Readit News logoReadit News
desas commented on UK government states that 'safety' act is about influence over public discourse   bsky.app/profile/tupped.b... · Posted by u/JoshTriplett
khalic · 4 months ago
Yeah that’s why I was making the parallel
desas · 4 months ago
Oh thanks for clearing that up, I misunderstood on my previous read.
desas commented on UK government states that 'safety' act is about influence over public discourse   bsky.app/profile/tupped.b... · Posted by u/JoshTriplett
khalic · 4 months ago
Ok I don’t know enough about this political system to contribute on that, there are some political systems built like that, like the US.
desas · 4 months ago
The same thing applies in the US doesn't it? There has essentially only been two political parties (three if you squint hard enough) for nearly the entire existence of the country?
desas commented on UK government states that 'safety' act is about influence over public discourse   bsky.app/profile/tupped.b... · Posted by u/JoshTriplett
GeoAtreides · 4 months ago
I will argue that the UK doesn't have a Constitution and that's because of this one thing: No parliament can bind a future parliament. A Constitution is exactly this: a contract binding all future Parliaments to a specific set of axioms that must be respected.
desas · 4 months ago
The US constitution is very similar, except in two important regards: amendments require two thirds majority votes in both houses and ratification by 75% of the states.

We don't have the state mechanism. You could argue the four nations could serve a similar purpose, though there's a debate about how democratic that is when England makes up something like 85% of the UK population (and doesn't have its own legislature).

desas commented on Online Safety Act – shutdowns and site blocks   blocked.org.uk/osa-blocks... · Posted by u/azalemeth
blisstonia · 4 months ago
Anyone know why news.ycombinator.com hasn't fallen foul of this legislation?
desas · 4 months ago
To "fall foul", i.e. be required to add highly effective age assurance, there's a number of tests you have to pass

One of the tests is:

> Are there a significant number of children using the service or is the service likely to attract a significant number of children.

I'd guess that HN would be in scope for the act overall - they provide user-to-user functionality and have a lot of users in the UK. Either they answer no to the questions above, or they answer yes and should have performed a risk assessment where they look at things like what kind of content is allowed, how the site is moderated, how do users contact each other etc etc.

desas commented on VPN use surges in UK as new online safety rules kick in   ft.com/content/356674b0-9... · Posted by u/mmarian
alias_neo · 5 months ago
> childcare vouchers before tax

I wasn't aware of this, I'll take a look and see if it applies thanks.

The pension route is the way I've gone to deal with it, but it doesn't fix the issue of "my bills are going up while my income can't". I'm sure retired me will be glad for it if it makes it that far, and we don't somehow end up being taxed to the hilt on _that_ too when we eventually get there.

EDIT: does > doesn't

desas · 5 months ago
The childcare voucher scheme closed to new entrants in 2018.
desas commented on Tram Trains   worksinprogress.news/p/tr... · Posted by u/ortegaygasset
Animats · 5 months ago
London? London has 13 major railroad stations and they're all dead ends.[1] Crossrail, with expensive tunnels, now provides some east-west through services.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Major_railway_stations_...

desas · 5 months ago
> Terminating a train and turning it around takes a lot of space, space that is usually unavailable in a city center.

This doesn't happen in London in my experience. Trains don't turn around, instead every train is double-ended. The driver gets out of the cab at the terminus, walks to the other end of the train and gets in the other cab. They can do it faster than the passengers disembark.

desas commented on Tram Trains   worksinprogress.news/p/tr... · Posted by u/ortegaygasset
kposehn · 5 months ago
> The low density of Charlotte means a transport network like Munich’s is not viable, but the city could take its pre-existing light rail network and join it up to the extensive network of railroad lines around the city that are currently used only for moving freight.

This is not a feasible option due to the vast difference in crashworthiness standards between US freight rail and other system types such as light rail. The FRA actually prohibits allowing these two types on the same network of tracks at the same time. However, they could use a line along the right-of-way were it big enough to accommodate another set of tracks.

desas · 5 months ago
Is there a reason you couldn't build new light rail trains to a higher level of crashworthiness than they are currently? I don't know the full details, but that's how tram-trains in Sheffield, UK were allowed access to the main railway network.
desas commented on How to Read a Novel   adjacentpossible.substack... · Posted by u/ingve
happytoexplain · 7 months ago
To be clear first: The parent is being a little unreasonable.

However.

There's no need to resort to insults, nor to use a single person as an example, which doesn't make sense, regardless of whether it's their "only hobby".

Average novel reading speed is an impossible metric. E.g. WPM measurements are irrelevant to long-form reading, are irrelevant to literary reading, and don't account for processing, tangential thought, or re-reading, which are of course highly variable. And "reading time" (the subset of free time conducive to literary reading) is also basically impossible to quantify broadly. It's also difficult to categorize people by how much they are trying to read. Some people are only a little interested, some not at all. Further, this is one of those fields where the super-humans aren't actually that rare, so you get a situation where the average person reads 8 books per year despite half of all people reading half a book per year (made up numbers).

Point of all that being, "novels a year" is one of the most culturally acceptable brags, because there is no "expected" value for people broadly. It's a hidden value, so we can say things like "yeah, I read 12 books a year, not a lot I know", and people generally won't roll their eyes at risk of appearing stupid.

Look at how many people on otherwise-rational HN are saying "I used to read 30 novels a year," "I used to read a novel a week," as if that means it must be easy to accomplish in Western work and life culture. We're drunk on the ease of implicitly painting people who can't read as much as us as simply dumb modern westerners.

I think it's an easy thing to do, and we shouldn't. It's not classy.

desas · 6 months ago
> We're drunk on the ease of implicitly painting people who can't read as much as us as simply dumb modern westerners.

I'm not sure we're doing that. That's certainly not my intention. I know and respect many people who read zero books per year.

I think what we're doing is showing surprise that reading ten books per year is seen as a flex or is worth lying about very publicly, and demonstrating (albeit unscientifically) that it's not that unusual.

desas commented on How to Read a Novel   adjacentpossible.substack... · Posted by u/ingve
pickledoyster · 7 months ago
the single takeaway from this book ad of a post: the CEO of Stripe claims to have read 10 novels/yr. Which is either a boast of how much free time he has or how he skimmed through some major novels. Third option: a lie.
desas · 7 months ago
This is a ludicrous take. I was on vacation last week and read three books, albeit not weighty novels. I can't remember when I read as few as 10 novels per year. I'm not a CEO, but reading is also far from my only hobby.
desas commented on I wrote to the address in the GPLv2 license notice (2022)   code.mendhak.com/gpl-v2-a... · Posted by u/ekiauhce
globular-toast · 8 months ago
As far as I know there are still some things you have to post in the UK, like sending your cut up old driver's licence to the DVLA and maybe you still have to post your V5 when you sell a car. OP might not own a car or drive, though, so who knows?
desas · 8 months ago
V5Cs have been online for 3-4 years now.

You still have to send back your cut up old driver's license, though I have my doubts that someone is sat there checking and cross referencing each one they receive.

u/desas

KarmaCake day933November 6, 2011View Original