Readit News logoReadit News
czatt commented on Andrew Ng: The suspension of H1B is bad for the US and bad for innovation   twitter.com/AndrewYNg/sta... · Posted by u/melenaboija
jimbob45 · 6 years ago
The other poster was remarkably rude for no reason. I’d say that you don’t really want an H1B though. What you want is a concrete and easily accessible path to citizenship that takes your high-skilled degree into account. To that end, I would support broader immigration reform rather than trying to fix the irredeemable H1B program.
czatt · 6 years ago
I 100% agree with your statement. But for now, all that was done was suspend H1Bs without a viable measure that would create a path to citizenship (or just settlement) via a high-skilled degree. So it seems like a step backwards and very disheartening.
czatt commented on Andrew Ng: The suspension of H1B is bad for the US and bad for innovation   twitter.com/AndrewYNg/sta... · Posted by u/melenaboija
czatt · 6 years ago
As an intended MBA applicant for the class of 2021, the recent uncertainty around H1B visas makes me very uneasy and disappointed. I was forced to leave the U.S. back in 2016 despite having an investment banking job and paying meaningful taxes, which was incredibly frustrating. I was hoping for another shot at living and working in the US after completing an MBA, and now it looks like there either won't be a chance or it will be at best a shot in the dark. I am now seriously considering avoiding U.S. schools altogether and applying for top business schools in Europe such as LBS and INSEAD.
czatt commented on Ask HN: HNers, where do you hang out online in your spare time?    · Posted by u/bryk
czatt · 6 years ago
Oh, so many places! I generally do a lot of reading.

I love longform.org whenever I have more than 30min to spare and am looking for deeper reading.

Farnam Street (fs.blog) has some really great content on mental models and tools.

I'm slowly reading through 80000hours.org, which covers how to re-think your career to solve the world's "biggest problems"

waitbutwhy.com has some fun long posts on random topics, and is currently doing a lengthy series called "The Story of Us" about the development of ideas, primarily in the U.S.

And if I feel like going on a wikipedia loophole, I go to explodingtopics.com/ (which I first saw in a ShowHN!) and google the top results for the past month.

czatt commented on Ask HN: Someone is using my email account to sign up for random websites    · Posted by u/czatt
mtmail · 6 years ago
I'm on the opposite side. A script setting up accounts on our website where clearly the name and email address (and timezone and IP address) don't fit together to get users to click those link in confirmation emails.

Best theory we have is they want to identify users who click on anything to send them a real scam later.

Very annoying.

czatt · 6 years ago
Ugh. I wonder if there is anything I can do that is not just sitting and waiting for them to stop.

I hope I don't have to get rid of my gmail! Alternative is to come up with a way to filter those straight to spam, I guess..?

czatt commented on Ask HN: How far along is the development of AI for reading medical scans?    · Posted by u/czatt
davismwfl · 6 years ago
Oh the fun. Yes, there are some solutions being tested for specific types of scans and specific diagnosis, but not nearly enough is operational yet.

My "short" answer: There are a number of people/companies researching AI for medical scans/records, but it is true that finding enough properly documented and labeled scans/images/records etc is hard. Privacy laws also add a fairly high burden which makes the research hard, the privacy laws/rules are needed but sometimes they are more about adding road blocks than actually protecting anyone's privacy.

Another part to getting good training sources is in more complex scenarios there isn't always one answer for a given scan, or it is possible multiple issues can be found. So it is hard sometimes to isolate the specific issue in some scans which adds complexity. Add to this that if you have 4 medically trained people read the scan independently and without influence you will generally get different answers to all but the simplest diagnosis.

There are places in medicine that are easier and where more consistency is available and that is where the current set of most algorithms and work is being done. Some things are also easier to box into categories than others, so again that makes them lower hanging fruit which is what I see happening right now. All that said, to bring product to commercial market is the largest gap IMO, lots of companies/people have researched and built tools/algorithms/models but few have cleared the FDA in the U.S. I'd say the biggest hurdle right now is bringing products to commercialization and understanding how to do so.

As for most current AI: Most of what is commercially available is not predictive and instead is used as aids in finding missed data points that might change the diagnosis or highlight something specific for treatment. For example, there are some that highlight fractures that would otherwise be missed by a radiologist reading an x-ray. Same thing for CT/MRI scans where sometimes literally thousands of images are generated for a single scan and missing something is not unheard of. More work has been done around imagery analysis than on most other parts of the patient record IMO, so you'll find more data around that side than you would around vitals analysis or predictive diagnostics.

Honestly I could go on about this for a long time. This is an area ripe for innovation but has regulatory hurdles most startups fail to grasp and fail to navigate.

I am the CTO for a startup that is working on these types of problems (vitals & predictive specifically), we have one FDA cleared product and see many opportunities to make a positive impact on patient care.

czatt · 6 years ago
Thank you for the response! This seems to be a sector that could highly benefit from AI development, especially given the number of required medical scans is steadily increasing and the number of qualified radiologists is declining in most countries. Given you are in the sector, could you share the names of a few companies / startups that you think are making the most progress?

u/czatt

KarmaCake day37November 13, 2019View Original