Readit News logoReadit News
aspenmayer commented on The F-35 is losing the trade war   jalopnik.com/1945910/f-35... · Posted by u/rntn
cm2187 · 5 hours ago
What the doctrine is and whether France would follow it in practice are two different things. But it shouldn't matter.

Nuclear weapons as an ultimate warning is the doctrine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air-sol_moyenne_port%C3%A9e

Whether it would be followed in practice is anyone's guess. But place yourself in the shoes of the invading country. You are basically facing the same question. Would France ultimately use nuclear weapons? You may think that they will likely not. But if they do, that's a path to having your cities and basically your civilisation wiped out. So at what percentage probability are you still happy to try your luck at invading France? Unless you are a Hitler or Stalin, who were happy to spend tens of millions of their own population without a second thought, there is no scenario where a rational leader will be taking that risk. And therefore deterence is achieved.

aspenmayer · 5 hours ago
I appreciate the nuanced response. France needs this capability to be publicly known for it to have the desired deterrent effect, and like most military expenditures, the intent to use it is somewhat independent from the capability to use it. I think France needed a new Maginot Line, and this is likely what that looks like in current year.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maginot_Line

aspenmayer commented on The F-35 is losing the trade war   jalopnik.com/1945910/f-35... · Posted by u/rntn
cm2187 · 6 hours ago
My understanding is that jetfighters with nuclear weapons are meant to deliver an ultimate warning by nuking the invading army. ICBM are what comes next (unless the enemy went ICBM first).

That being said this all assumed that Russia had a strong air-defence. The various strikes that Ukraine has been able to make on Russian territory seems to have challenged that idea. I don't know how confident Putin feels he could block such attack, so that adds to the dissuasion too. The thing with nukes is that it only takes one missile to go through.

aspenmayer · 6 hours ago
A nuclear first strike is the worst deterrent possible, though. It basically enables and ensures a nuclear retaliatory strike, which is how you rapidly reach midnight on the atomic clock, queueing up WW3.

I don’t think France would ever strike first with nukes, even against Russia invading France itself. Conventional munitions and bombs are justifiable, but I can’t see France nuking any EU country that is being invaded by Russia or anyone else, even as a last resort. There’s nothing to gain militarily by doing so, and it would only give their enemies justification to escalate.

I honestly don’t know much about French nuclear doctrine and policy, so I would be happy to be corrected or pointed in the right direction.

aspenmayer commented on The F-35 is losing the trade war   jalopnik.com/1945910/f-35... · Posted by u/rntn
actionfromafar · 12 hours ago
I think it's very simple. France hinted at placing its own nuclear bombers closer to the Russian border. That does not require that other European countries trust France. It's just France shifting its nuclear posture a bit more to the East.
aspenmayer · 7 hours ago
Does France have submarines with nuclear weapons? I’m not sure how much of a deterrent nuclear bombers are compared to ICBMs, but it’s better than not having them.
aspenmayer commented on Colombian Black Hawk Downed by Drone Is a Glimpse of What's to Come   twz.com/air/colombian-bla... · Posted by u/Michelangelo11
digitalPhonix · 11 hours ago
> subsonic-Mach 4

How is it subsonic and mach 4?

aspenmayer · 10 hours ago
I interpreted it as a range of missiles, with subsonic on the low speed end, and Mach 4 on the high speed end.
aspenmayer commented on YouTube steps up fight against ad blockers again   ghacks.net/2025/06/09/goo... · Posted by u/nsdfg
1over137 · 13 hours ago
But thats even less private. If you log in, they know exactly who you are.
aspenmayer · 11 hours ago
They likely have nearly as good an idea who you are based on what you watch from which IP address(es).
aspenmayer commented on Why you can’t grow cool-climate plants in hot climates   crimepaysbutbotanydoesnt.... · Posted by u/surprisetalk
lazide · 18 hours ago
Mind doing some math and showing your work?
aspenmayer · 15 hours ago
> > No, but you could do enough of it in secret with Elon Musk resources to prove that it's both planetarily viable and doesn't cause catastrophes by existing and then lend your political weight to having it scaled up globally. By the time the public heard about it, it would already be a done deal.

> Mind doing some math and showing your work?

I don’t see how anyone could spend tens or hundreds of billions of dollars in secret, so I’m not sure how important it is to show their work. I found the premise a bit absurd.

aspenmayer commented on AI tooling must be disclosed for contributions   github.com/ghostty-org/gh... · Posted by u/freetonik
popalchemist · a day ago
Yes, that is one of those works that is over-represented in the training data, as I explained in the part of the comment you clearly did not comprehend.
aspenmayer · a day ago
> you clearly did not comprehend

I comprehend it just fine, I was adding context for those who may not comprehend.

aspenmayer commented on AI tooling must be disclosed for contributions   github.com/ghostty-org/gh... · Posted by u/freetonik
martin-t · a day ago
It's not about being mandatory. It's about having a privileged position and using it to extract value from people.

The nature of network effects is such that once a site gets as big as reddit (or facebook or tiktok or whichever), it's nearly impossible for competition to take over in the same design space.

Many communities (both small and large) are only present on specific platforms (sometimes only one) and if you want to participate you have to accept their terms or exclude yourself socially.

aspenmayer · a day ago
If they have a privileged position, it is earned and freely given. No one is obligated to use the site. The issue is more one of the commons being enclosed and encircled by corporate interests, and then branded and commodified. Once the deed is done, there is no reason for folks to leave, because everyone they know is there.

Most communities on Reddit that I’d care to be a part of have additional places to gather, but I do take your point that there are few good alternatives to r/jailbreak, for example.

The host always sets its own rules. How else could anything actually get done? The coordination problem is hard enough as it is. It’s a wonder that social media exists at all.

Gatekeepers will always exist adjacent to the point of entry, otherwise every site turns extremist and becomes overrun with scammers and spammers.

aspenmayer commented on Show HN: OS X Mavericks Forever   mavericksforever.com/... · Posted by u/Wowfunhappy
brewmarche · 2 days ago
There is another one, you can hold Option while booting and it will show disks to boot from. But there is also a SSID dropdown to do internet recovery like Shift+Option+Command+R.
aspenmayer · 2 days ago
Yes, Option is boot menu iirc.

You can even boot to Linux or Windows if you have the patience to set it up. I made a hackintosh for hard drive data recovery that would dual boot Windows 10 and macOS. It’s a fun ecosystem.

aspenmayer commented on Show HN: OS X Mavericks Forever   mavericksforever.com/... · Posted by u/Wowfunhappy
brewmarche · 2 days ago
Big Sur Recovery mode works for me with Option+Cmd+R, so if needed I can install that. What I meant is that the other goes into Mavericks Recovery mode. And I’m happy about that actually :-)

Edit: if you were referring to Option+Cmd+R anyway, I guess I misread

Edit2: by other one I meant Shift+Option+Cmd+R, just Cmd+R actually goes into Big Sur, you are right!

aspenmayer · 2 days ago
Yeah, there are a few keyboard combinations that do different things.

https://support.apple.com/en-us/102655

> On an Intel-based Mac:

> If you used Command-R to start up from the local Recovery system, you get the current version of the most recently installed macOS.

> If you used Option-Command-R to start up from Internet Recovery, you might get the latest macOS that is compatible with your Mac.

> If you used Shift-Option-Command-R to start up from Internet Recovery, you might get the macOS that came with your Mac, or the closest version still available.

u/aspenmayer

KarmaCake day5920January 9, 2016
About
by reading this message, you acknowledge that bots and generated comments are against hn guidelines:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33950747

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20%22generated%20comments%22&sort=byDate&type=comment

a person on the internet

email is my HN username @ gmail . com

https://twitter.com/aspenmayer

https://mastodon.social/@aspenmayer

Signal: aspenmayer.01

(DMs welcome for any or no reason, save spam)

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/aspenmayer; my proof: https://keybase.io/aspenmayer/sigs/WRQjWMNEwmqZQWTIEOiPTIcFzsC7yb4zBJc0VjGlWts ]

> The newest computer can merely compound, at speed, the oldest problem in the relations between human beings, and in the end the communicator will be confronted with the old problem, of what to say and how to say it.

> Edward R. Murrow

> If you want the truth rather than merely something to say, you will have a good deal less to say.

> Thomas Nagel

> This WHOIS server is being retired. Please use our RDAP service instead. Rate limit exceeded. Try again after: 2562047h47m16.854775807s.

sorry, i don't work here lol

View Original