Readit News logoReadit News
akshatjiwan commented on Efficient method to capture carbon dioxide from the atmosphere   helsinki.fi/en/news/innov... · Posted by u/lrasinen
jmward01 · a month ago
I am not against doing research in this area, please do, it is interesting and likely has many applications but global CO2 removal isn't one of them. Nothing proposed, including this, is within any orders of magnitude of a viable solution. The only solution we have is put less in the air in the first place. This tech looks interesting for transporting CO2 but that doesn't mean it sequesters it and even if sequestration was solved the scales here are massive. If we don't have the political will to reduce the amount going into the air then what makes anyone think we would have the political will to build out some system to capture and sequester? We need to focus more on not putting CO2 into the air and less on trying to take it out.
akshatjiwan · a month ago
I think you have a point. It could be difficult to justify the cost of carbon capture based on sequestration alone. One of the reasons I think this might still work is that captured carbon can be used to create platform chemicals (various hydrocarbons) using the fischer tropsch process. Electrofuels are using direct air capture to generate fossil replacements.

Only requirement is energy and there too it isn't all that expensive to pull air in from the atmosphere or to seperate CO2 from adsorbent via low grade heat (70-100c)

So far into the future this method could allow us to continue produce critical hydrocarbon materials (used everywhere from plastics to pharamaceuticals) without having to depend upon concentrated and contested oil supplies.

More than energy efficiency its volumetric efficiency that's the issue. At the moment (to the best of my knowledge) kg of capturing materials capture tens of grams of CO2. Pulling it from air is not that energy intensive but finding materials that can actually filter out CO2 from that air is difficult. If breakthroughs are made in this area it will have industrial applications. Then it won't be just sequestering.

Of course the easier solution is to plant more trees and grasses but they grow very slowly and require valuable land. Still this approach is feasible in some uncultivable lands. Crops like cottongrass[1] can grow even in tundra climate and can be valuable source of both technically imp carbon via cellulose and a means to capture CO2. We don't have to make a choice. We can do both simultaneously.

[1] https://www.fs.usda.gov/database/feis/plants/graminoid/eriva...

akshatjiwan commented on John Malone and the Invention of Liquid-Based Engines   permalink.lanl.gov/object... · Posted by u/akshatjiwan
moffkalast · a month ago
It is apparently a form of Stirling engine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malone_engine
akshatjiwan · a month ago
I find it a bit funny. Robert Stirling invented the Stirling engine because steam engines were dangerous (at that time) and could explode.

Malone(and others apparently) took Stirling engines and filled it with compressed water as a working fluid with some decent efficiency!

The advantage, based on what I could gather from limited info available, was that these liquid engines could be run at lower temp differential making them great for low grade heat recovery.

u/akshatjiwan

KarmaCake day173December 27, 2024
About
I'm Akshat. I'm the founder of bhū an independent non profit organisation dedicated to advancement of science and promotion of international relations.

I'm responsible for organisational strategy with focus on innovation,partnerships & transformation. I'm a self learner, self starter and have a background in theoretical research. I'm always open for collaboration.

With bhū, we aim to promote international harmony through creation of specific councils and bodies for regulating and overseeing international issues, while accelerating developments in nanotechnology, material science ,electrostatics, fluids, plasma science,thermodynamics and advanced manufacturing.

Let us work together.

Keywords : Innovation/ Materials science/International relations/Telecommunications/Digital Transformation/Partnerships

Mobile/whatsapp:+919654119771

email:getellobed@gmail.com

https://akshatjiwannotes.blogspot.com/p/bhu.html

https://orcid.org/0009-0003-1595-2215

View Original