Readit News logoReadit News
avsteele commented on Texas is suing all of the big TV makers for spying on what you watch   theverge.com/news/845400/... · Posted by u/tortilla
whacko_quacko · a day ago
Care to articulate them?
avsteele · a day ago
If you want a consequentialist answer:

If, for ethical reasons, fewer people were willing to take these jobs, then either salaries would have to rise or the work would be done less effectively.

If salaries rise, the business becomes more expensive and harder to scale. If effectiveness drops, the systems are less capable of extracting/using people’s data.

Either way, refusing these jobs imposes real friction on the surveillance model.

If you want a deontological answer:

You have a responsibility not to participate in unethical behavior, even if someone else would.

avsteele commented on Dollar-stores overcharge customers while promising low prices   theguardian.com/us-news/2... · Posted by u/bookofjoe
latexr · 12 days ago
I’m having a hard time parsing your comment.

> Article Context-free raw #'s

What does this mean?

> no comparisons to traditional grocery stores AFAIK.

So? The article is very specific from the beginning it was an investigation on two specific chains. That different stores may also do it does not invalidate the point.

> Dad journalism

Did you mean “bad journalism”, or is “dad journalism” a term with meaning (like “armchair psychologist”)? B and D aren’t that close on a typical QWERTY, but maybe it was a wrong autocorrect?

> You should not update on this article

Also here. I’m guessing “update” was meant to be a different word? I don’t understand what you mean.

> (…) a national report found that (…)

Which is useful information, but (again) does nothing for the article’s point. Because other stores do it, it doesn’t mean it’s not worth reporting that these ones do too. The article isn’t saying these are the only chains engaging the the practice. Furthermore, the point matters because the people who need to frequent dollar stores are the ones who are already cash strapped.

The article goes deeper than just presenting some numbers, it argues for why exactly this matters, why it happens, and why it isn’t being fixed.

avsteele · 12 days ago
> Article Context-free raw #'s

"Dollar General stores have failed more than 4,300 government price-accuracy inspections in 23 states since January 2022" Is this a lot or a little? There no context for national chain

> Dad journalism

"Bad" Typo, sorry

> You should not update on this article

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayesian_inference

> (…) a national report found that (…)

The article's thesis is that these stores are uniquely bad. Whether or not this is correct necessarily depends on a comparison with other stores.

avsteele commented on Dollar-stores overcharge customers while promising low prices   theguardian.com/us-news/2... · Posted by u/bookofjoe
avsteele · 12 days ago
Article Context-free raw #'s, no comparisons to traditional grocery stores AFAIK. Dad journalism.

You should not update on this article unless you have some outside knowledge of the industry.

I had AI look into it, it found a national report found that dollar stores had pricing errors at about twice (3.5%) the rate of traditional supermarkets (1.7%) but lower than convenience stores (4.9%).

https://cdn.ncwm.com/userfiles/files/Resources/Price%20Verif...

avsteele commented on It’s time to free JavaScript (2024)   javascript.tm/letter... · Posted by u/pavelai
avsteele · 16 days ago
Why is this worth doing? What wrong with the status quo? The author does not give any examples of Oracle threatening people for using the JavaScript (tm) name.
avsteele commented on Kmart's use of facial recognition to tackle refund fraud unlawful   oaic.gov.au/news/media-ce... · Posted by u/_p2zi
avsteele · 3 months ago
Interesting line to draw:

- you can record all manner of video in your store...

- but you can't process it in this particular way.

avsteele commented on Linux phones are more important now than ever   feddit.org/post/18353777... · Posted by u/wicket
avsteele · 3 months ago
The authors largest bullet point is on author identification. What are the arguments against this and do people really feel they outweigh the benefits?

My view: I would think given how many code supply chain attacks we've see recently this would be be regarded as (at worst) a necessary evil. How much software used by large numbers of people does the open source community think will be done by anons?

Sidenote: The author implies SyncThing development was stopped due to author ID but the post linked does not say this and gives a completely different reason (forced updates)

avsteele commented on Seven replies to the viral Apple reasoning paper and why they fall short   garymarcus.substack.com/p... · Posted by u/spwestwood
foldr · 6 months ago
This sort of omission would not be considered scientific malpractice even in a journal article, let alone a blog post. A rebuttal of a position that fails to address the strongest arguments for it is a bad rebuttal, but it’s not scientific malpractice to write a bad paper — let alone a bad blog post.

I don’t think I agree with you that GM isn’t addressing the points in the paper you link. But in any case, you’re not doing your argument any favors by throwing in wild accusations of malpractice.

avsteele · 6 months ago
Malpractice slightly hyperbolic.

But anybody relying on Gary's posts in order to be be informed on this subject is being being mislead. This isn't an isolated incident either.

People need to be made be aware when you read him it is mere punditry, not substantive engagement with the literature.

avsteele commented on Seven replies to the viral Apple reasoning paper and why they fall short   garymarcus.substack.com/p... · Posted by u/spwestwood
foldr · 6 months ago
It does rebut point (1) of the abstract. Perhaps not convincingly, in your view, but it does directly addresses this kind of response.
avsteele · 6 months ago
Papers make specific conclusions based on specific data. The paper I linked specifically rebuts the conclusions of the paper. Gary makes vague statements that could be interpreted as being related.

It is scientific malpractice to write a post supposedly rebutting responses to a paper and not directly address the most salient one.

avsteele commented on Seven replies to the viral Apple reasoning paper and why they fall short   garymarcus.substack.com/p... · Posted by u/spwestwood
avsteele · 6 months ago
This doesn't rebut anything from the best critique of the Apple paper.

https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.09250

avsteele commented on BYD's Five-Minute Charging Puts China in the Lead for EVs   spectrum.ieee.org/byd-meg... · Posted by u/pseudolus
amazingamazing · 6 months ago
still don't get the point of huge batteries. in USA average commute is about 20 miles one way. seems like a 75mile battery + gas is both more practical and requires less infra.

edit: it seems some are confused. I'm saying a PHEV is superior to BEV.

avsteele · 6 months ago
Many people drive places other (further) than work multiple times a year. "75 mile battery" wouldn't even be good enough for a one-way trip of this kind let alone there and back again.

u/avsteele

KarmaCake day1694October 5, 2017
About
adam@avsteele.com

adam@zerok.com

View Original