Readit News logoReadit News
imh commented on The Brain Is Not a Computer (2016)   aeon.co/essays/your-brain... · Posted by u/cjauvin
leftyted · 7 years ago
The dollar bill thing seems silly. The fact you can draw anything without looking at a dollar bill means something is being stored, right? That means the brain stores information. There's no way out of that. And that fact that you can draw the dollar bill on cue means something is being retrieved. No way around that either. It doesn't matter how the information is represented. The brain as a computer analogy doesn't specify that "neurons are bits" or whatever.

I don't expect the brain to work like any computer we've ever built (which seems to be the point of view this writer is attacking), but I do expect that it has the capacity to store, retrieve, and process information and so the computer analogy seems useful.

imh · 7 years ago
Yeah, you could make the same complaints about jpeg compression.
imh commented on How random can you be?   expunctis.com/2019/03/07/... · Posted by u/mdp
svat · 7 years ago
Here's a fun trick I learned from Flajolet and Sedgewick's Analytic Combinatorics (available online, page 52). I imagine it will seem incredible when tried with an actual classroom:

> Révész in [Strong theorems on coin tossing] tells the following amusing story attributed to T. Varga: “A class of high school children is divided into two sections. In one of the sections, each child is given a coin which he throws two hundred times, recording the resulting head-and-tail sequence on a piece of paper. In the other section, the children do not receive coins, but are told instead that they should try to write down a ‘random’ head-and-tail sequence of length two hundred. Collecting these slips of paper, [a statistician] then tries to subdivide them into their original groups. Most of the time, he succeeds quite well.”

> The statistician’s secret is [...] in a randomly produced sequence of length 200, there are usually runs of length 6 or more: the probability of the event turns out to be close to 97%. On the other hand most children (and adults) are usually afraid of writing down runs longer than 4 or 5 as this is felt as strongly “non-random”. The statistician simply selects the slips that contain runs of length 6 or more as the true random ones. Voilà!

----

Obviously, the way to beat this site (or the above classroom trick) would be to use "true" random numbers. But if one doesn't have access to coins or computers, it raises the question: what is a good way to generate a long sequence of reasonably random coin flips in one's head? For example, if you've memorized many digits of pi or e or some such "believed to be normal" constant, you could use whether each digit is odd or even (or maybe even something like throw away 8 and 9, and read each remaining digit in octal to get 3 random bits). But that only gets you so far...

imh · 7 years ago
One way to generate a sequence of heads and tails is to start with either heads or tails, then randomly choose how many of those to use before switching to the other. You're sampling the length of runs. e.g. Heads, then choosing 12113 would translate to HTTHTHHH.

It feels easier to ditch some of my biases generating a sequence this way.

imh commented on San Francisco median one bedroom apartment rent hits a new peak of $3,690   cnet.com/news/san-francis... · Posted by u/vector_spaces
ksec · 7 years ago
Excuse my ignorance. SF doesn't look anywhere like Hong Kong, possibly the most crowed places on earth, and it is not close to Tokyo or Seoul. It has plenty of Spaces, for many coming from Asia, most part of SF is like country side so to speak.

What cant there be more housing development on the edge of SF, or taller building with many smaller apartments etc. Underground packing lot?

Edit: Ok, is it because it is in an Earthquake zone?

imh · 7 years ago
>What cant there be more housing development on the edge of SF...

Three of the edges of SF are water.

imh commented on Why Are So Few Male Students Studying Abroad?   theatlantic.com/education... · Posted by u/Balgair
imh · 7 years ago
I was so bummed when I looked into this in college. Going for a physics degree, there was basically nowhere I could go in the spanish speaking world with classes that counted towards my degree. Which is nuts, since physics is a degree almost everywhere.
imh commented on Open Letter from New York State Budget Director Robert Mujica Regarding Amazon   governor.ny.gov/news/open... · Posted by u/agreen
imh · 7 years ago
>The seventy percent of New Yorkers who supported Amazon and now vent their anger also bear responsibility and must learn that the silent majority should not be silent because they can lose to the vocal minority and self-interested politicians.

This like makes me frustrated. It shouldn't be everyone's responsibility to go on twitter or wherever and be loud. Maybe politicians should put in real effort to learn about who they represent. They could engage in the same kind of polling they do during election season, rather than just paying attention to whoever is loudest.

imh commented on Toxic Workers Are More Productive, But the Price Is High   tlnt.com/toxic-workers-ar... · Posted by u/tarunupaday
atoav · 7 years ago
I am not sure what best means in this context..?

Most utilitaristic? Best in stealing public resources while being seen as a philantropist?

What the best is, depends on the incentives, the goals and the company culture. The best Mafioso in a group of the best mafiosi will be without a doubt a damn good Mafioso – but what does this mean for the rest of society?

imh · 7 years ago
The definition of best is irrelevant. The point is the distinction between maximizing something for an individual versus maximizing that same thing for the group.
imh commented on Pee, Not Chlorine, Causes Red Eyes from Swimming Pools: CDC (2015)   cbc.ca/news/trending/pee-... · Posted by u/colinprince
shittyadmin · 7 years ago
Because you just touched your pelvic region which has tons more bacteria than urine itself does. Urine will have some, especially some from the urethra on the way out, so definitely shouldn't be considered sterile, but wash your hands if you're touching your pelvic region in general please.
imh · 7 years ago
I think your hands probably have more bacteria than your junk.
imh commented on Pee, Not Chlorine, Causes Red Eyes from Swimming Pools: CDC (2015)   cbc.ca/news/trending/pee-... · Posted by u/colinprince
Zimahl · 7 years ago
Michael Phelps was fucking with whomever was interviewing him. I was a competitive swimmer and it's almost impossible to need to go pee while working out in a pool. Not only are you getting dehydrated by sweating profusely, you are getting dehydrated via osmosis.
imh · 7 years ago
I doubt Phelps was fucking with the interviewer. I was also a competitive swimmer and my experience matches what Phelps said.
imh commented on Toxic Workers Are More Productive, But the Price Is High   tlnt.com/toxic-workers-ar... · Posted by u/tarunupaday
FakeComments · 7 years ago
How so?

Naively, it seems like capitalism is a means of “top group” selection, so long as there is relatively high chance for social mobility and opportunity.

The method which worked better for chickens still involved selecting the best cohort (capitalism), and this improved over open breeding (socialism) or winner-take-all (monarchy).

imh · 7 years ago
It'll reward the companies with the best groups of people, but not the best groups of companies, which I think the other comment was getting at.
imh commented on Reinforcement Learning: An Introduction (2018) [pdf]   incompleteideas.net/book/... · Posted by u/atomroflbomber
nafizh · 7 years ago
With all its hype in RL, I am yet to see significant real life problems solved with it. I am afraid with all the funding going into it, and nothing to show for except being able to play complex games, this might contribute to the mistrust in proper utilization of research funds. Also the reproducibility problem in RL is many times worse than in ML.
imh · 7 years ago
I'd bet that sample efficiency is a factor in translating they most hyped bits of RL into solving IRL problems. So many business problems translate to "Learn which of these things to do, as quickly and cheaply as possible."

u/imh

KarmaCake day3016June 9, 2014View Original