Readit News logoReadit News
umutisik commented on Deep Learning Is Applied Topology   theahura.substack.com/p/d... · Posted by u/theahura
theahura · 4 months ago
I say this as someone who has been in deep learning for over a decade now: this is pretty wrong, both on the merits (data obviously lives on a manifold) and on its applications to deep learning (cf chris olah's blog as an example from 2014, which is linked in my post -- https://colah.github.io/posts/2014-03-NN-Manifolds-Topology/). Embedding spaces are called 'spaces' for a reason. GANs, VAEs, contrastive losses -- all of these are about constructing vector manifolds that you can 'walk' to produce different kinds of data.
umutisik · 4 months ago
If data did live on a manifold contained, e.g. images in R^{n^2}, then it wouldn't have thickness or branching, which it does. It's an imperfect approximation to help think about it. The use of mathematical language is not the same as an application of mathematics (and the use of the word 'space' there is not about topology).
umutisik commented on Deep Learning Is Applied Topology   theahura.substack.com/p/d... · Posted by u/theahura
umutisik · 4 months ago
Data doesn't actually live on a manifold. It's an approximation used for thinking about data. Near total majority, if not 100%, of the useful things done in deep learning have come from not thinking about topology in any way. Deep learning is not applied anything, it's an empirical field advanced mostly by trial and error and, sure, a few intuitions coming from theory (that was not topology).
umutisik commented on Data centers contain 90% crap data   gerrymcgovern.com/data-ce... · Posted by u/billybuckwheat
umutisik · 5 months ago
Make the cost of operating data centers reflect the damage to the environment and see how quickly people optimize. I don’t know how damaging storage is, but that’s the only way to make a difference.
umutisik commented on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (April 2025)    · Posted by u/whoishiring
umutisik · 5 months ago
Incept AI | Remote (US) | Full-time | Software Engineers and Deep Learning Scientists | https://www.incept.ai

Incept AI is solving the last mile problem in Voice AI. Our team of PhD applied scientists and software engineers builds neural audio processing systems, audio-processing foundation models, and agentic AI workflows that make Voice AI reliable and truly useful in the real world.

Our first application is the lucrative drive-thru and phone automation market for restaurants. We have built the most accurate order-taking restaurant Voice AI assistant in the world, and are working with major restaurant chains to help elevate their customer service while providing major automation-led savings.

We are well-funded are looking to grow our team with Software Engineers (generalists or back-end, previous work experience required) and Applied Scientists (PhD in a technical field like CS, Math, Physics, ... or equivalent deep learning experience required).

https://www.incept.ai/careers

umutisik commented on I'm Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA    · Posted by u/proberts
umutisik · 6 months ago
When considering a candidate on an F-1 + OPT, what should be our expectation of their need for H1B sponsorship? What are O-1 and National Interest Waiver success rates for recent PhD grads (in computer science)?
umutisik commented on The cultural divide between mathematics and AI   sugaku.net/content/unders... · Posted by u/rfurmani
umutisik · 6 months ago
If AI can prove major theorems, it will likely by employing similar heuristics as the mathematical community employs when searching for proofs and understanding. Studying AI-generated proofs, with the help of AI to decipher contents will help humans build that 'understanding' if that is desired.

An issue in these discussions is that mathematics is both an art, a sport, and a science. And the development of AI that can build 'useful' libraries of proven theorems means different things for each. The sport of mathematics will be basically over. The art of mathematics will thrive as it becomes easier to explore the mathematical world. For the science of mathematics, it's hard to say, it's been kind of shaky for ~50 years anyway, but it can only help.

umutisik commented on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (March 2025)    · Posted by u/whoishiring
umutisik · 6 months ago
Incept AI | Remote (US) | Full-time | Software Engineers and Deep Learning Scientists | https://www.incept.ai

Incept AI is solving the last mile problem in Voice AI. Our team of PhD applied scientists and software engineers builds neural audio processing systems, audio-processing foundation models, and agentic AI workflows that make Voice AI reliable and truly useful in the real world.

Our first application is the lucrative drive-thru and phone automation market for restaurants. We have built the most accurate order-taking restaurant Voice AI assistant in the world, and are working with major restaurant chains to help elevate their customer service while providing major automation-led savings.

We are well-funded are looking to grow our team with Software Engineers (generalists or back-end, previous work experience required) and Applied Scientists (PhD in a technical field like CS, Math, Physics, ... or equivalent deep learning experience required).

https://www.incept.ai/careers

umutisik commented on Ask HN: Promoted, but Career Path Derailed    · Posted by u/golly_ned
umutisik · 7 months ago
What is going to benefit the customers the most? You staying in your specialty where things are already in good shape, or you improving the area where the company has been underperforming? Perhaps, if the latter is better for the customers, you can find the motivation in yourself to seize the opportunity to deliver there.
umutisik commented on Calm tech certification "rewards" less distracting tech   spectrum.ieee.org/calm-te... · Posted by u/headalgorithm
umutisik · 8 months ago
Tablets and phones could be calm tech too if they adjusted their brightness and white-point correctly based on ambient lighting.
umutisik commented on Procrastination and the fear of not being good enough   swapnilchauhan.com/blog/p... · Posted by u/swapxstar
umutisik · 10 months ago
Great observation. I have observed the same thing in my own life.

The solution: do things that you really believe people need. Then you owe it to them to find out if you actually are “good enough”, and you don’t care what others think because all you care about is whether the people who need it are happy with it.

u/umutisik

KarmaCake day393August 29, 2013View Original