Readit News logoReadit News
ColinWright commented on Tao: An experiment reviving an archaic practice from the era of Gauss   mathstodon.xyz/@tao/11602... · Posted by u/ColinWright
ColinWright · 2 days ago
This is a fascinating experiment! I've just been reading the first few paragraphs of the paper ... easily readable, intended to be accessible by anyone.

In Gauss's time mathematicians would solve problems, publish the solutions in an encrypted form, and then challenge their contemporaries to solve the problems.

Here the authors of a paper on the arXiv say:

"To assess the ability of current AI systems to correctly answer research-level mathematics questions, we share a set of ten math questions which have arisen naturally in the research process of the authors. The questions had not been shared publicly until now; the answers are known to the authors of the questions but will remain encrypted for a short time."

Tao says:

"... the challenge is to see whether 10 research-level problems (that arose in the course of the authors research) are amenable to modern AI tools within a fixed time period (until Feb 13).

"The problems appear to be out of reach of current "one-shot" AI prompts, but were solved by human domain experts, and would presumably a fair fraction would also be solvable by other domain experts equipped with AI tools. They are technical enough that a non-domain-expert would struggle to verify any AI-generated output on these problems, so it seems quite challenging to me to have such a non-expert solve any of these problems, but one could always be surprised."

ColinWright commented on Ask HN: Is there anyone here who still uses slide rules?    · Posted by u/blenderob
philipwhiuk · 4 days ago
Does it implement Duckworth-Lewis-Stern ;)
ColinWright · 4 days ago
No, but a friend of mine made a nomogram to do that.
ColinWright commented on Ask HN: Is there anyone here who still uses slide rules?    · Posted by u/blenderob
ColinWright · 4 days ago
A slide rule is casually used by the General in "Fantastic Voyage"
ColinWright commented on Ask HN: Is there anyone here who still uses slide rules?    · Posted by u/blenderob
ColinWright · 4 days ago
Funny you ask ... I lieterally just now pulled out one of my slide rules to keep track of the required run rate for a cricket T20 game.

Fastest and best feedback for whether the batting team is ahead of the rate.

u/ColinWright

KarmaCake day133784December 14, 2009
About
If you want to contact me, find me on the web. I am especially interested in math, juggling, programming, and education, and since there are other people with my name you'll probably need to include at least one of those terms in any search.

I was once a prolific contributor and commenter, but no more. I go through bouts of submitting stuff, but then go and disappear for lengths of time. If there is something you'd like me to see or comment on, you can email me. Don't ask me to upvote things. If it is interesting (to me) then I will.

Submissions do not imply endorsement.

My spam filtering is pretty severe, but I've put the word "Dysprosium" on the allow-list - quote that and your email will get through.

I used to have an email here but it got harvested by spammers - I'm looking at you, mbientlab.com - so it has been removed. This is a temporary one:

HN_a7dab8S4@solipsys.co.uk

Email sent there and quoting the element name will pass my spam filters. After that we can use "proper" email addresses.

View Original