Readit News logoReadit News
singpolyma3 commented on Discord Alternatives, Ranked   taggart-tech.com/discord-... · Posted by u/pseudalopex
palata · a day ago
How would devs not have to know about them? Say I want to write an XMPP-enabled app, how do I do it? Are there XMPP libraries that already implement all the required need protocols?
singpolyma3 · 15 hours ago
Yes. I work on one of them https://borogove.dev but there are a few others as well
singpolyma3 commented on Discord Alternatives, Ranked   taggart-tech.com/discord-... · Posted by u/pseudalopex
MarsIronPI · 2 days ago
This is what I mean by "it needs a good client". It needs a single implementation that works consistently across platforms and has the features and UX people care about. The groundwork is there, and is better than Matrix. It's a matter of writing software to implement the useful subset of the specs.
singpolyma3 · a day ago
Working on it
singpolyma3 commented on Discord Alternatives, Ranked   taggart-tech.com/discord-... · Posted by u/pseudalopex
aaravchen · 2 days ago
I don't disagree, but whether you're even aware of the XEPs and how it's presented to the user, is a critical factor in viewing it as "confusing". Gaim for example only even tells you about XEPs if you dig into the server settings, and then it shows a very good job of listing all XEPs from either the server or client and noting which are supported by each in a table if you're far enough down the rabbithole that this info is useful. But for a regular user they just log in and it Just Works (tm).
singpolyma3 · a day ago
Yes I agree, apps should never mentioned XEPs. Most devs have no reason to even know about them, why would a user case? Some apps are built by protocol nerds and they like seeing the list. Maybe very hidden is ok but in general not something any user cares about.
singpolyma3 commented on Discord Alternatives, Ranked   taggart-tech.com/discord-... · Posted by u/pseudalopex
aaravchen · 2 days ago
XMPP has had less allure as "the new thing" since it's been around for a very long time. It was _the_ chat protocol in the 2000s when it started, and all chat apps used it (when AOL Instant Messenger, Trilian, Purple, Yahoo, ICQ, etc all interoperated). Vendor lock in started taking off not long after though, so Facebook Messenger (also originally XMPP) stopped interoperating and went fully closed along with a number of others, and the ones that interoperated didn't shift business models and disappeared. None of that means there's anything wrong with XMPP, it just means it's not in the public mind.

IRC has been getting the retro nostalgia kick start, and it briefly came back to attention when Slack started as "wrapper" of IRC. In my experience IRC channels are used by about 50% of open source projects, even though it's abysmal for access on mobile devices, very unfriendly for users, and extremely limited in functionality. About 50% of those have a bridge to Matrix so the mobile access is at least somewhat solved, and there are some more usable client options.

It seems because you haven't seen people already adopt it, you believe it must not be good. I'd encourage some basic research for your own benefit so you can see how XMPP is way easier to setup and maintain, far more efficient, and more capable than the oddly more commonly used Matrix/Element. In fact, between the organization issues of the last couple years, everyone finally getting fed up with Matrix being brittle, unmaintainable, and extremely inefficient to run on a server, I would expect Matrix support channels to drop off very rapidly over the next few years.

singpolyma3 · a day ago
> when AOL Instant Messenger, Trilian, Purple, Yahoo, ICQ, etc all interoperated

Sorry to remind you, but this never happened. AIM and ICQ eventually interoperate because they were owned by the same company at that point. There was never XMPP federation in the mix here.

singpolyma3 commented on You Are Here   brooker.co.za/blog/2026/0... · Posted by u/mltvc
lbreakjai · 5 days ago
> If all you were doing is taking requirements from someone else and poorly coding them up

So, in your entire career, you've always worked in companies where you were a subject matter expert on everything the company did? Always knew the business domain inside out? You were running the numbers, sitting with customers, and determining yourself what they really wanted?

> If you push back on requirements when they are not reasonable. Etc

I did, because the requirements had a cost, which I had to balance with limited resources.

If widget A would make 10 customers happy, but would cost two weeks of work, that could be better spent making widget B that'd make 20 customers happy, then it would not be reasonable.

If widget A and B are free, then it becomes unreasonable to say no.

singpolyma3 · 5 days ago
> So, in your entire career, you've always worked in companies where you were a subject matter expert on everything the company did? Always knew the business domain inside out? You were running the numbers, sitting with customers, and determining yourself what they really wanted?

You don't have to be the only person involved in the requirements for you to be involved. So yes, I've been involved from my very first internship where I pitched a new product to the CEO in my second month on the job and got told to go make that happen.

singpolyma3 commented on You Are Here   brooker.co.za/blog/2026/0... · Posted by u/mltvc
singpolyma3 · 5 days ago
If all you were doing is taking requirements from someone else and poorly coding them up (and yes I know a decent % of the industry matches close to this) then yes you are obsolete. Something just as useless but much faster now here.

If you are part of the requirements process. If you find problems to solve and solve them. If you push back on requirements when they are not reasonable. Etc. Then you still have a career and I don't see anything coming for you soon.

singpolyma3 commented on Speed up responses with fast mode   code.claude.com/docs/en/f... · Posted by u/surprisetalk
jstummbillig · 5 days ago
> It seems unlikely it’s just prioritization

Why does this seem unlikely? I have no doubt they are optimizing all the time, including inference speed, but why could this particular lever not entirely be driven by skipping the queue? It's an easy way to generate more money.

singpolyma3 · 5 days ago
Until everyone buys it. Like fast pass at an amusement park where the fast line is still two hours long
singpolyma3 commented on Show HN: Wikipedia as a doomscrollable social media feed   xikipedia.org... · Posted by u/rebane2001
singpolyma3 · 11 days ago
Please only continue if you are an adult? You realize Wikipedia has no age restrictions right...
singpolyma3 commented on US has investigated claims WhatsApp chats aren't private   bloomberg.com/news/articl... · Posted by u/1vuio0pswjnm7
TZubiri · 12 days ago
With all due respect to Stallman, you can actually study binaries.

The claim Stallman would make (after punishing you for using Open Source instead of Free Software for an hour) is that Closed Software (Proprietary Software) is unjust. but in the context of security, the claim would be limited to Free Software being capable of being secure too.

You may be able to argue that Open Source reduces risk in threat models where the manufacturer is the attacker, but in any other threat model, security is an advantage of closed source. It's automatic obfuscation.

There's a lot of advantages to Free Software, you don't need to make up some.

singpolyma3 · 12 days ago
I was with you until you somehow claimed obfuscation can improve security, against all historical evidence even pre-computers.
singpolyma3 commented on Students using “humanizer” programs to beat accusations of cheating with AI   nbcnews.com/tech/internet... · Posted by u/unpredict
jurgenaut23 · 12 days ago
I used em dashes heavily 15 years ago when writing my PhD thesis.
singpolyma3 · 12 days ago
So did every author of classic literature. People who think they can spot AI writing by simple stylistic indicators alone are fooling themselves and hurting real human authors

u/singpolyma3

KarmaCake day788July 21, 2015View Original