Readit News logoReadit News
greg_w commented on IBM Patented Euler's 200 Year Old Math Technique for 'AI Interpretability'   leetarxiv.substack.com/p/... · Posted by u/busymom0
Retric · a month ago
Patents go way back possibly as far as 500 BC, with other examples dating to 1331 etc, yet the introduction didn’t kick off any great wave of progress.

Instead a wide range of factors like better plants feeding both population growth and an ever larger percentage of society could do something other than grow food where the real root causes here. Devoting land and labor to cotton for example requires a surplus of food.

greg_w · a month ago
I would rather call the old iterations proto-patents. It took a while to get to a system where anyone can claim an invention as property and make it protected from "borrowing without permission" by law.
greg_w commented on IBM Patented Euler's 200 Year Old Math Technique for 'AI Interpretability'   leetarxiv.substack.com/p/... · Posted by u/busymom0
linuxhansl · a month ago
Software patents are mostly garbage and unneeded. And I say that having some in my name (I actually tried to get my name off them, but our lawyers said it's not possible).

Show me one useful software patent that (a) is not "obvious to one skilled in the art", and (b) benefits society by being granted a monopoly. Just one!

Software rarely requires expensive research that would be worth protecting. Rather than enabling a fair market, this takes fairness out of the market.

Software patents are like getting a patent on "Murder story with final revelation of who did it." Maybe add one or two features, like a "detective with hat", etc. In one fell swoop you would be able to own most murder mysteries.

Software (like books, stories, art, etc) is better handled by Copyright law. May the one who actually has a better product win!

Sorry for the rant.

greg_w · a month ago
One cannot (in the US) get a patent for software itself. This was settled a while ago. There needs to be more in the claims. In fact, the patent discussed here does not claim continued fractions and nobody would be in danger using them even if the patent issued as is (which is not certain, because the patent claims rather trivial modification of a classic neural network architecture, which should be brought up by the examiner as obvious).

Patents are propelling the society when they work as intended. They made XIX century and at least good chunk of XX century. Without patents, people fall back to copying each other, because it is much easier to copy than to innovate.

greg_w commented on Reticular Thalamic Activity and Autism Spectrum Disorders   science.org/doi/10.1126/s... · Posted by u/greg_w
greg_w · 3 months ago
From engineering viewpoint, reticular thalamic nucleus is like a gate modulating traffic between preprocessed input from thalamus (which could be sensory or inner thinking) and cerebral cortex. It makes sense that when it malfunctions brain might have problems to develop "correct" connectome. If the results of this study replicate in humans, this could be a cure for autism.

u/greg_w

KarmaCake day3August 29, 2025View Original