Readit News logoReadit News
digbybk commented on The new science of “emergent misalignment”   quantamagazine.org/the-ai... · Posted by u/nsoonhui
bigyabai · 11 days ago
FWIW, I agree with the parent comment's rebuttal. Simply saying "AI could be bad" is nothing Asimov or Roddenbury didn't figure out themselves.

For Elizer to really deign novelty here, he'd have predicted the reason why this happens at all: training data. Instead he played the Chomsky card and insisted on deeper patterns that don't exist (as well as solutions that don't work). Namedropping Elizer's research as a refutation is weak bordering on disingenuous.

digbybk · 11 days ago
What were the deeper patterns that don't exist?
digbybk commented on Why are there so many rationalist cults?   asteriskmag.com/issues/11... · Posted by u/glenstein
ivm · 14 days ago
None of them are practicing Buddhist meditation though, same for the "personal growth" oriented meditation styles.

Buddhist meditation exists only in the context of the Four Noble Truths and the rest of the Buddha's Dhamma. Throwing them away means it stops being Buddhist.

digbybk · 14 days ago
I disagree, but we'd be arguing semantics. In any case, the point still stands: you can just as easily argue that these rationalist offshoots aren't really Rationalist.
digbybk commented on Why are there so many rationalist cults?   asteriskmag.com/issues/11... · Posted by u/glenstein
digbybk · 14 days ago
When I was looking for a group in my area to meditate with, it was tough finding one that didn't appear to be a cult. And yet I think Buddhist meditation is the best tool for personal growth humanity has ever devised. Maybe the proliferation of cults is a sign that Yudkowsky was on to something.
digbybk commented on "The Illusion of Thinking" – Thoughts on This Important Paper   hardcoresoftware.learning... · Posted by u/rbanffy
jmsdnns · 2 months ago
> just code and math either

this is literally what they are

digbybk · 2 months ago
I think it’s the “just” that they are taking issue with. We are “just” neurons. But we demonstrate interesting emergent behaviors that, in principle, can be reduced to firing neurons but in practice we don’t understand and shouldn’t diminish with the word “just”.
digbybk commented on Changes since congestion pricing started in New York   nytimes.com/interactive/2... · Posted by u/Vinnl
philipallstar · 3 months ago
The increased speeds are excellent for those who can afford the toll. This is a universal benefit of toll roads for those people.
digbybk · 3 months ago
Also excellent for those public transport riders who can't afford car ownership.
digbybk commented on Evolving OpenAI's Structure   openai.com/index/evolving... · Posted by u/rohitpaulk
CorpOverreach · 4 months ago
I'd really love to talk to someone that both really believes this to be true, and has a hands-on experience with building and using generative AI.

The intersection of the two seems to be quite hard to find.

At the state that we're in the AIs we're building are just really useful input/output devices that respond to a stimuli (e.g., a "prompt"). No stimuli, no output.

This isn't a nuclear weapon. We're not going to accidentally create Skynet. The only thing it's going to go nuclear on is the market for jobs that are going to get automated in an economy that may not be ready for it.

If anything, the "danger" here is that AGI is going to be a printing press. A cotton gin. A horseless carriage -- all at the same time and then some, into a world that may not be ready for it economically.

Progress of technology should not be artitrarily held back to protect automateable jobs though. We need to adapt.

digbybk · 4 months ago
> I'd really love to talk to someone that both really believes this to be true, and has a hands-on experience with building and using generative AI.

Any of the signatories here match your criteria? https://safe.ai/work/statement-on-ai-risk#signatories

Or if you’re talking more about everyday engineers working in the field, I suspect the people soldering vacuum tubes to the ENIAC would not necessarily have been the same people with the clearest vision for the future of the computer.

digbybk commented on NYC home prices rise 10% in early 2025   qns.com/2025/04/home-pric... · Posted by u/geox
readthenotes1 · 4 months ago
If we are going for a reductivism, I'm going to take it all the way to pride, greed, and envy for the housing supply problem.

(I could throw in lust, but that's last century's problem since various forms of birth control have negated its influence on housing demand)

digbybk · 4 months ago
Changing human pride, greed and envy is hard. We know how to build housing. Or we used to.
digbybk commented on Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for repeat speeders   fastcompany.com/91323835/... · Posted by u/jmpfrog
jampekka · 4 months ago
Cars are also indirectly a huge cause of early death due to health problems caused by sedentary lifestyle.
digbybk · 4 months ago
I agree with you but addressing that wouldn't be a goal of this particular policy.
digbybk commented on Virginia passes law to enforce maximum vehicle speeds for repeat speeders   fastcompany.com/91323835/... · Posted by u/jmpfrog
hermannj314 · 4 months ago
I am fully in support of making cars or mopeds or all travel safer.

The US government and state governments are openly hostile to our residents and currently implementing massive mechanisms to track and control our population including our immigrant communities, women who need access to birth control, LGBTQ communities .

The government wanting a system that requires GPS and speed information to allow law enforcement to remotely control the movement of undesirable activities is the obvious goal here.

digbybk · 4 months ago
Cars are the leading cause of death of children in the US. More than cancer. Maybe you're right, I don't know, but it's not the "obvious goal".
digbybk commented on I analyzed chord progressions in 680k songs   cantgetmuchhigher.com/p/i... · Posted by u/jnord
digbybk · 4 months ago
I’m having a hard time believing power chords only account for 5.8% of chords in metal.

u/digbybk

KarmaCake day507May 4, 2021View Original