Readit News logoReadit News
jackothy commented on Clair Obscur having its Indie Game Game Of The Year award stripped due to AI use   thegamer.com/clair-obscur... · Posted by u/anigbrowl
PunchyHamster · 2 days ago
and the rules of the contest did not include any sane boundaries.

Like, using automatic lipsync is "generative AI", should that be banned ? Do we really want to fight with that purely work-saving feature ?

jackothy · a day ago
All AI features are purely work saving
jackothy commented on Leaked Apple M5 9 core Geekbench scores   browser.geekbench.com/v6/... · Posted by u/aurareturn
danhon · 3 months ago
Moore was just about the transistor count doubling. Not performance.
jackothy · 3 months ago
Performance is an excellent proxy for transistor count. Somebody else replied with the actual transistor counts, which had basically equal scaling.
jackothy commented on Leaked Apple M5 9 core Geekbench scores   browser.geekbench.com/v6/... · Posted by u/aurareturn
porphyra · 3 months ago
Nice. Lots of people still claim that M1 is super duper fast but now we're at almost twice the performance!
jackothy · 3 months ago
What is that, 6 years for less than a doubling? Nothing against the Apple chips themselves, but gone are the days of Moore...
jackothy commented on Leaked Apple M5 9 core Geekbench scores   browser.geekbench.com/v6/... · Posted by u/aurareturn
ascagnel_ · 3 months ago
> though if Apple suddenly took gaming seriously, like extending Rosetta to act as a translation layer for Windows games a la Proton, I’d gladly throw down for an M5 Ultra when it’s released

No joke, if I could run my Steam library on my phone, I'd probably buy a new phone every year (and might need to, given what the thermals and rapid charge/discharge cycles would do to battery longevity). But Apple's current strategy is to provide a tool, then let developers do the work themselves; compare to Valve's efforts (and occasionally stepping on rakes when games update themselves).

jackothy · 3 months ago
The problem is they don't "let the developers do the work themselves"

If only the platform was open enough that developers had real access, Apple might get away with like you say not providing first party support for gaming.

jackothy commented on Charlie Kirk killed at event in Utah   nbcnews.com/news/us-news/... · Posted by u/david927
shruubi · 3 months ago
The fact that we're talking about this using terms like "sides" is the problem. American politics has long since stopped being about policy, but is treated like a sport where you follow your "team" and defend them no matter what. It's as though people are incapable of having thoughts on an issue more complex than "does my side think this is good or bad?" and suddenly those who disagree with you are evil, and with partisan media suddenly you see the "other side" as some faceless evil rather than people with differing and complex experiences and views.

I don't agree with a lot of the things Charlie Kirk said, and as someone who is not an American, there was also a lot of things he said I simply didn't care about because they didn't apply to me. I also found that his way of communicating was more geared towards encouraging discussions that would generate views. But despite all that, I can appreciate that he was a man who was willing to have a (mostly) civil conversation with all sides, something I wish more people would try to do.

American politics isn't politics, it's one step short of being like football hooliganism for supposedly smart people.

jackothy · 3 months ago
I also find it a bit extreme how many people feel the need to add some sort of disclaimer every time they say something nice about the guy who died:

- "I strongly disagree with Charlie Kirk, but [...] Condolences to his wife and small kids"

- "I have scant philosophical agreement, but..."

- "While I'm not a fan..."

Says something about the level of polarization that people are so afraid of accidentally being mistaken for a supporter, even in these circumstances. He was not a particularly niche character, his views are probably similar to a decently sized share of the American population. The American people are struggling so hard to find any kind of unity.

jackothy commented on Charlie Kirk killed at event in Utah   nbcnews.com/news/us-news/... · Posted by u/david927
jennyholzer · 3 months ago
I've never heard of the "steelman" thought experiment

I'm familiar with the "strawman" concept that it derives from, although in my experience this is typically presented as a logical fallacy.

What is the purpose of "steelmanning" a political actor's political perspectives?

What is this supposed to achieve?

Where did you and the people responding to this comment hear about this concept? Are there articles out there making the case for "steelmanning"?

jackothy · 3 months ago
It's just that a lot of people argue badly, either because of lacking skill or lacking goodwill.

That doesn't mean their arguments are necessarily wrong. It is necessary to try to reframe such badly made arguments in a way that presents the message properly in order to be able to actually compare competing ideas and find truth.

If you compare one well-crafted argument to a poorly crafted argument, the well-crafted argument would seem to come out on top even if its underlying ideas were actually wrong.

E.g. if I say "Apples are good because my grandma loved apples and you are stupid!"

And my opponent says "Apples are bad because there are other fruits that can be grown much more efficiently and feed people better"

Then my opponent would probably "win" the argument. But that doesn't mean apples are actually bad. Try to remake the argument for why apples are good in a better way, in order to fairly compare the two sides and find the truth.

jackothy commented on iPhone Air   apple.com/newsroom/2025/0... · Posted by u/excerionsforte
jackothy · 3 months ago
I want a version of this where the camera is flush with the surface of the phone. I understand and accept that this means the camera will be worse.
jackothy commented on We should have the ability to run any code we want on hardware we own   hugotunius.se/2025/08/31/... · Posted by u/K0nserv
bluesign · 4 months ago
I think it is kind of levels:

"can't participate in society without a mobile phone" "can't participate in society without internet" "can't participate in society without google"

not sure where is the logical correct threshold making it wrong. because we all accept maybe people not participating without internet.

jackothy · 4 months ago
Clearly the logical threshold is when a single private corporation becomes the gatekeeper to your life. The internet itself is decentralized so that's fine. Mobile phones as a concept is also fine.
jackothy commented on Is it possible to allow sideloading and keep users safe?   shkspr.mobi/blog/2025/08/... · Posted by u/ColinWright
rcarmo · 4 months ago
The “use a website instead” angle doesn’t really work for a lot of things, and given the impermanence of websites these days, is actually a major point of potential failure.
jackothy · 4 months ago
The "use a website instead" angle should work for the majority of things people spend phone time on. For the few things that could not be a PWA, some extra effort is needed.
jackothy commented on Is it possible to allow sideloading and keep users safe?   shkspr.mobi/blog/2025/08/... · Posted by u/ColinWright
mathiaspoint · 4 months ago
Or it's not a computer and really something more like a television. In that case these things should be thought of as a vice rather than a productivity tool.

The social structure of the smartphone app ecosystem is remarkably similar to the cable provider -> network -> show situation from before too.

jackothy · 4 months ago
The problem is larger than just smart phones. Smart phones are the templates for all future devices. You car now runs Android as well.

In the future, when your whole house is controlled by a computer, do you want that computer to be controlled by Google or to be controlled by yourself?

u/jackothy

KarmaCake day218June 23, 2021View Original