Readit News logoReadit News
culot commented on Police in Minnesota round up journalists and take pictures of their faces   usatoday.com/story/news/n... · Posted by u/joe_the_user
newacct583 · 4 years ago
...hence these very protests. And thus the outsized extra-legal response.

This is a gang war, fundamentally. Cops view the protest movement as an existential threat (and strictly, they're not wrong) and are going to use whatever tools they can find to fight it. They aren't trying to enforce the law, they're trying to put down their enemies.

culot · 4 years ago
Don't the police already use kid gloves to handle most of the situations? I've been watching livestreams of these for a solid year now and that seems to be a common theme: the police are in general far nicer and accommodating than they could be or even should be.

The dramatic brush you're painting this with is extremely unrealistic.

culot commented on Police in Minnesota round up journalists and take pictures of their faces   usatoday.com/story/news/n... · Posted by u/joe_the_user
ahD5zae7 · 4 years ago
> [...] temporary order barring the Minnesota State Patrol from using physical force or chemical agents against journalists

I'm sorry, I'm not from USA, can somebody explain why it has _just_ been _temporarily_ banned to use "force or chemical agents" against journalists? I was under the impression that using such things against journalists was banned a long time ago in most of the developed countries, what with the freedom of the press and so on... Is Minesotta an exception here? Or USA?

culot · 4 years ago
There have been many cases of rioters claiming press credentials in attempts to bypass responsibility for criminal activity. "I'm not with mob of rioters attempting to burn down that courthouse, I'm a journalist. See, look on my helmet - P R E S S."

I think that was common in Portland over the last year.

culot commented on A Distinctly American Problem, Police Killings, Needs Systematic Investigation   theatlantic.com/ideas/arc... · Posted by u/CapitalistCartr
pksebben · 4 years ago
I would love to read your sources. can you provide them?
culot · 4 years ago
I had previously referenced the Washington Post's police shootings database, but that is now paywalled. I was referring to that stats stating that of the roughly 1000 police killings in 2019, something like 50 involved unarmed suspects. Of those 50, almost all of them involved those suspects attacking the police and lethal force being justified.

The Botham Jeans and Daniel Shavers, as horrifically egregious as those cases are, are relatively rare.

culot commented on A Distinctly American Problem, Police Killings, Needs Systematic Investigation   theatlantic.com/ideas/arc... · Posted by u/CapitalistCartr
jnwatson · 4 years ago
America has the highest rate of incarceration in the world. The historical reduction in crime started before 1994, so there's not good evidence for a causal connection (controversially, Dubner and Levitt in Freakonomics argued it was Roe v Wade that was largely responsible).

Regardless, any system by which 8 percent of adult black men are in prison clearly has bigger problems. It would be much cheaper to tackle the problem at its source: structural racism and poverty.

culot · 4 years ago
- Define 'structural racism' and why it forces blacks to be far more criminal and violent than the rest of the population.

- Can poverty explain, for example, why blacks in Wisconsin commit 2/3 of all violent crime while they are only 7% of the state's population? There are wholly White and Native American cities in Wisconsin that are dirt poor - the poorest - and yet they are not committing insanely high levels of crime.

culot commented on A Distinctly American Problem, Police Killings, Needs Systematic Investigation   theatlantic.com/ideas/arc... · Posted by u/CapitalistCartr
gnu8 · 4 years ago
A better term for it might be “Police Lynching”. Most of these incidents seem to revolve around a black (but not necessarily) person failing to show the correct level of subservience to a police officer and provoking a visceral reaction of extreme violence. Not saying all of them are racist, but to some police, everyone is the wrong color (not blue).
culot · 4 years ago
>A better term for it might be “Police Lynching”.

No, it wouldn't. That is unnecessary hyperbole. Unjustified police killings, instances where the police were at fault, are a rarity. The big problem here is not lack of police training nor overreach, but violent, uncooperative suspects.

>failing to show the correct level of subservience

While there are some grotesque examples of that, like with Daniel Shaver, most police killings, the overwhelming majority of them, are due to them being attacked by someone or being confronted with an armed suspect who refuses to disarm.

>Not saying all of them are racist, but to some police, everyone is the wrong color (not blue).

Are there any actual instances of racism being the driving impetus for police killings at any time in recent decades? I cannot think of any offhand.

culot commented on Reuters website goes behind paywall in new strategy   reuters.com/article/us-th... · Posted by u/uptown
tootie · 4 years ago
Lol, Fox has never won a Pulitzer and for good reason. They run propaganda in prime time every single night. Roger Ailes was a bona fide conspiracy nut: https://www.axios.com/john-boehner-book-ted-cruz-fox-news-a1...

NY Times has been in operation for 170 years and has made a few mistakes. There is just no comparison. They are best news source in the country bar none.

culot · 4 years ago
>They run propaganda in prime time every single night.

All major news outlets run propaganda - not just in prime time, but all of the time. That is their job. The NY Times does have the privilege of being one of the primary establishment press outfits, resulting in their main aim being setting the tone for propaganda outfits around the nation and throughout much of the western world.

If you want to know which way the wind is blowing inside the FBI or CIA, the NY Times is where you go.

To compare them to Fox is pointless, as Fox does little to no print journalism. NY Times excels in [often overly-]lengthy, well-written articles, whereas I don't think Fox has ever done much more than briefs and blurbs.

culot commented on Bezos says Amazon needs to do better for employees in last letter as CEO   reuters.com/business/bezo... · Posted by u/lsllc
warent · 4 years ago
This strikes me as very similar to an abusive, narcissistic person miraculously having a change of heart and wanting to mend the path of destruction behind them after being diagnosed with a terminal illness.

Here we see Bezos hurriedly trying to patch up his horrendous legacy with an empty letter. Too little too late. Hopefully peoples' memories aren't so short to forget that he's been nothing but the encyclopedic example of greed.

culot · 4 years ago
This made-for-TV change of heart might indicate he'll be joining the league of superwealthy philanthropists like Bill Gates and George Soros who leave their lengthy, extraordinarily and unforgivably damaging lives of evil behind to become a power for good. I mean, surely that is exactly what this means.

>Hopefully peoples' memories aren't so short

Who has time for thinking when Marvel Megahero Show #34 has 3000 new episodes to binge? Besides, he's donating to or even directing all the Right Causes now! He's like a real life superhero.

culot commented on Azimuth unlocked iPhone at center of legal battle between the FBI and Apple   washingtonpost.com/techno... · Posted by u/ajay-d
jb12 · 4 years ago
A lot of journalists just assumed that Israelis unlocked the phone. They should do some introspection as to why they had that assumption.
culot · 4 years ago
Azimuth is a Unit 8200 shop, just as Cellebrite is. So, yes, still an Israeli outfit.
culot commented on Will.i.am Debuts Innovative Face Technology Concept, Xupermask   xupermask.com/... · Posted by u/laurex
moftz · 4 years ago
What's the plan for in a year or two when no one is wearing a mask anymore? Seems like an overly complicated solution to a simple problem.
culot · 4 years ago
I don't think there's any indication that mask requirement will abate anytime soon. All posturing from western leadership point to precisely the opposite. The notion that the mask requirement will disappear in as early as 1-2 years is farcically optimistic.
culot commented on Black Girls Code   blackgirlscode.com/... · Posted by u/doener
tehwebguy · 4 years ago
That's great! Sadly, our constitution did not outlaw the extremely common practice of enslaving Black people until the 13th amendment, which was only ratified in 1865.

In the hundreds of years prior to that most everyone else in the country was allowed to acquire land, wealth and an education while the enslaved folks were legally blocked from doing the same. It took nearly another ~100 years for their right to vote to be marginally protected and to finally end legal segregation, that was less than one generation ago so you can imagine that the inequity here won't match that of every other country.

culot · 4 years ago
Your snarky, condescending post most definitely goes against HN rules. You did not attempt engage the parent, you did not address the content of their post whatsoever, instead, in a sarcastic tone, resorted to preaching a total aside.

u/culot

KarmaCake day513March 9, 2017View Original