https://www.reddit.com/r/GoogleMaps/comments/1737ft9/google_...
https://www.reddit.com/r/GoogleMaps/comments/1737ft9/google_...
ugh. The right thing to do is buy and THEN download the no drm version from "other sources." You should always support the authors.
A better example is Google Image Search. Thumbnails are transformative because they have a different purpose and aren't the same data. An LLM is much more transformative than a thumbnail.
It's more lossy than even lossy compression because of the regularization term; I'm pretty sure you can train one that's guaranteed to not retain any of the pretraining text. Of course then it can't answer things like "what's the second line of The Star Spangled Banner".
There is something novel here.
Google Books created a huge online index of books, OCRing, compressing them, and transforming them. That was copyright infringement.
Just because I download a bunch of copyrighted files and run `tar c | gzip` over them does not mean I have new copyright.
Just because I download an image and convert it from png to jpg at 50% quality, throwing away about half the data, does not mean I have created new copyright.
AI models are giant lossy compression algorithms. They take text, tokenize it, and turn it into weights, and then inference is a weird form of decompression. See https://bellard.org/ts_zip/ for a logical extension to this.
I think this is the reason that the claim of LLM models being unencumbered by copyright is novel. Until now, a human had to do some creative transformation to transform a work, it could not simply be a computer algorithm that changed the format or compressed the input.
No. It's a decided case. It's transformative and fair use. My understanding why it's transformative is that Google Books mainly offers a search interface for books and it also have measures to make sure only snippets of books are shown.
RSS didn't stick for me until:
1. I decided to quit most social media, so without RSS I would miss stuff I actually care about.
2. I unsubscribed to all news sites. RSS fatigue is a thing. Don't subscribe to sites that make money the more they post. I used to subscribe to Phoronix, the top HN frontpage articles, OSNews, LWN, etc.: bad idea, you don't want to wake up to 50 unread posts per day and get overwhelmed. Now I mostly follow personal blogs, and I have one new post per day to read. Much more manageable and higher signal-to-noise ratio.
3. https://fetchrss.com/ is genius for everything else that doesn't support RSS. It allows to turn any website into an RSS feed, and the free plan is generous enough for my needs.
I pay for Feedbin, and it's great.
---
1: I wish Firefox still showed an RSS feed icon when a page has one. These days I have to "view-source" and search for feed or atom or rss to tell.
That's an interesting tip. Never thought about it this way.
- https://github.com/omer-faruq/assistant.koplugin, which is forked from:
- https://github.com/drewbaumann/AskGPT
The first one even has prompts for quick recaps, summarize, translations, and more.