Readit News logoReadit News
liotier commented on A new database on police use of force and misconduct in California   journalism.berkeley.edu/p... · Posted by u/Improvement
liotier · 18 days ago
Sousveillance - the first step to taking power to account.
liotier commented on Eleven Music   elevenlabs.io/blog/eleven... · Posted by u/meetpateltech
amradio1989 · 19 days ago
I could be wrong, but I think the use case here is mainly for non-artists in domains where the music is not particularly important.

For example, a podcaster/youtuber may want a short intro track. An entertainer or a marketer may want some generic or silly background music.

Does it have a use case for a producer/musician? Maybe. It might give them ideas for chord progressions, melodies, etc. But real music does that too, and much more effectively.

liotier · 18 days ago
Polemics about generative AI might indeed benefit from separately addressing art and entertainment. Generative AI in art is worth debating, but entertainment is not even a question: entertainment is a proven market for mass-produced slop, where artless works just fine and art is marginally valued.
liotier commented on A dive into open chat protocols   wiki.alopex.li/ADiveIntoO... · Posted by u/Bogdanp
BrenBarn · 21 days ago
This was a pretty fun read. I like that the author gives their impressions and seems reasonably knowledgeable but also admits they don't know all the ins and outs of some of the things they address.

I find myself leaning more these days towards the view that the whole "eventually consistent JSON database replicated across all participating servers" thing is maybe too much of a reach. One big reason is that I think the challenges of moderation put a cap on how decentralized any usable communications system can be, so decentralizing things beyond the level of moderation doesn't actually add much, and can in some ways make things worse.

It's abundantly clear that you can't run any kind of public anything on the internet these days without some sort of moderation. It's also clear that moderation ultimately requires humans making decisions; you can have bots reacting in various ways to filter spam but you always need humans at the top who can override and tune those bots. For public forums, the capacity of those humans to keep things running in a sane manner is the bottleneck on centralization, not any technical decentralization of the protocol.

What this means is that if you have a chat room with a three-person mod team, there is not much to be gained by having the underlying protocol decentralized across the servers and/or clients of all 100 or 500 or 10,000 users in the room. Everything that every user sees is already subject to the decisions of the three mods and is therefore effectively "gatekept". Moreover, what it means for the room to be healthy is that all those users are basically satisfied with the moderation, which means that letting unmoderated traffic flow in a free and decentralized manner is actually not what people want --- it just means they'll see more spam.

A possibility to explore would be something that has some kind of partial or two-tiered decentralization in which (within the context of a given room) moderator servers have different status than ordinary-user servers. This might mean, for instance, that non-moderator servers simply trust moderator servers about state, rather than every server doing the full state resolution for every room. It could also mean that when moderation is overwhelmed by a flood of spam, there is a mechanism that can throttle traffic to the non-mod users, so that the room just appears quiet, rather than the whole flood of spam being replicated to everyone.

This idea is half-baked but I feel like something along these lines could mitigate some of the worst cases I've seen on Matrix, which can arise when the spam effectively DDoSes the moderators and the moderation actions (such as redactions or bans) become stuck in the processing queue behind spam messages.

In any case, though, it's clear that moderation needs to be baked into the protocol at a lower level than it currently is.

liotier · 21 days ago
> In any case, though, it's clear that moderation needs to be baked into the protocol at a lower level than it currently is.

Lesson learned and relearned across all social and communication software... Moderation cannot be grafted on later: it is core, it makes or breaks the social experience.

HN, Bluesky and Reddit, for example, got it right, each in their own way for their own use case, and I believe it one of the main reasons of their success.

liotier commented on Digital vassals? French Government ‘exposes citizens’ data to US'   brusselssignal.eu/2025/07... · Posted by u/ColinWright
asdff · a month ago
Well, they are remilitarizing by buying lockheed and raytheon products. I don't think they will ever bite the hand that arms them.
liotier · 22 days ago
We are slow to wake up, but the hectic mood in the French arms industry is unprecedented and buying American is nowadays considered a stopgap - temporary evil.

Also, European defense firms are getting more competitive, by the simple virtue of larger orders enabling more investment.

liotier commented on Yes in My Bamako Yard   asteriskmag.com/issues/11... · Posted by u/surprisetalk
liotier · 23 days ago
In 2016, I visited a call center in Bamako - it was powered by an Asterisk VOIP system... And that is what I expected the article to cover...

Anyway, yes... Think America is the land of infinite suburban sprawl ? Meh - Africa is where it's at, with the obvious severe negative impact on urban development, mass transportation etc. Similar challenges as the USA, but a tenth of the resources.

liotier commented on “No tax on tips” is an industry plant   newyorker.com/magazine/20... · Posted by u/littlexsparkee
nobleach · 23 days ago
In France, I always thought it was customary to leave the change from l'addition. (I'm not French though, so perhaps I was commiting a faux pas)

I can confirm in Italy almost no one will even accept a tip. (Taxi drivers, wait-staff, hotel staff)

liotier · 23 days ago
> leave the change from l'addition

Yes, that is the basic tip if you expect to come back to that restaurant and get an upgraded welcome.

But even with no tip, being a regular counts - tip or no tip, you are good business and worth cultivating.

liotier commented on “No tax on tips” is an industry plant   newyorker.com/magazine/20... · Posted by u/littlexsparkee
froddd · 23 days ago
> Are there still customers giving tips as "a reward for good service"?

Sad if this is no longer the case.

In the UK at least (and the rest of Europe too, as far as I can tell), this is still very much the case. The curve varies with the individuals tipping. I would be quite happy to give 20% if the service was outstanding. I’m equally happy to not tip at all if the service was very poor.

liotier · 23 days ago
France here - no tip is the norm, tip is for service above & beyond... But, contrary to the USA, everyone gets a proper living wage !
liotier commented on Friction and Not Being Touched   tante.cc/2025/07/30/frict... · Posted by u/colinprince
PedroBatista · 24 days ago
While the author might be in one end of the spectrum, you might want to acknowledge you are at the other end and I hope it’s temporary because you sound bitter to the point you’re either a teenager or a person hurt by life.
liotier · 24 days ago
Now that's friction !
liotier commented on Vector Tiles are deployed on OpenStreetMap.org   blog.openstreetmap.org/20... · Posted by u/ikawe
lutoma · a month ago
Personally I'm quite happy that these tiles cut down on the clutter in the original OSM tiles. It made it very hard for me to actually use them for navigation because there was just so much stuff everywhere.

For example the old tiles displayed rail tracks extremely prominently, which just aren't relevant 99% of the time even when traveling by train. In the vector tiles they're much more muted and thinner.

liotier · a month ago
> I'm quite happy that these tiles cut down on the clutter in the original OSM tiles. It made it very hard for me to actually use them for navigation

The Openstreetmap.org tiles are a demo and a contributor quality assurance tool - they are not meant for end-user applications, hence the rather over-the-top selection of map objects.

liotier commented on Open Source Maintenance Fee   github.com/wixtoolset/iss... · Posted by u/AndrewDucker
bgwalter · a month ago
It is good for you to feel that way, others increasingly view it as a narrative endorsed by big tech to get free labor and "AI" training material.
liotier · a month ago
If it solves your problem, why would you care about what other people do with it ? Free software isn't charity, just a way to find allies - usage by other people is a side effect which doesn't cost anything to the project and is entirely irrelevant apart as some input for the user-to-ally pipeline.

u/liotier

KarmaCake day9671March 11, 2011
About
Information systems project manager for most of the French ISP and telecommunications operators since 1997. Arguably one of the worst PHP, Bash and Perl script authors in the world.

https://liotier.bsky.social

View Original