Readit News logoReadit News
justanything commented on Data brokers are selling flight information to CBP and ICE   eff.org/deeplinks/2025/07... · Posted by u/exiguus
jandrewrogers · 2 months ago
People don't grasp how easy it is to build data models like this even without privileged first-party data access.

In 2012 I created a killer prototype that demonstrated that you could accurately reconstruct most people's flight history at scale from social media and/or ad data. Probably the first of its kind. This has been possible for a long time.

A quick sketch of how it worked:

We filtered out all spatiotemporal edges in the entity graph with an implied speed of <300 kilometers per hour or <200 kilometers distance, IIRC. This was the proxy for "was on a plane". It also implicitly provided the origin and destination.

These edges can be correlated with both public flight data and maintenance IoT data from jet engines to put entities on a specific flight. People overlook the extent to which innocuous industrial IoT data can be used as a proxy for relationships in unrelated domains.

In rare cases, there was more than one plausible commercial flight. Because we had their flight history, we assumed in these cases that it was the primary airline they had used in the past, either generally or for that specific origin and destination. This almost always resolved perfectly.

This was impressively effective and it didn't require first-party data from airlines or particularly sophisticated analytics. Space and time are the primary keys of reality.

justanything · 2 months ago
Can you eli5 the implementation and how your prototype worked?
justanything commented on I may be beyond redemption    · Posted by u/justanything
tomhow · 2 months ago
Comments that assert that genetic inheritance determines life outcomes are not what we want on HN. It has very ugly implications that I don't need to spell out. And it's personal for me because I, and others I know and love, have put a lot of work over many years into overcoming inner obstacles that were said by "experts" to be "hard-wired" traits.

We want HN to be a place for talking about expanding people's possibilities, not limiting them.

justanything · 2 months ago
How did you do that? how did you overcome "hard-wired" traits?
justanything commented on I may be beyond redemption    · Posted by u/justanything
ecoled_ame · 2 months ago
How old are you? I am 34 and was recently reading my journals from college when I was ~21. I was continually lamenting my laziness and lack of direction, filled with worry too. I had high aspirations but no clue how to get there. Proceed to 10 years of absolute failure but learning the value of a determination to persist. Now happy with a mid-level job that I worked so hard to get, nowhere near the PhD or MBA friends I have, but that’s okay. Living in the middle of nowhere and that’s okay. Realize I can always get a job at a restaurant and at least pay rent. Idk, just hang around and keep trying and lower your standards. Maybe get away from your parents so you are forced to be independent.
justanything · 2 months ago
I am working on the determination aspect but it is so slow and frustrating, plus any time I am learning, I get flashbacks of my own failures and also thoughts of how everyone else is so much ahead.
justanything commented on I may be beyond redemption    · Posted by u/justanything
spaceprison · 2 months ago
There’s more to life than money, this is why your parents are willing to “waste” it on you.

When I was in a similar rut/loop the best thing that happened to me was when I finally stopped trying to keep up appearances, got honest and asked for help.

It was embarrassing to finally humble myself to ask for help, luckily embarrassment isn’t life threatening, just really uncomfortable for a minute.

The people in my life wanted to help me more than they wanted repayment. They helped in finding a gp the gp helped find a psychologist and then they all helped find a psychiatrist.

justanything · 2 months ago
There is no meaning to life, the only meaning I can have is family and money. I failed one and the other I can't get
justanything commented on I may be beyond redemption    · Posted by u/justanything
justanything · 2 months ago
That's fucked up for me, I would rather die

Although, my bio parents and grandparents were white-collar or white collar adjacent at least. And one of my bio grandpa was very conscientious and active well into old age

justanything commented on I may be beyond redemption    · Posted by u/justanything
sinenomine · 2 months ago
Anhedonia or negative symptoms of schizophrenia, or something else, might be even me/cfs, or obscure allergy.

... You seem to have intrinsic motivation to write longish texts though, unironically.

justanything · 2 months ago
Haha, I don't know why I love writing about how shit I am, probably because I am hoping for some miracle
justanything commented on I may be beyond redemption    · Posted by u/justanything
sinenomine · 2 months ago
Might be low T btw
justanything · 2 months ago
Nope, pretty high on T but without any of the pros of having high T
justanything commented on I may be beyond redemption    · Posted by u/justanything
yawpitch · 2 months ago
Go feed some pigeons.

Seriously, just buy a bag of seed, go find some pigeons, and feed them.

Now, watch them, carefully… see how hard they work, every day, even when they’re hobbling around on grotesque stumps where their feet used to be before they got wrapped up in our discarded waste.

Notice how something can put so much effort into just surviving, against all the odds, and against the abuse and mistreatment and just casual negligent brutality inflicted upon them by your species. See how they aren’t focused on money or jobs or learning or prestige, just on being now and being for a bit longer.

See how they’ll eventually trust you enough to approach or land on your hand to feed. How, if you do this day after day, they’ll recognize you and wait for you.

The only living thing that won’t, eventually, react to a modicum of gentleness and kindness with trust is a human.

You’re not on this planet to earn money. You’re not here to work. You’re certainly not here to build edifices of ephemeral noise. You’re here to be, while you can.

Pay your parents back on their real investment, by dedicating your time to them. Be there to care for them as they age. Give them a bit of gentleness and kindness… they need that much more than they need the fiction that is money.

When they’re done, then check out if you want to. I’ve been suicidal for as long as I can remember, I’m faking it until there’s no one else to care for. That’s enough.

No one is beyond redemption, if only because there’s no such thing as redemption in the first place.

justanything · 2 months ago
I need money to be here. and to have decent money, i need to have skills, which i have to learn, which i am not able to do
justanything commented on I may be beyond redemption    · Posted by u/justanything
sinenomine · 2 months ago
If you aren't suitable for white collar track, you very well know you can get into blue collar trades or become a taxi driver.

The tests for ADHD and some variations of depression are leaky, erroneous shit. Just get the drugs (Adderall xr, Wellbutrin) and see if these help.

You say you tried some NDRI spectrum drugs, this probably means you have some rare type of depression or schizo spectrum disorder, or something else entirely.

If your parents truly care about you they will find you a decent doctor that will diagnose it.

>it did not stop them from learning or becoming great engineers.

You seem not to be wired to get intrinsic motivation from coding, idk.

justanything · 2 months ago
I am not wired to get intrinsic motivation from anything. period.
justanything commented on I may be beyond redemption    · Posted by u/justanything
android521 · 2 months ago
first, you don't need to reward or payback your parent. You don't need to feel guilty for the love and support of your parent. second, it is never too late. you already had a time machine. your future 70 year old self transported you back so that you had awareness and wrote this post but you can't remember that you're from the future. But you do know that you can make a difference starting now. Don't aim for big changes. You will mostly disappoint and give up. Aim for small daily improvements. Procratinate a little bit less (just a little will do) . Learn a bit more (just a bit more is enough) every day.Time will be your friend and you will be a different person a year from now.
justanything · 2 months ago
I do owe my parents, firstly because I am adopted and secondly, they went above and beyond for me in every way they could. Thank you for the kind words, I appreciate them.

I am trying small daily improvements now, for the millionth time. But the fear and the guilt is overwhelming, and I am never gonna catch up to other normal people, much less high earners. And then there is AI.

u/justanything

KarmaCake day20May 2, 2025View Original