Readit News logoReadit News
deorder commented on My experience with Claude Code after two weeks of adventures   sankalp.bearblog.dev/my-c... · Posted by u/dejavucoder
ianberdin · 8 months ago
Reading all these glowing reviews of Claude Code, I still get the feeling that either everyone’s been paid off or it’s just the die-hard fans of terminal windows and editors like Emacs and Vim. Using the terminal is right up their alley—it’s in their DNA.

Every time I read comments saying Claude Code is far better than Cursor, I fire it up, pay for a subscription, and run it on a large, complex TypeScript codebase. First, the whole process takes a hell of a lot of time. Second, the learning curve is steep: you have to work through the terminal and type commands.

And the outcome is exactly the same as with the Claude that’s built into Cursor—only slower, less clear, and the generated code is harder to review afterward. I don’t know… At this point my only impression is that all those influencers in the comments are either sponsored, or they’ve already shelled out their $200 and are now defending their choice. Or they simply haven’t used Cursor enough to figure out how to get the most out of it.

I still can’t see any real advantage to Claude Code, other than supposedly higher limits. I don’t get it. I’ve already paid for Claude Code, and I’m also paying for Cursor Pro, which is another $200, but I’m more productive with Cursor so far.

I’ve been programming for 18 years, write a ton of code every single day, and I can say Cursor gives me more. I switch between Gemini 2.5 Pro—when I need to handle tasks with a big, long context—and Claude 4.0 for routine stuff.

So no one has convinced me yet, and I haven’t seen any other benefit. Maybe later… I don’t know.

deorder · 8 months ago
I am a software developer with over 25 years of professional experience and have been working with coding agents for quite some time starting with AutoGPT and now using Claude Code almost 24/7 orchestrated via Task Master to automatically spin up new instances working on a multi layer project.

You are absolutely right. A large portion are influencers (I would estimate around 95% of those you see on YouTube and forums) that are full of hype. I think most are not affiliated with Anthropic or any vendor, they are just trying to sell a course, ebook or some "get rich with AI" scheme.

What I appreciate about Claude Code:

- Since it is a terminal/CLI tool it can be run headlessly from cron jobs or scripts. This makes it easy to automate.

- I appreciate the predictable pricing model. A flat monthly fee gives me access to Claude Sonnet and Opus 4 in five-hour sessions each with its own usage limit that resets at the start of a new session. There is a fair use policy of around 50 sessions per month, but I haven’t hit that yet. I deliberately run only one instance at a time as I prefer to use it responsibly unlike some of the "vibe" influencers who seem to push it to the limit.

That's it. Despite being a CLI based tool, Claude Code is remarkably out of the box for what it offers.

That said, no coding agent I have encountered can fully ingest a large inconsistent legacy codebase especially one with mixed architectures that accumulated over years. This limitation is mainly due to context size constraints, but I expect this to improve as context windows grow.

deorder commented on Andy Warhol's lost Amiga art found   dfarq.homeip.net/andy-war... · Posted by u/todsacerdoti
LocalH · 2 years ago
I'm pretty sure he used a pre-release version of Graphicraft, running on a pre-release Kickstart and AmigaDOS (so early that it predated Workbench).
deorder · 2 years ago
Thanks. It seems you're right. I started with the first Deluxe Paint myself back then and always incorrectly thought he used it based on the videos I saw.
deorder commented on Andy Warhol's lost Amiga art found   dfarq.homeip.net/andy-war... · Posted by u/todsacerdoti
deorder · 2 years ago
From what I remember he used Deluxe Paint and the color cycle feature to change the color palette around.
deorder commented on Tell HN: YouTube's web UI just got even worse    · Posted by u/Pooge
deorder · 3 years ago
Lately I often have trouble finding the date/time a youtube video was posted. Sometimes I find it when I open the description box, but not always.
deorder commented on Lua, a Misunderstood Language (2021)   andregarzia.com/2021/01/l... · Posted by u/synergy20
amai · 3 years ago
The world would be better if we had Lua in our browsers instead of Javascript.
deorder · 3 years ago
They are both prototype-based languages influenced by Self.
deorder commented on I've said it all before but here we go again   backreaction.blogspot.com... · Posted by u/paulmooreparks
bjornsing · 3 years ago
I only have a master in (engineering) physics but working with statistical modeling and AI I’ve come to appreciate the “all models are wrong but some models are useful”-mindset, and I’ve started applying that to physical “laws” as well: I no longer see them as some divine truths waiting to be discovered, but more like models of the world that will always be wrong but sometimes useful.

From that point of view what’s happening in physics today is no surprise, but it is a bit depressing: we’ve probably passed the level of complexity where models are useful and are now adding detail that make them less so. I guess you can see it as a form of overfitting, like when less scrupulous AI researchers use the test set for validation.

deorder · 3 years ago
That is similar to how I see it. The currently accepted physics may just be at a local minima, but not at the global minima.
deorder commented on Yahoo admits mangling e-mail (2002)   news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/scien... · Posted by u/Andoryuuta
mr-ron · 4 years ago
Tangent related to this. I had an old yahoo mail address from late 90s till mid 00s before I switched to gmail. Lots of family / high school / college / early professional emails were there.

The other month I logged in to view them as I do every so often and yahoo had purged the entire archive. Like 20MB worth of emails gone.

Apparently they have a policy if you do not log in in a year of time they will delete everything with no way to recover.

I can’t imagine the decision making to put this policy in nor could I ever imagine using yahoo email again for any purpose whatsoever.

deorder · 4 years ago
The same thing happened to me and I'm still sick of it. I lost a lot of emails from the beginning of my career. I found out when I finally got around to backing up my old stuff. There are still a lot of emails that I wish I still had. I know it is / was a free service, but still.
deorder commented on GitHub Copilot is generally available   github.blog/2022-06-21-gi... · Posted by u/sammorrowdrums
DustinBrett · 4 years ago
Also, $10/mo is not so bad but I am not in the place right now for more subscriptions. I am in the process of stopping several at the moment.
deorder · 4 years ago
Same here. With prices rising everywhere and a salary of ~40k euros before taxes (which is normal in IT in many EU countries if you don't work for big tech) I hardly have room for another subscription. People here are too quick to say "what is $10 on a $80/hour salary?"
deorder commented on Save money on Next.js image optimization   dmitry-ishkov.com/2022/02... · Posted by u/therusskiy
deorder · 4 years ago
I was planning to do this myself. Thanks for the article. I am ok with the code dump :D

Right now I am using nginx with the image_filter module + caching to do this.

Deleted Comment

u/deorder

KarmaCake day167June 2, 2017View Original