Readit News logoReadit News
crimsoneer commented on Pro-democracy HK tycoon Jimmy Lai convicted in national security trial   bbc.com/news/articles/cp8... · Posted by u/onemoresoop
skippyboxedhero · 2 days ago
...i am confused. Yes, we do understand why.

The UK choosing to shut down most of its native financial sector is a good example. With RBS it was particularly mad because the government ended up being a massive shareholder and then they chose to shut down all the profitable parts of the business, and double-down on the worst parts. Natwest rates franchise was probably worth £5bn, they basically shut the unit down in entirety (and a lot of those people went to large hedge funds and just went back to generating hundreds in millions in revenue) meaning that the taxpayer lost tens of billions AND the economy was knee-capped for decades.

This is taken as an example to show that even when the incentives were there, the government took a decision for nakedly political reasons. In the opposite direction, they folded HBOS into Lloyds, this was done to protect Scotland (both the PM and the Chancellor had a large number of constituents who would have lost their job if these banks were shut down...they were bailed out) and the result was Lloyds needing a bailout about one year after the banking crisis ended in the US. Again, this was sold to the public as the result of "risky casino bankers on huge bonuses"...in reality, it was just poorly paid commercial bankers lending very large amounts of money to people who couldn't ever it pay back AND politicians then making terrible choices with other people's money to boost their chances in some byelection no-one remembers.

This attitude permeates almost everything the UK does. Schools, politics first. Healthcare, politics first. Electricity, politics first.

I genuinely do not understand how anyone can't look at the scale of political intervention into the economy in the UK and not understand why this might lead to lower growth than the US. In Scotland, the government is 60% of the economy, this higher than Communist states with no legal private sector, it is an incredible number. If you look at income distribution, after-tax income under £100k is as flat or flatter than Communist states too, again this is incredible.

What is surprising is that the UK's economy is growing so quickly. The supply-side in most sectors is almost completely gone, in some economically-significant sectors you have regulators effectively managing companies, very few workers have economically useful skills because of the strong incentives in place to acquire non-economic skills...and the economy is still growing faster than most of Europe. To be fair, almost all of that immigration of low-skilled labour into the UK which is going to be absolute time-bomb financially and the rapid growth in public-sector pay has also helped consumption (even more so, the UK is running a deficit of 5% of GDP with revenues growing 4%/year in an economy that is shrinking in per capita terms...obviously, this is not sustainable)...but growth is still way higher than reason would dictate.

Comparing this to the US is not serious in any way. You have a country that prioritises growth beyond reason and are comparing that with a country which is hostile to change beyond reason. There is no possible comparison. The decisions every government since 1997 has made have been intended to reduce growth, people happily voted for this, and are now upset that the economy is shit...why?

crimsoneer · 5 hours ago
but then why was our GDP growth essentially identical (if not exceeding) the US between 1997 and 2008?
crimsoneer commented on Coursera to combine with Udemy   investor.coursera.com/new... · Posted by u/throwaway019254
crimsoneer · 5 hours ago
This feels like another nail in the coffin of the open, optimistic internet we all dreamed of in 2012, and it makes me sad.
crimsoneer commented on The World Happiness Report is beset with methodological problems   yaschamounk.substack.com/... · Posted by u/thatoneengineer
rkagerer · a day ago
In case others are wondering what the one simple question is (called the Cantril Ladder):

“Please imagine a ladder with steps numbered from zero at the bottom to ten at the top. Suppose we say that the top of the ladder represents the best possible life for you and the bottom of the ladder represents the worst possible life for you. If the top step is 10 and the bottom step is 0, on which step of the ladder do you feel you personally stand at the present time?”

Personally feels a little more convoluted than just asking "How happy are you, on a scale of 0-10?"

crimsoneer · 13 hours ago
I'm assuming part of this is it's not always asked in English...?
crimsoneer commented on Pro-democracy HK tycoon Jimmy Lai convicted in national security trial   bbc.com/news/articles/cp8... · Posted by u/onemoresoop
nradov · 2 days ago
They didn't run out of money just because they fought two wars. For some bizarre reason the UK has simply chosen to be (relatively) poor instead of embracing a growth policy. Despite all their potential advantages their GDP per capita is about equal to the poorest US state.
crimsoneer · 2 days ago
It's worth pointing out this happened entirely post 2008. This is not some "decision" people took, or some long term loss of empire. The US recoevered from the 2008 crisis way better than everyone else, and nobody really understands why yet.
crimsoneer commented on Pebble Index 01 – External memory for your brain   repebble.com/blog/meet-pe... · Posted by u/freshrap6
utopcell · 8 days ago
I really don't see the benefit of this over, say, pixel buds.
crimsoneer · 7 days ago
I really wanted pixel buds to fit this use case, but have found the experience incredibly crap. "Hey Google, let's chat live" is like some mad lottery.
crimsoneer commented on Pebble Index 01 – External memory for your brain   repebble.com/blog/meet-pe... · Posted by u/freshrap6
maeln · 8 days ago
You can buy a rechargeable e-ring with several sensors and even a tiny screen for like 20$ on AliExpress. 75$ for a non-rechargeable, e-waste ring with just a button and a mic is insane.
crimsoneer · 8 days ago
but probably not a microphone, right.
crimsoneer commented on I wasted years of my life in crypto   twitter.com/kenchangh/sta... · Posted by u/Anon84
kaon_2 · 10 days ago
Is Atlas Shrugged really that bad? Heh, I started reading the fountainhead in my mid 30ies. The natural way you get introduced to new characters is great, but man I got so angry with the unrealistic robotic personalities I kept putting the book away and after 200 pages I really just could not continue. So Atlas Shrugged is similar? What a disappointment!

Anybody here that loved the books and would care to elaborate it speak to them so much?

crimsoneer · 10 days ago
As a teenager who went through quite a similar journey back in the day, it wasn't as much the books (which are quite badly written, I still have PTSD from that monologue) and more about the story very plainly supporting the view of the world I had back then... Champions of industry, unshackled by free enterprise, freed from the stagnation of governance etc.
crimsoneer commented on I wasted years of my life in crypto   twitter.com/kenchangh/sta... · Posted by u/Anon84
hvb2 · 10 days ago
> your bank account would just hold USDC or Bitcoin, and you could send a billion dollars to anyone in the world in a few seconds. That belief is powerful and I still ascribe to it.

These statements still surprise me to this day. If you're a good person engineer, why does sending money in seconds need blockchain? There's parts of the world where this is commonplace and free as well.

I don't believe cross border was there in 2010 or so but why not implement that feature in an existing system instead of building out a parallel universe

crimsoneer · 10 days ago
Because you don't trust or don't believe in the legitimacy of governments.
crimsoneer commented on Porn company fined £1M over inadequate age checks (UK)   bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c... · Posted by u/ndsipa_pomu
IlikeMadison · 13 days ago
Do you really believe Ofcom and the UK establishment in general really care about the children or terrorists when they are pushing for mandatory digital ID and age-verification in every aspect of our digital lives or are you playing naive?
crimsoneer · 13 days ago
Controversially, I think most people I know in politics really are actual humans, who got into politics to stop bad things happening, and think that children having ready access to pornography is A Bad Thing.
crimsoneer commented on Porn company fined £1M over inadequate age checks (UK)   bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c... · Posted by u/ndsipa_pomu
brainwad · 13 days ago
I think it actually is a radical totalitarian demand, if the only accepted form of age verification is government ID scans or selfie face capture. People should have a right to serve content without having to deal with the SPII of their clients.
crimsoneer · 13 days ago
... but they specifically don't have to, right? You can just use a third party verification company. Or you can not, if you'd prefer not to. You just have to do something vaguely meaningful that isn't just "Pinky swear you're 18".

u/crimsoneer

KarmaCake day629November 9, 2014View Original