Readit News logoReadit News
jballanc commented on Cloudflare Global Network experiencing issues   cloudflarestatus.com/inci... · Posted by u/imdsm
kordlessagain · 3 months ago
It’s time to revolt.
jballanc · 3 months ago
More like it's time for the pendulum to swing back...

We had very decentralized "internet" with BBSes, AOL, Prodigy, etc.

Then we centralized on AOL (ask anyone over 40 if they remember "AOL Keyword: ACME" plastered all over roadside billboards).

Then we revolted and decentralized across MySpace, Digg, Facebook, Reddit, etc.

Then we centralized on Facebook.

We are in the midst of a second decentralization...

...from an information consumer's perspective. From an internet infrastructure perspective, the trend has been consistently toward more decentralization. Initially, even after everyone moved away from AOL as their sole information source online, they were still accessing all the other sites over their AOL dial-up connection. Eventually, competitors arrived and, since AOL no longer had a monopoly on content, they lost their grip on the infrastructure monopoly.

Later, moving up the stack, the re-centralization around Facebook (and Google) allowed those sources to centralize power in identity management. Today, though, people increasingly only authenticate to Facebook or Google in order to authenticate to some 3rd party site. Eventually, competitors for auth will arrive (or already have ahem passkeys coughcough) and, as no one goes to Facebook anymore anyway, they'll lose grip on identity management.

It's an ebb and flow, but the fundamental capability for decentralization has existed in the technology behind the internet from the beginning. Adoption and acclimatization, however, is a much slower process.

jballanc commented on It's unlikely that there will be any further releases of mt32-pi   github.com/dwhinham/mt32-... · Posted by u/nickt
chongli · a year ago
I don’t see how it’s foolish. When you mention a bazaar essentially no one thinks of the closed door meetings of the merchant guilds. Instead, they think of the hustle and bustle of a busy marketplace where all manner of goods, services, and ideas are openly exchanged.

This in contrast to the somber atmosphere of a cathedral where people whisper even when there are no services taking place at the time. It’s an image of reverence, humility, and monumental architecture.

jballanc · a year ago
Yeah, "foolish" maybe wasn't the right word. All metaphors fall short in some way (hence why they're metaphors). I just, knowing something of the history of that part of the world, like to use the opportunity to share the knowledge that, despite the appearances of a chaotic, random aggregation of humans, Bazaars often had a significant structure under the surface (perhaps another lesson about open source to be had there).
jballanc commented on It's unlikely that there will be any further releases of mt32-pi   github.com/dwhinham/mt32-... · Posted by u/nickt
aidenn0 · a year ago
> ...where he compares the rather top-down, leader driven culture of Unix development to the free-for-all style of Linux.

The Cathedral example was actually GNU, which is Not Unix (it's in the name!).

jballanc · a year ago
Shoot, you're absolutely right! It's been a long while since I last re-read the article, and I had forgotten how "targeted" (for lack of a better term) it was at certain specific individuals.
jballanc commented on It's unlikely that there will be any further releases of mt32-pi   github.com/dwhinham/mt32-... · Posted by u/nickt
jakelazaroff · a year ago
> Return to Cathedral.

What does this mean?

jballanc · a year ago
It's a reference to Eric S. Raymond's famous article "The Cathedral and the Bazaar", where he compares the rather top-down, leader driven culture of Unix development to the free-for-all style of Linux.

Of course, I always like to point out the foolishness of this metaphor: Bazaars in the Near East were usually run in a fairly regimented fashion by merchant guilds and their elected or appointed leaders.

jballanc commented on Ask HN: PhDs/students, how do you come up with viable problems/solutions?    · Posted by u/wayoverthecloud
jballanc · a year ago
I can tell you the same thing I was told when I started my program: no thesis represents more than 1 year's worth of work. The reason it takes most Ph.D.s 5-10 years (8 in my case) to graduate is that you have to fail, and fail, and fail again for 4-9 years before you find your thesis project.

In my case, I started on two exploratory gene knockout "fishing expeditions", both of which didn't turn up anything interesting after a year. Then I crystalized a protein and submitted it to X-ray diffraction, but the results were not good enough for a "high quality" structure, and besides the structure we did find was not particularly interesting. Then I switched to working on NMR structures, but ended up switching universities (politics...there's going to be lots of politics) before that went anywhere.

At my new university I switched to structure modeling and worked on a project my advisor suggested for about a year to optimize a modeling routine, but even the optimized version didn't turn up anything interesting. Finally, I landed on a very intriguing problem that could have had far reaching implications. I worked hard at it for almost a year, only to realize that even state-of-the-art modeling was at least a decade away from being able to begin to address the problem I needed to solve. Finally, I returned to a question that a professor had asked me in my first year of graduate school, half jokingly, assuming there was no way to answer the question. For about a year I worked hard at it, finally arrived at a very interesting answer, and graduated.

jballanc commented on Is the world really running out of sand?   practical.engineering/blo... · Posted by u/chmaynard
smt88 · a year ago
It seems likely to me that both concrete and plastic are used in greater mass and greater volume than wood.
jballanc · a year ago
And concrete dates back to (at least) Roman times
jballanc commented on Was the Internet created to survive a nuclear strike? (2022)   siliconfolklore.com/inter... · Posted by u/edward
localfirst · 2 years ago
That's the narrative. Just like Tor's narrative is that it helps America's spies communicate from hostile jurisdictions. The former never got the attention as back then we had monoculture shaped by mainstream media (no other alternatives) and we just ate up whatever we were told.

The latter appears to be under more scrutiny lately, leading us to believe this is just like the lofty idea that VPN encryption is completely anonymous from the big five.

Spies operating out of China or Russia would never use VPN or Tor? That would be painting a red target on their backs. So I wonder what the true intention is for Tor as is the mysterious origin of Bitcoin and so many other things. We won't know.

One thing is for sure, what we believed to be bastions of Western democracy and privacy are no more.

jballanc · 2 years ago
I'm no expert on Tor, but IIRC the story is precisely that spies operating from hostile territory would have a red target painted on them from using encrypted communications...unless a whole lot of people in that hostile territory were also using encrypted communications. This is why Tor was released open source and wide adoption was encouraged.
jballanc commented on The evolution of Ruby's Range class   zverok.space/blog/2024-07... · Posted by u/todsacerdoti
jballanc · 2 years ago
Nice write-up, but no discussion of Ruby's Range class is complete without at least a mention of the venerable flip-flop!

Can you predict the output of the following?

    (1..20).each do |i|
      puts i if i.odd?..i.prime?
    end

jballanc commented on The irrational hungry judge effect revisited (2023)   cambridge.org/core/journa... · Posted by u/fzliu
QuiDortDine · 2 years ago
Coming from a psychology major myself, scientific studies should never be cited before being reproduced, especially not psychology studies.
jballanc · 2 years ago
Without having read in-depth either original paper, it seems like the issue here is much simpler than reproduction (though reproduction is the gold standard as is totally under-appreciated these days).

Rather, it seems the authors made a much simpler mistake: hypotheses can only be refuted by evidence, not confirmed. So, in this case, if the hypothesis is "judges act more harshly when hungry", what they should have been doing is looking for evidence disproving that statement. Instead, they seem to have presented a correlation and a suggestion, which is not the same thing as a scientific finding.

u/jballanc

KarmaCake day9330November 23, 2008
About
I'm just a guy with some ideas...programming lets me do something with them.

Get in touch! jballanc@gmail.com https://github.com/jballanc

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/jballanc; my proof: https://keybase.io/jballanc/sigs/pxb6FPsVF9hoQMyb2ap0euWoNG3YxwN2g4VY94RRxX8 ]

View Original