Readit News logoReadit News
shivenigma commented on Why LLMs can't really build software   zed.dev/blog/why-llms-can... · Posted by u/srid
andrewmutz · 15 days ago
The author does not understand what LLMs and coding tools are capable of today.

> LLMs get endlessly confused: they assume the code they wrote actually works; when test fail, they are left guessing as to whether to fix the code or the tests; and when it gets frustrating, they just delete the whole lot and start over. This is exactly the opposite of what I am looking for. Software engineers test their work as they go. When tests fail, they can check in with their mental model to decide whether to fix the code or the tests, or just to gather more data before making a decision. When they get frustrated, they can reach for help by talking things through. And although sometimes they do delete it all and start over, they do so with a clearer understanding of the problem.

My experiences are based on using Cline with Anthropic Sonnet 3.7 doing TDD on Rails, and have a very different experience. I instruct the model to write tests before any code and it does. It works in small enough chunks that I can review each one. When tests fail, it tends to reason very well about why and fixes the appropriate place. It is very common for the LLM to consult more code as it goes to learn more.

It's certainly not perfect but it works about as well, if not better, than a human junior engineer. Sometimes it can't solve a bug, but human junior engineers get in the same situation too.

shivenigma · 12 days ago
> The author does not understand what LLMs and coding tools are capable of today.

Not really, I would say they used it well and understood the limitations of LLM exactly. No matter how much polished the output or how good it is, LLMs can't build mental models of a codebase like a human does because they are just statistical machines.

shivenigma commented on Speeding up my ZSH shell   scottspence.com/posts/spe... · Posted by u/saikatsg
hdjrudni · a month ago
I don't want to spend ages figuring out which knobs to turn to get a half decent shell. If there's an alternative to oh-my-zsh that looks halfway decent, has that nice fzf integrated, and the 'ghost text' history suggestions, then I welcome it!
shivenigma · a month ago
Have a look at Prezto, it is much simpler and faster than oh My ZSH.
shivenigma commented on OpenAI’s Windsurf deal is off, and Windsurf’s CEO is going to Google   theverge.com/openai/70599... · Posted by u/rcchen
submeta · 2 months ago
I went from Emacs to VS Code, then to Cursor, next to Claude Code, which is so good that I feel like I am having half a dozen junior devs at my fingertips, 24/7.

Since Claude Code is cli based, I reviewed my cli toolset: Migrated from iTerm2 to Ghostty and Tmux, from Cursor to NeoVim (my God is it good!).

Just had a 14h workday with this tooling. It’s so good that I complete the work of weeks and months within days! Absolutely beast.

At this point I am thinking IDEs do not reflect the changing reality of software development. They are designed for navigating project folders, writing / changing files. But I don’t review files that much anymore. I rather write prompts, watch Claude Code create a plan, implement it, even write meaningful commit messages.

Yes I can navigate the project with neovim, yes I can make commits in git and in lazygit, but my task is best spent in designing, planning, prompting, reviewing and testing.

shivenigma · 2 months ago
> But I don’t review files that much anymore.

Say no more.

shivenigma commented on Ask HN: Who wants to be hired? (January 2025)    · Posted by u/whoishiring
shivenigma · 8 months ago
Location: Chennai, India (IN)

Remote: Yes, Open to Hybrid and In-person to

Willing to relocate: Yes, depends on the offer

Technologies: Typescript, Angular, React, PHP, Laravel, Javascript, CSS, Flutter

Résumé/CV: [https://drive.google.com/file/d/1v1aK0uTlzlPCOFOvJ9SDhtA8pox...

Email: ms.vignesh31 [at] gmail [dot]com

I'm flexible with the tech stack and open to learn anything I don't know and would like to work in end to end solutions and solving technical problems.

shivenigma commented on Ask HN: Who is hiring? (January 2025)    · Posted by u/whoishiring
alpha_squared · 8 months ago
Thoughtful AI | https://thoughtful.ai | Remote (US preferred) | Multiple Engineer Roles | $140k - $250k

Thoughtful AI is a health-tech company building solutions for revenue cycle management (RCM). We're solving immediate problems in healthcare administration by speeding up payment cycles for providers and increasing accuracy in healthcare claim approvals. Something we can brag about a little is that there's so much demand for our solutions that we're throttling our sales team so our engineering can keep up. Come help us solve problems in healthcare!

Forward Deployed Engineer | $140k - $190k | https://www.thoughtful.ai/job?gh_jid=4488592005

Staff Software Engineer, Platform | $190k - $250k | https://www.thoughtful.ai/job?gh_jid=4467861005

Staff Software Engineer, Applied AI | $190k - $250k | https://www.thoughtful.ai/job?gh_jid=4470319005

We review every application.

shivenigma · 8 months ago
US preferred -> Can I apply if I'm outside of US but willing to match or overlap with US timezone?
shivenigma commented on Telegram founder Pavel Durov arrested at French airport   theguardian.com/media/art... · Posted by u/NoxiousPluK
nstart · a year ago
Even in WhatsApp which has E2EE they have reporting mechanisms so if someone starts a broadcast channel with the explicit intention of promoting illegal behaviour, it can at least be taken down by reporting. Personal experience and second hand accounts tell us that Telegram was known to mismanage these things in ways that a company of its size and impact cannot ignore.

There’s a lot of false dichotomy in the ongoing discussions here which assumes there’s a binary “control to the gov” or “freedom for all” choice. It’s a spectrum where at the most basic level, a robust process to handle reports of illegal activity should be accepted.

shivenigma · a year ago
Illegal things are going to happen mostly in physical world regardless of where they plan it. The government can catch them while they're at it or after. The governments are fear-mongering and creating a public narrative to support mass surveillance.

There are only very few illegal things that can happen within the telegram app like fraud, or minor abuse. Those must be reported by end users and individual actions can be taken against them.

What the government is asking is a massive backdoor for surveillance in the name of preventing crime, but they decide what they can monitor. It is a pandora box and if you open it there is no going back. Even if the current government is asking it with purest intentions and manage it well, the same can not be said for any next elected governments.

shivenigma commented on Thousands of subreddits pledge to go dark after the Reddit CEO’s recent remarks   theverge.com/2023/6/10/23... · Posted by u/ValentineC
satvikpendem · 2 years ago
I highly doubt anything of substance will occur after this going dark period. Remember Ellen Pao, and the firing of Victoria? There was similar drama then, and lo and behold, nothing happened, quite the opposite as Reddit's userbase increased. The average user uses new Reddit and the official app, they simply do not give a shit about any of this drama. In a year's time, most people won't care anymore.

People who use third party apps are outliers. They do not make Reddit any money so Reddit would be glad to be rid of them while also saving on API costs. No other online service allows freeloading millions upon millions of API requests in addition to allowing third party apps to a large extent. Facebook, Whatsapp, Discord, Instagram, Slack, Twitter all don't, so it's a wonder that Reddit did all this time, for free.

If subreddits go dark for 48 hours, then from the perspective of Reddit, they'd think, great, then it returns to normal. If they go dark indefinitely, Reddit admins will wait a few days then force the subs open and demod everyone involved. There is a long list of mods who are willing to contribute.

In the end, consumer boycotts like this simply don't work.

shivenigma · 2 years ago
> People who use third party apps are outliers. They do not make Reddit any money

I do agree with you. Bu the outliers usually feed the site with good content. There is a quote by Paul G (or someone)

> whatever the hackers do on the weekends, normal people will be doing regularly in 10 years.

This is a recital from memory, prone to be watered down. But the idea is that the outliers are the ones that makes it worthwhile to be in the community. If they are gone because for any reason, landed somewhere else, the normal users will eventually move away. It is not going to be visible immediately, but will have negative effects in the long run.

shivenigma commented on How to Start Your Blog in 2023   molodtsov.me/2023/02/how-... · Posted by u/ymolodtsov
shivenigma · 3 years ago
hashnode.com checks all the criteria you mentioned. Worth checking about.
shivenigma commented on Ask HN: What is the best thing you read in 2022?    · Posted by u/th33ngineer
madmax108 · 3 years ago
Book: You Are Not Expected to Understand This: How 26 Lines of Code Changed the World by Torie Bosch [1]

Came across this book randomly on Twitter and picked it up. The book is broken into 26 essays about significant pieces of code (defined vaguely), ranging from the Morris Worm to Pagerank to the popup window and the 1x1 invisible gif and how these shaped the modern tech landscape. Lovely read overall, and really shows how pieces of code you work on today can end up having long lasting impact on how society perceives technology as a whole. Best of all, it's not a heavy read, but offers a lot of concise info that can send you down wormholes of wikipedia.

Paper: Amazon DynamoDB: A Scalable, Predictably Performant, and Fully Managed NoSQL Database Service [2]

Database systems have always been a passion of mine, and the paper from AWS about how DynamoDB works internally is an incredible look into what makes a NoSQL DB platform capable of serving 89 million requests per second _(this is in the intro)_ which is incredible scale. Always good to see how engineering decisions shape products, and it's been interesting to see Dynamo take shape over the last decade _(though I recommend most folks to stay away from it because of it's mad pricing)_

[1]: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/60254955-you-are-not-exp...

[2]: https://www.usenix.org/system/files/atc22-elhemali.pdf

shivenigma · 3 years ago
the dynamo db paper was a great read. I was reading it repeatedly just for the fun of the numerous topics/choices it introduced to me.

u/shivenigma

KarmaCake day35June 19, 2020View Original