Readit News logoReadit News
WesleyLivesay commented on I have been writing a niche history blog for 15 years   resobscura.substack.com/p... · Posted by u/benbreen
matthiaswh · 9 days ago
Oh you're that Wesley. Big fan of your podcasts!
WesleyLivesay · 9 days ago
Thanks for listening! Yes, I am "that" one.
WesleyLivesay commented on I have been writing a niche history blog for 15 years   resobscura.substack.com/p... · Posted by u/benbreen
libraryofbabel · 9 days ago
Ex-historian here, now an engineer. Ben is one of the few historians really thinking in depth about the implications of LLMs for historical research and teaching: both the good (wow, they are really great at transcribing difficult handwritten documents now; you can use Claude Code to vibe code up quick visualizations for your research or teaching that would have taken weeks of work before), and the bad (students submitting AI-generated essays). Highly recommended reading.

It's also nice to see a working historian who posts to HN. (If there are any others, please raise your hand!) Our community is richer for the wide variety of non-engineering professions represented here, from medical doctors to truckers to woodworkers to pilots to farmers. Please keep posting, all of you.

WesleyLivesay · 9 days ago
I wouldn't call myself a historian, but I have been doing a history podcast since 2014.

I agree that Ben's writings on LLMs and how they impact the humanities/history are great reads. But I am also the perfect target market for that kind of discussion, dev by day amateur historian by night.

WesleyLivesay commented on Trying out Gemini 3 Pro with audio transcription and a new pelican benchmark   simonwillison.net/2025/No... · Posted by u/nabla9
simonw · a month ago
The audio transcript exercise here is particularly interesting from a journalism perspective.

Summarizing a 3.5 hour council meeting is something of a holy grail of AI-assisted reporting. There are a LOT of meetings like that, and newspapers (especially smaller ones) can no longer afford to have a human reporter sit through them all.

I tried this prompt (against audio from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qgJ7x7R6gy0):

  Output a Markdown transcript of this meeting. Include speaker
  names and timestamps. Start with an outline of the key
  meeting sections, each with a title and summary and timestamp
  and list of participating names. Note in bold if anyone
  raised their voices, interrupted each other or had
  disagreements. Then follow with the full transcript.
Here's the result: https://gist.github.com/simonw/0b7bc23adb6698f376aebfd700943...

I'm not sure quite how to grade it here, especially since I haven't sat through the whole 3.5 hour meeting video myself.

It appears to have captured the gist of the meeting very well, but the fact that the transcript isn't close to an exact match to what was said - and the timestamps are incorrect - means it's very hard to trust the output. Could it have hallucinated things that didn't happen? Those can at least be spotted by digging into the video (or the YouTube transcript) to check that they occurred... but what about if there was a key point that Gemini 3 omitted entirely?

WesleyLivesay · a month ago
I think it appears to have done a good job of summarizing the points that it summarize, at least judging from my quick watch of a few sections and from the YT Transcript (which seems quite accurate).

Almost makes me wonder if it is behind the scenes doing something similar to: rough transcript -> Summaries -> transcript with timecodes (runs out of context) -> throws timestamps that it has on summaries.

I would be very curious to see if it does better on something like an hour long chunk of audio, to see if it is just some sort of context issue. Or if this same audio was fed to it in say 45 minute chunks to see if the timestamps fix themselves.

WesleyLivesay commented on How I am deeply integrating Emacs   joshblais.com/blog/how-i-... · Posted by u/signa11
YuukiRey · a month ago
> I have seen what people are capable of doing when their tools get out of the way, and they are free to just create. This is how world class athletes, musicians, artists, writers, and of course programmers take what is in their mind and translate it into reality.

I think this is a fallacy. If you approach the question of how these people achieve the things they do with a bias towards tooling then you'll come to the conclusion that it plays a big role in their success.

In reality, many of these folks start with a very strong drive to achieve something and then the rest sort of follows. If you want to be a world class musician, start practicing an instrument. Ideally fall in love with music. The rigorous and meticulous practice routine comes later.

In other words: you can have the world's best tooling that gets out of the way, but you're still as unmotivated to do anything as before.

I think it's a cool idea and it sounds like a fun and creative endeavor. I don't want to talk it down. But I also wouldn't want folks to get the, in my opinion, misguided impression that "tooling -> success" is the correct order.

WesleyLivesay · a month ago
Seems particularly funny in an article about Emacs, a piece of software that lets you get in situations where some portion of your "just create" time becomes "managing my custom emacs, please don't break".
WesleyLivesay commented on LLMs solving problems OCR+NLP couldn't   cloudsquid.substack.com/p... · Posted by u/universesquid
behnamoh · 4 months ago
This is a nothing burger blog post that likely made it to the front page because it mentions "LLM" in the title. Worse yet, it's an ad actually.
WesleyLivesay · 4 months ago
You beat me to this comment, but you are absolutely correct.
WesleyLivesay commented on AI is different   antirez.com/news/155... · Posted by u/grep_it
jordanpg · 4 months ago
Of course, your opinion may be subject to selection bias (i.e., you are only judging the art that you became aware was AI generated).
WesleyLivesay · 4 months ago
Reminds me of the issue with bad CGI in movies. The only CGI you notice is the bad CGI, the good stuff just works. Same for AI generated art, you see the bad stuff but do not realize when you see a good one.
WesleyLivesay commented on The Rising Cost of Child and Pet Day Care   marginalrevolution.com/ma... · Posted by u/surprisetalk
monkeyelite · 4 months ago
It’s expensive because people are willing to pay a lot for it.

Complaints about child care costs never end in “so I stopped paying them”.

WesleyLivesay · 4 months ago
No, but it might cause some people to say "so I am not having kids"
WesleyLivesay commented on Win, lose, or draw: trends in English football match results   blog.engora.com/2025/06/e... · Posted by u/Vermin2000
h46u5jytyhtg · 5 months ago
I completely disagree with the premise of the article that draws are most boring and the wider the score difference the more interesting the game is.

Frequently draws are very exciting, they can make compelling viewing. In a game that is completely dominated by one team, there can be very little of interest.

An alternative metric would be the degree of uncertainty/jeopardy in the game. So a game that ends 1-1 has a high degree of jeopardy because at any moment a team can score and take point from the other team.

WesleyLivesay · 5 months ago
Agreed, classifying all draws as boring is just wrong.

There are boring draws, some are excruciating to watch because so little is happening.

There are also draws that are the most stressful, exciting, and action packed games you will ever see.

WesleyLivesay commented on Show HN: FFmpeg in plain English – LLM-assisted FFmpeg in the browser   vidmix.app/ffmpeg-in-plai... · Posted by u/bjano
toddmorey · 5 months ago
The Warp terminal[1] is excellent for this type of thing. In agent mode, you just describe what you want to have happen and it generates the proper command(s) (that you can approve before running).

I use it a lot to convert videos and turn a folder of tiff files into pngs at 1/2 size, etc. It's great at generating FFMEG commands and chaining the right tools together.

[1] https://www.warp.dev

WesleyLivesay · 5 months ago
I was going to mention Warp here as well. It is fantastic when it comes to almost anything in the terminal. It has caused me to use the terminal a lot more on all of my computers because I don't have to spend a bunch of time poking around on Google to find the command to run.

I have used it for ffmpeg and then a lot of other slightly more complex commands. A recent one from the other day was gathering up all of the .epub documents in a directory tree, renaming them to the name of the directory they were in, and then placing them all in one single directory. That would have been a whole project for me, and Warp gave me the command with just that description. Any LLM interface would have done the same, but Warp just let me hit "Enter" and run it, no need to copy and paste.

WesleyLivesay commented on What I learned gathering nootropic ratings (2022)   troof.blog/posts/nootropi... · Posted by u/julianh65
mentos · 5 months ago
I’ve been experimenting with making my last meal of the day as far from my sleep as possible ideally waking up at 5am, drinking water / vitamins, exercising by lifting my dumb bells in my studio apartment, eating a 1k calorie breakfast and 1k calorie lunch and done with eating by ~1-2 so I have 4-6 hours to digest before bed

Best sleep I’ve ever gotten.

You don’t know what you’re missing out on until you’ve experienced not good but GREAT sleep.

if that’s too extreme avoid too much water before bed if you’re getting up to pee you are ruining your sleep

WesleyLivesay · 5 months ago
On the flip side, I get absolutely garbage sleep if I don't eat within about 1-2 hours of going to sleep.

u/WesleyLivesay

KarmaCake day545January 6, 2017View Original