing Greenfield rewrites of a multi-decade old app, using some tech less than 1 year old.

Turns out brand new stuff doesn't always survive, and even if it does you don't know its tradeoffs & pain points yet.

Everything is perfect & bug-free when it has no product use.

Seen it many times, and seen the wreckage later.

woliveirajr · 7 months ago
Remembers me of https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/04/06/things-you-should-... : "All new source code! As if source code rusted."
woliveirajr commented on Dexterity assessment of hospital workers: prospective comparative study   bmj.com/content/387/bmj-2... · Posted by u/bkudria
woliveirajr · 8 months ago
> Implementation of a surgical swear jar initiative

Yes, the main goal of a surgical site is to avoid swearing

> our findings are not applicable to children younger than 4 years for whom the buzz wire game’s small parts may represent a choking hazard, although these individuals are unlikely to be currently employed in secondary care.

Now, that's a point. I'd avoid a 0-3 toddler if i could choose so before some surgery.

woliveirajr commented on Masks, Smoke, and Mirrors: The story of EgyptAir flight 804   admiralcloudberg.medium.c... · Posted by u/gdmt
eadmund · 8 months ago
Why is it surprising? There’s no danger from smoking on-board; banning it was never about safety.
woliveirajr · 8 months ago

u/woliveirajr

KarmaCake day4096January 26, 2015View Original