Readit News logoReadit News
rahoulb commented on The drawbridges come up: the dream of a interconnected context ecosystem is over   dbreunig.com/2025/06/16/d... · Posted by u/dbreunig
mxmilkiib · 2 months ago
for me, when both Facebook and Google rejected Jabber/XMPP federation :(

but yeah, in general, what happened to the dream of true Data Portability?

rahoulb · 2 months ago
As other posters have said - capitalism.

But also privacy - it would be amazing to just be able to connect to any app or service you want, interact and react to stuff that's happening _over there_.

However, do you want any old app or service connecting to _your_ data, siphoning it and selling it on (and, at best, burying their use of your data in a huge terms of service document that no-one reads, at worst, lying about what they do with that information)? So you have to add access controls that are either intrusive and/or complex, or, more likely, just ignored. Then the provider gets sued for leaking data and we're in a situation where no-one dares open up.

rahoulb commented on Claude Code feels like magic because it is iterative   omarabid.com/claude-magic... · Posted by u/todsacerdoti
sylware · 2 months ago
You can give a set of test cases?
rahoulb · 2 months ago
My favourite way to use it is to write tests first, then say "make these pass". It will generate some code, run the tests, say "oh, there's an error here ... let's fix that ... oh, there's an error there, let's fix that ..." and (most of the time) it will reach a solution where the tests pass.

I already do TDD a lot of the time, and this way I can be sure that the actual requirements are covered by the tests. Whereas asking it to add tests to existing code often gets over-elaborate in areas that aren't important and misses cases for the vital stuff.

Sometimes, when asking Claude to pass existing tests, it comes up with better implementations than I would have done. Other times the implementation is awful, but I know I can use it, because the tests prove it works. And then I (or Claude) can refactor with confidence later.

rahoulb commented on Storytelling lessons I learned from Steve Jobs (2022)   fastcompany.com/90747313/... · Posted by u/tosh
bbarnett · 6 months ago
You missed the other horror of modern marketing. Using the thing sold to you, that you paid for, to trap you in endless marketing hell.

I don't mean using it, eg to visit a social media site or whatever. I mean, the device spamming you with ads and "helpful hints' about more products to buy.

Like Google and Android not shutting up about Gemini, nagging you to try it. Or dark patterns to trick you into subscribing to a service.

rahoulb · 6 months ago
I should refine my original comment: good marketing is about meeting the right people with the right message at the right time.

That kind of persistent nagging is the wrong time, with the wrong message at the wrong people.

rahoulb commented on Storytelling lessons I learned from Steve Jobs (2022)   fastcompany.com/90747313/... · Posted by u/tosh
palata · 6 months ago
I always am skeptical about this idea that "great marketers make great products". I mean of course marketing is important to sell stuff, and of course people want to think that they have a major contribution into the success of their company, but...

Take the iPhone. My first iPhone was a 3G. I did not buy it because Steve Jobs convinced me: I bought it because a friend had one, I tried it and it was actually pretty cool. I had tried a PDA before, and did not feel like buying one. No storytelling there, just a product that was a better fit at a better time.

rahoulb · 6 months ago
People often mix marketing and sales. For me marketing is about "understanding your market". You wanted an iPhone because His Steveness knew what many people were looking for in a phone.

(The other parts of marketing, IMO, are getting the right message across at the right time - to those right people. The storytelling is the message part).

rahoulb commented on The subtle art of designing physical controls for cars   theturnsignalblog.com/the... · Posted by u/vsdlrd
nottorp · 6 months ago
That's how the knobs normally work. And the original poster describes how "automatic a/c" or "climate controls" have always worked in cars, you set a target temp and they handle fan speed and air temperature.

Why does the article want to make a multifunction dial with no tactile feedback? Have they only ever driven a Tesla?

rahoulb · 6 months ago
There's a whole section in the article about experimenting with different positions and weights of the haptic feedback as the dial is moved and how to tie them in to the display on the control itself.
rahoulb commented on Mac(OS)talgia   swallowmygraphicdesign.co... · Posted by u/mgrayson
rahoulb · 7 months ago
I love that.

Also the MacOS "Zoom" button makes so much more sense than the OSX/macOS green button - and I still miss window shading.

rahoulb commented on Show HN: Cut the crap – remove AI bullshit from websites   cut-the-crab.streamlit.ap... · Posted by u/muc-martin
keiferski · 9 months ago
I bookmarked this comment a few months ago because I thought it was hilarious and increasingly accurate:

It's approaching a very strange situation where people make overly wordy and bloated AI generated content and other people try to use AI to compress it back into useful pellets vaguely corresponding to the actual prompts used to generate the initial content. Which were the only bits anybody cared about in the first place. One guy pays the AI to dig a hole, the other guy pays the AI to fill in the hole. Back and forth they go, raising the BNP but otherwise not accomplishing anything.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41635079

More seriously though; I wonder if/when we will reach a point at which asking for a Neuromancer-esque précis summary video of a topic will replace the experience of browsing and reading various sources of information. My gut feeling is that it will for many, but not all scenarios, because the act of browsing itself is desirable and informative. For example, searching for books on Amazon is efficient but it doesn’t quite replace the experience of walking through a bookstore.

rahoulb · 9 months ago
I feel the real problem comes when people stop publishing on the (open) web because 1) no-one is reading it directly and 2) they know their hard work will just get slurped up and regurgitated by LLMs.
rahoulb commented on The tragedy of running an old Node project   abdisalan.com/posts/trage... · Posted by u/abdisalan
pzmarzly · 9 months ago
Good for you, my experience with Jekyll is closer to OP's experience with Node. I have a big website that I built in 2014, with tons of custom plugins, that is now stuck on Jekyll 2.x and Ruby 2.x, and has a ton of hidden C++ dependencies. The way I build it now is using a Dockerfile with Ubuntu 18.04. I probably could update it given enough effort, but I was rather thinking of rewriting it in Astro.js or Next.js.
rahoulb · 9 months ago
This is the issue I have with the "build vs buy (or import)" aspect of today's programming.

There are countless gems, libraries or packages out there that make your life easier and development so much faster.

But software (in my experience) always lives longer than you expect it to, so you need to be sure that your dependencies will be maintained for that lifetime (or have enough time to do the maintenance or plug in the replacements yourself).

rahoulb commented on Apple may stop producing Vision Pro by the end of 2024   macrumors.com/2024/10/23/... · Posted by u/mfiguiere
bee_rider · 10 months ago
I’d like Apple Maps to show up in my field of view. In that case I could even not have a phone at all. (But not like $3500 want). I agree that nobody has found a really good use case. I do wonder to what extent that is just because nobody has released an AR headset that you’d wear outside.
rahoulb · 10 months ago
I have done that with XReal glasses and my phone.

But they still look kind of off when wearing them in public (slightly bigger than normal sunglasses, cable from one ear and other people can see the light from the screens from the side or back).

And the lack of integration is a pain - the phone has to be unlocked so is subject to random taps and swipes in my pocket.

However, an Apple-built Carplay-style projection into XReal type glasses could work very well - the question being how would you control it?

rahoulb commented on Apple may stop producing Vision Pro by the end of 2024   macrumors.com/2024/10/23/... · Posted by u/mfiguiere
rahoulb · 10 months ago
I wonder if the lack of third party software for it is because the resentment with the App Store has built up so much?

Building an iPhone app? Pretty much required.

Building an iPad app? Almost free when you're building an iPhone app (depending on your tolerance for UI/UX)

Building a Watch app? It's a popular device but is it worth the investment? Most people say no.

Building for a brand new platform where we have to live with Apple's rules? No thanks.

u/rahoulb

KarmaCake day2430November 9, 2009
About
Rubyist - https://theartandscienceofruby.com/ CTO at Collabor8Online - https://www.collabor8online.co.uk/
View Original