Readit News logoReadit News
dynamorando commented on Web Environment Integrity has no standing at W3C; understanding new W3C work   w3.org/blog/2023/web-envi... · Posted by u/TangerineDream
EGreg · 2 years ago
Back in 2014 I met with Tim Berners-Lee himself, and his SoLiD team, and proposed to join forces. Here is the pic: https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/Rp4Su5Z2h28vCASKfrbhYKrULG...

His team lead (Dmitry Zagidulin) liked what we were doing a lot. But ultimately Tim chose to go in a different direction, spun off "Inrupt" and left MIT. We continued building our open source platform to try to realize the vision he keeps writing about: https://theconversation.com/tim-berners-lees-plan-to-save-th...

I was writing very similar things, but of course I didn't invent the Web: https://cointelegraph.com/news/how-a-web-that-lost-its-way-c...

Ultimately, my point is that we tried our best. I even hired Dmitry when he left Tim's project for a while, but very quickly Dmitry got demotivated to work with us because we were putting out working code for customers, instead of conforming to standards. Back then I argued to him that we don't have a ton of funding and executions matters more, after which the winners can help spearhead the standards. After all, Twitter pioneered oAuth, and Meebo+Google pioneered xAuth (if anyone remembers that). Dmitri and I did.

So we went our separate ways, and I realized that standards are an expensive detour that can work if you have extra funds to hire people. We plan to support Matrix, Mastodon and other interoperability. But for the time being, our platform is "just" free and open source.

Whether it's the UBI "movement", or the decentralized web, or other initiatives, everyone seems to go their separate way and it fizzles out (e.g. https://decentralizedweb.net and https://indieweb.org/). I wish people were willing to join forces on projects more, and get each other funded. That's how we can build real open source alternatives to the corporate internet we are all forced to depend on.

dynamorando · 2 years ago
What project are you referring to?
dynamorando commented on Google engineers want to make ad-blocking (near) impossible   stackdiary.com/web-enviro... · Posted by u/pabs3
mozball · 2 years ago
Mozilla should really double down on Mozilla VPN. Judging by all the NordVPN ads on every major youtuber's video, the profit margins must be astronomical (or their business model must be suspicious). It should provide a good income stream for Mozilla. The entire space is shady and filled with dubious actors. It is just begging to be disrupted by a trustworthy organization.

I can't think of a single candidate other than Mozilla that has the technical expertise, experience, trust, reputation, resources (not to mention non-profit structure) built over 20 years defending the open web. I don't understand why Mozilla is dragging their feet on this. They should have owned the entire VPN market by now. VPNs aren't cryogenic rockets.

dynamorando · 2 years ago
Is the Mozilla organization generally responsive to social media? I have had a hard time trying to figure out where the organization responds to publicly, generally.

I would love to have a Mozilla hosted email and calendar service from them, for example. I don't understand why they aren't branching out into more common web citizen needed services.

dynamorando commented on Wind and solar will be 25% of U.S. generating capacity within three years   electricenergyonline.com/... · Posted by u/geox
ianburrell · 2 years ago
Wind and solar are complementary, solar during the day and wind at night.

In the short term, wind and solar provide power when they can and make up the difference with natural gas. That is much better than the current system of coal and natural gas. This extends to wind and solar providing all of the normal power. Then can have storage to cover the daily needs. There is no problem turning off wind and solar when not needed, but we will find ways to use the free power.

In the long term, we can have so much wind and solar capacity, I have seen 3 times load, to cover nearly all the time. The excess power will be needed for carbon capture and fuel production. For the rare times when renewables aren't enough, can use hydrogen or other generated fuels as backup.

dynamorando · 2 years ago
You seem to have some knowledge in this area. I'm curious your thoughts on Enhanced Geothermal?

https://www.cnbc.com/2023/07/18/fervo-energy-hits-milestone-...

dynamorando commented on Wind and solar will be 25% of U.S. generating capacity within three years   electricenergyonline.com/... · Posted by u/geox
dynamorando · 2 years ago
I realize that this article is about Wind + Solar, but given this breakthrough, can anyone who is an authority on the subject explain if EGS is also set to take off?

https://www.cnbc.com/2023/07/18/fervo-energy-hits-milestone-...

dynamorando commented on Ask HN: Anyone using or working on a life dashboard?    · Posted by u/helghardt
sdfzguf · 2 years ago
To create a space that holds together information of a varity of data (types, format, unit, etc). This would enable a more holistic approach to themes that include multiple points of content, which itself can be linked to several themes.

Example: Download a PDF of a book. Read it. Notes derive from that. Those notes can concern a diary, quote for some other work, inspiration for art, language learning, etc. The book itself can contain text, data entries, tabular, photo, etc.

There is a multitude of possibilities to find categories for every aspect of this 'idea'. The goal is to find a (not 'the') abstraction to handle data so it is possible to work with it. As someone already mentioned, even if such a system can be found, it is unclear if this would make it easier to work with all it contains, than how we do it conventionally.

Addit: DevonThink comes closest to what I described.

dynamorando · 2 years ago
So to me, this sounds more like building a personal knowledge base. Not a dashboard IMO.

How does this differ from other note taking apps like Obsidian?

dynamorando commented on Ask HN: Anyone using or working on a life dashboard?    · Posted by u/helghardt
sdfzguf · 2 years ago
I've thought about this for years at this point. But I haven't compiled all my thoughts into a coherent system. So I can't share anything with substance :/ It's just a dump for bullet points as of now. Also, I'm not a technical person (yet).

I haven't looked into Org mode, but this might include all you (we) need.

dynamorando · 2 years ago
What is the end state here? A way to measure personal life KPIs? Or just building a dak board?
dynamorando commented on Web Environment Integrity API Proposal   github.com/RupertBenWiser... · Posted by u/reactormonk
dynamorando · 2 years ago
Bring back AOL!
dynamorando commented on In 1961 a Gallup poll showed only 33% of Americans in favor of moon landing   newsletter.pessimistsarch... · Posted by u/headalgorithm
dynamorando · 2 years ago
I realize that there's a million obvious answers; but as I type this in the part of the country currently roasting by the heatwave in the United States: will something like this ever happen for climate efforts?
dynamorando commented on Tim Berners-Lee’s new internet   brownstoneresearch.com/bl... · Posted by u/hhs
imiric · 2 years ago
I don't see how anything you said makes it a bad idea. I'm not deeply familiar with how Solid works, but if the goal is to put users in control of their own data, this is worth pursuing. Self-hosting is only accessible to technical users, and decentralized web apps are an improvement over the status quo, but in practice users can still choose to give up their rights to a 3rd party.

What TBL is trying to do is commendable, and it's something that should've been built into the web from the beginning, so Solid feels like him trying to correct his past mistakes. Though I'm afraid that it might be too late to do course correction on the modern ad-powered web behemoth, and that a web reboot would be necessary for this to gain any traction at all.

> Just because a guy comes up with a good thing once doesn't mean his next thing needs to be covered ad nauseum on his personal brand name alone.

Ad nauseum? The coverage of this is severely limited, and even the technical discussion around it, as you can see on this forum.

Yes, this probably shouldn't ride on his brand name alone, but maybe it's worth listening to the father of the web when he says that his invention has gone astray.

dynamorando · 2 years ago
One thing that frustrates me is that Solid relies on Linked Data; and working with Linked Data, at least in my experience, is frustrating.

u/dynamorando

KarmaCake day23January 31, 2022View Original