Readit News logoReadit News
appease7727 commented on Analysis of the GFW's Unconditional Port 443 Block on August 20, 2025   gfw.report/blog/gfw_uncon... · Posted by u/kotri
chickenzzzzu · 3 days ago
How do you propose users in China will magically get around a nation state injecting packets?
appease7727 · 3 days ago
That's literally what VPNs are for.

If you aren't aware: a Virtual Private Network creates a fully encrypted link between you and a remote node. So long as your encryption keys are secure, there's no way for anyone (even a global superpower) to listen to or intrude on that connection. There is no possible way to break into this connection, even with the entire planet's computing resources.

From the outside, all you can see is a stream of encrypted data between two nodes. You cannot tell where the traffic goes once it exits the VPN server or what it contains.

The only way to compromise a VPN connection is the most straightforward and pedestrian: compromise the VPN host and directly spy on their clients with their own hardware.

The GFW certainly can and has detected such encrypted streams and blocked them for being un-inspectable. With a VPN you can perfectly hide what you're doing and you can perfectly prevent intrusion. You cannot prevent someone noticing you're using a VPN. China can simply blanket ban connections that look like VPN traffic. But they cannot tell what you're doing with that VPN.

appease7727 commented on Vibe coding creates a bus factor of zero   mindflash.org/coding/ai/a... · Posted by u/AntwaneB
appease7727 · 3 days ago
LLMs aren't bad for programming in general.

LLMs are bad for bad programmers. LLMs will make a bad programmer worse and make a layperson think they're a prodigy.

Meanwhile, the truly skilled programmers are using LLMs to great success. You can get a huge amount of value and productivity from an LLM if and only if you have the skill to do it yourself in the first place.

LLMs are not a tool that magically makes anyone a good programmer. Expecting that to be the case is exactly why they don't work for you. You must already be a good programmer to use these tools effectively.

I have no idea what this will do to the rising generation of programmers and engineers. Frankly I'm terrified for them.

appease7727 commented on Vibe coding creates a bus factor of zero   mindflash.org/coding/ai/a... · Posted by u/AntwaneB
layer8 · 3 days ago
> If you're using llms to shit out large swathes of unreviewed code you're doing it wrong

> bam, x days work done in 2 minutes

This is a bit of a misrepresentation, since those two minutes don’t account for the reviewing time needed (nor prorperly, which vastly exceeds that time. Otherwise you end up in the situation of “doing it wrong” described in your first paragraph.

appease7727 · 3 days ago
Most of these cases don't require "review". It either works or it doesn't.

If you have an LLM transform a big pile of structs, you plug them into your program and it will either compile or it won't.

All programmers write countless one-off throwaway scripts. I can't tell you how many times I've written scripts to generate boring boilerplate code.

How many hours do you spend reviewing such tools and their output? I'll bet anything it's just about zero.

appease7727 commented on Pixel 10 Phones   blog.google/products/pixe... · Posted by u/gotmedium
mg · 3 days ago
The people at Google seem to think much more like me than the people at Apple.

There are 3 primary decisions Google made that click with me, while Apple's choices are a mystery to me:

1: When I put a Pixel on a table, it sits there stable. Because the backside is symmetrical. When I put an iPhone on a table, it wobbles.

2: When I sort my photos on a Pixel, I sort them in folders. The "camera" folder is where the unsorted photos are. When I sit in a bus or in a cafe, I go through it and sort the new photos into folders. This seems impossible on iPhones. Everything stays in the main folder forever. You can add photos to albums, but that does not remove them from the main folder. So there is no way to know which photos I have already sorted.

3: On Android I can use Chrome. Which means web apps can use the File System Access API. This makes web apps first class productivity applications I can use to work on my local files. Impossible on iPhones.

I'm sure people who prefer iPhones have their own set of "this clicks with me on iPhones and puzzles me on Pixels" aspects?

Is this a "left brain vs right brain" type of thing? Do most HNers prefer Androids?

appease7727 · 3 days ago
My pixel 8 does not stay where I put it. Without a case, it will slide right off of any slightly tilted surface.

It should be illegal to put glass on the back of a phone.

appease7727 commented on Apple and Amazon will miss AI like Intel missed mobile   gmays.com/the-biggest-bet... · Posted by u/gmays
appease7727 · 3 days ago
Maybe Apple and Amazon are the only cool heads in this absolute shitstorm.

The real, intrinsic value of AI is essentially zero compared to the hype and tech-biz cargo culting. If I were John Apple, I would simply sit back and wait while all your competition dump all their money into the AI bonfire. Once the dust settles all the hyped-up ai startups are dead, you can come in and pick up whatever worked best and have a stellar AI product with no real cost. Assuming such a product can exist, it still isn't clear.

I don't think companies not literally setting billions of dollars on fire is a bad thing.

appease7727 commented on The rising returns to R&D: Ideas are not getting harder to find   papers.ssrn.com/sol3/pape... · Posted by u/surprisetalk
moomoo11 · 4 days ago
I think the solution is to knock them down to a point that they are like India or Russia.

Just big countries but stuck.

I wouldn’t mind if we could make some plays to revamp Japan and some EU, and maybe grow India while boxing China and Russia together.

As long as those countries have governments that aren’t on our side or at least sympathetic to our vision, they should be kept in check hard. Like manufacturing stuff for us but not really being able to use any of it. Sounds harsh but that’s reality. Nothing personal lol

All they’ve done is steal anyway and extracting knowledge from us after we showed them how to make a factory (reductionist but idc), so it’s not like we would be “morally” wrong.

appease7727 · 4 days ago
So you think the USA should interfere in a sovereign nation to intentionally and drastically damage their economy, industry, and quality of life?

Because the US can't get their collective heads out of their asses to build a competitive industry?

The USA is losing this imagined fight with China, and the solution is not to destroy an entire nation, but to actually become competitive.

Sure, let's just fucking nuke every country that's more successful than us. That'll show them!

Americans are absolutely fucking insane.

appease7727 commented on In 2006, Hitachi developed a 0.15mm-sized RFID chip   hitachi.com/New/cnews/060... · Posted by u/julkali
ipdashc · 4 days ago
I have always wondered how this works (along with wire bonding), especially in an economic way.

Chips being cheap makes sense at the lithography / wafer level because sure, you can stamp out thousands of them at once. But once you need to dice them up, bond wires to them, and package them... how on earth do you do that so efficiently that each chip can be sold for fractions of a cent?

appease7727 · 4 days ago
Lots of automation. Dicing is automatic, bonding, testing are automatic. The manual work is mostly just transporting materials.

The bonding machines are crazy. Definitely look it up on YouTube, the machine puts down bond wires super fast.

The other part of it is sheer scale. Once you start making thousands or millions of something, economies of scale drive the costs way down

appease7727 commented on 95% of generative AI pilots at companies are failing – MIT report   fortune.com/2025/08/18/mi... · Posted by u/amirkabbara
amirkabbara · 5 days ago
Why so bad?
appease7727 · 5 days ago
Turns out that garbage text has very little intrinsic value
appease7727 commented on Electricity prices are climbing more than twice as fast as inflation   npr.org/2025/08/16/nx-s1-... · Posted by u/geox
appease7727 · 6 days ago
Other nations comparable in wealth and power to the US have figured out how to build out green energy at scale.

The US wants to pretend that is completely impossible and we should keep burning fossil fuels instead.

Please learn some critical reading skills.

appease7727 commented on Who does your assistant serve?   xeiaso.net/blog/2025/who-... · Posted by u/todsacerdoti
Aurornis · 6 days ago
> I feel like this should go without saying, but really, do not use an AI model as a replacement for therapy.

I know several people who rave about ChatGPT as a pseudo-therapist, but from the outside the results aren’t encouraging. They like the availability and openness they experience by taking to a non-human, but they also like the fact that they can get it to say what they want to hear. It’s less of a therapist and more of a personal validation machine.

You want to feel like the victim in every situation, have a virtual therapist tell you that everything is someone else’s fault, and validate choices you made? Spend a few hours with ChatGPT and you learn how to get it to respond the way you want. If you really don’t like the direction a conversation is going you delete it and start over, reshaping the inputs to steer it the way you want.

Any halfway decent therapist will spot these behaviors and at least not encourage them. LLM therapists seem to spot these behaviors and give the user what they want to hear.

Note that I’m not saying it’s all bad. They seem to help some people work through certain issues, rubber duck debugging style. The trap is seeing this success a few times and assuming it’s all good advice, without realizing it’s a mirror for your inputs.

appease7727 · 6 days ago
IF (and ONLY if) you are fully cognizant and aware of what you're doing and what you're talking to, an LLM can be a great help. I've been using a local model to help me work through some trauma that I've never felt comfortable telling a human therapist about.

But for the majortiy of people who haven't seriously studied psychology, I can very easily see this becoming extremely dangerous and harmful.

Really, that's LLMs in general. If you already know what you're doing and have enough experience to tell good output from bad, an LLM can be stupendously powerful and useful. But if you don't, you get output anywhere from useless to outright dangerous.

I have no idea what, if anything, can or should be done about this. I'm not sure if LLMs are really fit for public consumption. The dangers of the average person blindly trusting the hallucinatory oracle in their pocket are really too much to think about.

u/appease7727

KarmaCake day91August 1, 2025View Original