Readit News logoReadit News
NobleLie commented on Benn Jordan's AI poison pill and the weird world of adversarial noise   cdm.link/benn-jordan-ai-p... · Posted by u/glitcher
dwighttk · 8 months ago
So leave him out of the training set… the impact will be minimal
NobleLie · 8 months ago
Excellent comment (seriously)
NobleLie commented on Bored of It   paulrobertlloyd.com/2025/... · Posted by u/NotInOurNames
nsagent · 9 months ago
I'll bite.

I received my PhD in Computer Science focused on NLP and creative text generation last year and I think the hype around LLMs is ridiculous (academics are no better than industry on chasing hype). They're trained to predict the next token given a context, and that's exactly what they're good at.

How old do you think I am?

NobleLie · 9 months ago
Thanks. Sometimes I feel like I'm going insane attempting to ŕeason with people who think the opposite. That these are oracles imbued with human level intellect and creativity.

Now, sure, these models can be impressive - but it's a warped lens of humanities own impressive (selected) corpuses.

NobleLie commented on Magpies and crows are using “anti-bird spikes” to make nests (2023)   audubon.org/magazine/appa... · Posted by u/perihelions
porphyra · 9 months ago
Interesting but I have a hard time imagining how a nest made of anti-bird spikes could be comfortable. Do they actually find it to be nice? I guess corvids are super smart and wouldn't accidentally get tricked into making an uncomfortable nest due to man made materials...
NobleLie · 9 months ago
My take is its less so about being physically comfortable, but there is a different type of comfort by the protection of the nest from predators. It's like being uncomfortable to have peace of bird mind, in other words.
NobleLie commented on 60% of Americans say they probably won't get an updated Covid-19 vaccine   pewresearch.org/short-rea... · Posted by u/hn_acker
toomuchtodo · a year ago
~17M people in the US alone suffer from long covid.

https://www.kff.org/coronavirus-covid-19/issue-brief/as-reco...

NobleLie · a year ago
How many from long flu to fairly compare?
NobleLie commented on How dermatology became the 'it' job in medicine   wsj.com/lifestyle/careers... · Posted by u/bookofjoe
NameError · a year ago
When my primary care doc referred me to a dermatologist for a suspicious mole, I could not find an actual dermatologist who would see me in less than ~8 months. I ended up seeing a physician's assistant, which I'm still uneasy about since there's been a study that shows that PA's seem to have a lower success rate vs. doctors [1], and the educational requirements are very different for PAs.

As a layperson, it seems like we (patients / society) would benefit from having more doctors, i.e. opening up more residency slots and admitting more people to med school, but there's probably a lot I don't understand about the issue. Not sure if it's a lack of political willpower to do this, or if there are other reasons why the number of doctors we train is so restricted.

[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29710082/ ("PAs performed more skin biopsies per case of skin cancer diagnosed and diagnosed fewer melanomas in situ, suggesting that the diagnostic accuracy of PAs may be lower than that of dermatologists")

NobleLie · a year ago
It started with the flexner report (1910). I urge you to look into it if you are interested in this topic and let me know your thoughts

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flexner_Report

NobleLie commented on Trump wins presidency for second time   thehill.com/homenews/camp... · Posted by u/koolba
nightski · a year ago
Trump didn't print $4T, the bi-partisan effort in Congress for COVID relief did.

I think the problem in voters eyes is that Biden did not stop after this. He pushed through multiple trillion dollar bills on top of it.

I'm not saying I agree with that stance, but calling the $4T Trump's doing is a really misleading. It was not part of his economic agenda at all.

NobleLie · a year ago
Yep. It was probably the singular reason (of a few) he lost 2020.
NobleLie commented on Trump wins presidency for second time   thehill.com/homenews/camp... · Posted by u/koolba
deepfriedchokes · a year ago
I would argue it’s not just the economy, but capitalism in general is no longer serving the public well, and hasn’t for a long time. It is corrupting our public institutions, it is creating poverty and suffering, and it abuses power to exploit people. Capitalism is abusive, and very often the things that we aren’t supposed to talk about are what we need to talk about the most.
NobleLie · a year ago
Schumpeter called it the eroding foundation of Capitalism. Its not technically Capitalism, as the system, at fault though. It's interesting. Feel free to explore it more. Or perhaps you already do
NobleLie commented on Prompts are Programs   blog.sigplan.org/2024/10/... · Posted by u/rbanffy
ithkuil · a year ago
Code Is data that expresses instructions to some processing unit for it to do tasks.

Prompts fit that description very well so I don't find that provocative or controversial at all.

The fact that traditionally the execution unit was very rigid and that the language used to express instructions was distant from human natural language is more of a consequence of an implementation rather than a fundamental distinction between code and data

NobleLie · a year ago
> expresses instructions

To instruct is akin to providing an input. Where do we input to? The program. The program is programmed; but most importantly, the input is not programmed in the sense the program is programmed. It is, perhaps, thoughfully designed (or not). This role is best described as Prompt Designing or Prompt Engineering, not Prompt "Programming". In any case, it is indeed very important. But in my respectful opinion, it is not programming.

It's kind of like thinking that entering a query into a search engine is programming - a host of techniques can be utilized to optimize how that input effects the output (tomes can be written on this just as they can for LLM prompt design by now).

I can kind of defend that premise but it breaks the meaning of conventional usages, and creates more confusion than it brings clarity.

NobleLie commented on Prompts are Programs   blog.sigplan.org/2024/10/... · Posted by u/rbanffy
NobleLie · a year ago
No...prompts are definitely not programs, prompts are inputs to programs. How someone can write a blog post on such a demonstrably fallacious premise is beyond me.

I am beginning to write a blog post in rebuttal, because it's so fascinating.

NobleLie commented on Legalizing sports gambling was a mistake   theatlantic.com/ideas/arc... · Posted by u/jimbob45
serial_dev · a year ago
While everything you wrote I agree with, I’m not sure I arrived to the same conclusion. Alcohol, cigarettes, workaholics, social media apps all ruin the lives of the weak and those around them. Should we make them all illegal?
NobleLie · a year ago
Some people believe that their beliefs and way of life should be enforced. Here, which human habits or activities are allowed or "OK" even if partially or very deletorious.

The desired force vector varies in magntitude and orientation, but can, in the extreme include removal of independence / imprisonment or less extreme banning and fining etc

Because a single or group of people believe it, it must be for everyone, equally.

u/NobleLie

KarmaCake day46January 24, 2015View Original