Readit News logoReadit News
rachelshu commented on Ask vs. Guess Culture   jeanhsu.substack.com/p/as... · Posted by u/kiyanwang
nostrademons · 2 years ago
I've also heard of "Tell" culture. To use the moving example:

You call up your best friend and say, "Hey, I'm moving on Saturday, come over and help me." Your friend either says "Sure, I'd love to" or "Sorry, got a hot date, catch you at your housewarming party."

Ironically, Ask culture is usually used in transactional settings where you barely know someone, Guess culture is usually used in smaller community settings where you have a lot of personal context, but Tell culture (which is a level beyond Ask in directness) is usually used in intimate settings where you have a strong bond with someone - either family or very close friends. At that level of intimacy, it's expected that someone can say no to a direct request without hurting the relationship. It's the same reason close friends frequently make fun of each other or horse around in mock physical combat - it demonstrates that your relationship is strong enough that insult doesn't hurt it.

rachelshu · 2 years ago
Mixed feelings on this. Tell culture allows people to express their feelings directly without prompting, but can also be used manipulatively when insisted on as a behavioral standard by someone who's overbearing relative to the people they're around.

For further reading, here's the blog post that named the concept: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/rEBXN3x6kXgD4pLxs/tell-cultu...

And further discussion within the same community: https://thingofthings.wordpress.com/2015/05/08/against-tell-...

There were a bunch of tumblr posts on this as well which are more work than it's worth to go recover.

rachelshu commented on Things Unexpectedly Named After People   notes.rolandcrosby.com/po... · Posted by u/vortex_ape
rachelshu · 5 years ago
There seem to be two meanings of “unexpected” not being differentiated here:

1) name-derived terms like Debian, or the French ‘poubelle’ in the comments, which have become genericized to the point where most of its users don’t know the derivation

2) a more interesting subset of (1), like PageRank, or Lake Mountain in the comments, where part or all of the name itself looks like a normal word appropriate for the situation. (a related concept is nominative determinism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nominative_determinism)

rachelshu commented on Slate Star Codex and Silicon Valley’s War Against the Media   newyorker.com/culture/ann... · Posted by u/hprotagonist
rachelshu · 5 years ago
For all the other reasons that people on this site might hate this article, nevertheless it succeeds in doing the one thing that Scott asked of journalists: that they respect his pseudonym.
rachelshu commented on I Am Deleting the Blog   slatestarcodex.com/2020/0... · Posted by u/perditus
maxwelljoslyn · 5 years ago
I clicked on this expecting it to be Scott Alexander blogging about somebody else getting doxxed. I flipped like a boat when I realized what I was reading. Holy shit!

I was just in SSC's Open Thread a few hours ago opening comment permalinks in tabs to respond to them.

That NYT writer should be fired. I hope Scott recovers soon. SSC is my favorite place on the Web.

rachelshu · 5 years ago
I don't think, given Scott's recent defense of Steve Hsu, that he'd really want people fired for doing ill-advised things, even if they could be reasonably construed as dangerous, unless harm was demonstrated. It's still disappointing that the journalist is making this choice.
rachelshu commented on Ghoti   en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gho... · Posted by u/marvindanig
jcranmer · 5 years ago
Do you object to the fact that the spelling "th" invariably means /þ/ or /ð/, and not /th/? Or mapping "sh" to /ʃ/ and not /sh/? I highly doubt you do.

Here's the thing: spelling rules are context-sensitive, and if you actually understand the underlying sound rules, spelling in English is often not that bad. For example, there is a fricatization process for /t/ and /s/ sounds convert to a /ʃ/ or a /ʒ/--this is how "-tion" is pronounced /ʃən/. Or the tendency of multiple consonants in a cluster to all be voiced or unvoiced (hence why dogs is pronounced /dogz/ and not /dogs/). Even consider the velarization of "n" in the "-ing" suffix, which is pronunced /ŋg/ and not /ng/ (try actually pronouncing /ng/! It's not easy).

I'm not aware of any spelling reforms that would propose to fix the last two examples I give, but the fricatization changes is often one of most common ones people suggest changing. That's a sign that people are willing to tolerate some degree of phonetic inaccuracies.

The real issue with English is our tendency to adopt foreign words with foreign pronunciations, foreign spellings, and sometimes even foreign morphology. And sometimes we even botch that--witness words like "gyro" or "ginkgo". This means that trying to pronounce unusual words often means first guessing what language the words (or even morphemes!) comes from, and then internalizing some bastardized form of that foreign language's phonology.

rachelshu · 5 years ago
"th" is occasionally /th/, for example in the compound word "hothouse".

u/rachelshu

KarmaCake day95June 21, 2020View Original