Readit News logoReadit News
jonathankoren commented on California approves final high-speed rail link connecting San Francisco to LA   sfchronicle.com/bayarea/a... · Posted by u/edward
Invictus0 · a year ago
$100 billion for 463 miles of track is outrageous, and that's surely to double by the time it's completed. In 1964, Japan was able to build its 320 mile long Shinkansen from Tokyo to Osaka in just 5 years for less than $12B, inflation adjusted.
jonathankoren · a year ago
There’s no single answer to why infrastructure is ludicrously expensive in the United States. It’s too easy to delay, so the costs go up. (Especially in California with its multiple rounds of public feedback.) Laws requiring American contractors, mean no one has experience building large complex projects, so things get delayed. Add in contractors along every link in the chain charging a government job premium, and the fact that government agencies have been gutted so whose left is easily bamboozled by the private grifters, or forced to hire expensive consultants to do jobs that used be done more cheaply in house, it’s no wonder everything is expensive.

It’s simultaneously too much regulation, and too little government oversight.

https://www.vox.com/22534714/rail-roads-infrastructure-costs...

Deleted Comment

jonathankoren commented on Fast Crimes at Lambda School   sandofsky.com/lambda-scho... · Posted by u/plinkplonk
dang · a year ago
I just don't think you would say that if you saw the full range of requests we get. Some feel excessively fussy to me (ok, a lot feel that way) but some are coming from people in genuine distress.
jonathankoren · a year ago
I do not care. People fuck up all the time. It’s not anyone’s job to bail them out from their actions.
jonathankoren commented on Fast Crimes at Lambda School   sandofsky.com/lambda-scho... · Posted by u/plinkplonk
dang · a year ago
I know it's easy to feel that way when the user asking for help has been labeled $bad for whatever reason. But I doubt you would say that about most of the users who ask for this help, and if we're going to do it for some, I don't feel comfortable picking who gets helped and who doesn't. Nor do I think the community would support us in doing it that way.
jonathankoren · a year ago
It’s not about picking. It’s about doing it at all.

Now you’re active participant in a cover up. They want to delete something, edit something? Fine. The controls are there. Everyone knows that. But that’s not what this is. This is taking extraordinary action to gaslight and coverup. That’s what’s trash. It’s the secrecy. It’s changing of the archive. That’s what trash.

In all my decades of dealing with public forums, I have never seen this as something done in a reputable forum, outside of a court order.

It’s a betrayal of trust. The fact that you’re not defending it on the merits, but rather that it’s supposedly open to all that knew about the secret door is just the chef’s kiss of abuse of power. If I was asked to do this, I would quit.

Dang, every time you do this, it shows contempt to everyone on this forum. It’s absolute trash. It is bad, and you should feel bad. But of course, you don’t feel bad about doing it. You feel good about it.

jonathankoren commented on Fast Crimes at Lambda School   sandofsky.com/lambda-scho... · Posted by u/plinkplonk
dang · a year ago
Renaming accounts, redacting posts, etc. are all things that we do for users in general. We make no distinction between "high-ranking" users and others.

We take care of these requests every day and have bent over backwards (e.g. spending hours writing code) to help people individually in cases where their needs were unusually complex. I can tell you for sure that whether the person is high- or low-status in $whoever's eyes has nothing to do with this. Often I don't even know who the person is.

Our approach boils down to this: we don't want anyone to get in trouble from anything they posted to HN. It doesn't matter who the "anyone" is. Countless times I've deleted posts, redacted personal data and/or randomized usernames for accounts that had long been abusing and trolling HN. I don't rub their nose in it—I just pretend not to have noticed. You'd be surprised how polite and thankful people become when they need something.

I'm not surprised to see accounts like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40732721 being scurrilously silly, but you've been around here long enough to know better.

Edit: here's the last time this came up: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26949343. It's a more complete explanation than I have time to give right now, and nothing has changed since then.

jonathankoren · a year ago
This is a trash policy. It's reputation laundering as a service.
jonathankoren commented on Lists   news.ycombinator.com/list... · Posted by u/cromulent
simonw · a year ago
I'm assumed that was why the karma scores for the top ten users aren't visible - you can karma farm your way to the top ten but after that you're blind: https://news.ycombinator.com/leaders

Maybe psychologically that helps people think "why bother?"

jonathankoren · a year ago
Nah. You just set the prize at top 10.
jonathankoren commented on Fast Crimes at Lambda School   sandofsky.com/lambda-scho... · Posted by u/plinkplonk
smabie · a year ago
Well maybe indentured servitude is fine too?
jonathankoren · a year ago
yOu cAn'T tRulLy bE fReE iF yOu cAn'T sELL yOuRsELf iNtO sLaVeRy.

I remember this take. It's the kind of thing that only makes sense in a dorm room full of financially secure people that ignore that this is simply creates a slave class of economically disadvantaged.

jonathankoren commented on Fast Crimes at Lambda School   sandofsky.com/lambda-scho... · Posted by u/plinkplonk
AJC-Official · a year ago
Percentage of earnings is just equity. They're different, but not ethically. Slavery would be forcibly taking 100% of an individual's equity, but given that ISAs are both optional and a minor percentage (Lambda's was 18% when I went thru), the comparison is unreasonable.
jonathankoren · a year ago
Equity in what property?

Equity in what property?

honk honk honk

jonathankoren commented on Fast Crimes at Lambda School   sandofsky.com/lambda-scho... · Posted by u/plinkplonk
wmf · a year ago
What does that make student loans? Slavery?
jonathankoren · a year ago
Loans are a payment. These were a percentage of earnings. They are very different.
jonathankoren commented on Fast Crimes at Lambda School   sandofsky.com/lambda-scho... · Posted by u/plinkplonk
dustincoates · a year ago
I'm convinced that Lambda School was shady, and I'm not debating that, but some of this seems over the top.

ISAs as indentured servitude? The shadowy negotiating a company's validation "behind closed doors?" (Where else are you supposed to do it.)

The criticism of Lambda School can stand on its own without wading into the extreme hyperbole.

jonathankoren · a year ago
ISAs were indentured servitude. That's literally what they were. It was the single most scummy concept that Austin came up with and PaulG endorsed.

u/jonathankoren

KarmaCake day4795November 24, 2008
About
Downvotes aren’t a counter argument. All it means is you made someone feel bad for some reason.

Social vote counters are just sentiment thermometers.

-- Me (-4, flagged)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21539167

View Original