Readit News logoReadit News
Isamu commented on The Timmy Trap   jenson.org/timmy/... · Posted by u/metadat
Isamu · 9 days ago
You can compare the current state of LLMs to the days of chess machines when they first approached grandmaster level play. The machine approach was very brute force, and there was a lot of work done to improve the sheer amount of look ahead that was required to complete at the grandmaster level.

As opposed to what grandmasters actually did, which was less look ahead and more pattern matching to strengthen the position.

Now LLMs successfully leverage pattern matching, but interestingly it is still a kind of brute force pattern matching, requiring the statistical absorption of all available texts, far more than a human absorbs in a lifetime.

This enables the LLM to interpolate an answer from the structure of the absorbed texts with reasonable statistical relevance. This is still not quite “what humans do” as it still requires brute force statistical analysis of vast amounts of text to achieve pretty good results. For example training on all available Python sources in github and elsewhere (curated to avoid bad examples) yields pretty good results, not how a human would do it, but statistically likely to be pertinent and correct.

Isamu commented on AI-induced dehumanization (2024)   myscp.onlinelibrary.wiley... · Posted by u/walterbell
cratermoon · 9 days ago
I'm unwilling to accept the discussion and conclusions of the paper because of the framing of how LLMs work.

> socio-emotional capabilities of autonomous agents

The paper fails to note that these 'capabilities' are illusory. They are a product of how the behaviors of LLMs "hack" our brains and exploit the hundreds of thousands of years of evolution of our equipment as a social species. https://jenson.org/timmy/

Isamu · 9 days ago
No, I think the thesis is that people perceive falsely that agents are highly human, and as a result assimilate downward toward the agent’s bias and conclusions.

That is the dehumanization process they are describing.

Isamu commented on Why are there so many rationalist cults?   asteriskmag.com/issues/11... · Posted by u/glenstein
Isamu · 12 days ago
So I like Steven Pinker’s book Rationality, to me it seems quite straightforward.

But I have never been able to get into the Rationalist stuff, to me it’s all very meandering and peripheral and focused on… I don’t know what.

Is it just me?

Isamu commented on How Apple could send democracy to the spam folder   washingtonpost.com/opinio... · Posted by u/CharlesW
Isamu · 17 days ago
OMG, pollsters may be treated like spammers. Truly the greatest threat to democracy today.
Isamu commented on AI Ethics is being narrowed on purpose, like privacy was   nimishg.substack.com/p/ai... · Posted by u/i_dont_know_
qualeed · 17 days ago
This is a pretty good example of what parent comment was referencing, I think.

You say "Asimov’s three laws are not a good framework.", then don't present any arguments to why it is not a good framework. Instead you bring up something separate: the framework can facilitate story writing.

It could be good for story writing and a good framework. Those two aren't mutually exclusive things. (I'm not arguing that it is a good framework or not, I haven't thought about it enough)

Isamu · 17 days ago
Right, in particular Asimov is not presenting a detailed framework of any kind.

His laws are constraints, they don’t talk about how to proceed. It’s assumed that robots will work toward goals given them, but what are the constraints?

People now who want to talk about alignment seem to want to avoid talk of constraints.

Because people themselves are not aligned. To push alignment is avoiding the issue that alignment is vague and the only close alignment we can be assured of is alignment with the goals of the company.

Isamu commented on AI Ethics is being narrowed on purpose, like privacy was   nimishg.substack.com/p/ai... · Posted by u/i_dont_know_
Isamu · 18 days ago
This has been happening for a long time. I first noticed this with the hand waving dismissals of older concepts like Asimov’s laws.

Not a carefully reasoned argument why “not causing harm to a human” is outmoded, but just pushing it aside. I would love to see a good reasoned argument there.

No, instead there is Avoiding talking about harm to humans. Just because harm is broad doesn’t get you out of having to talk about it and deal with risks, which is at the root of engineering.

Isamu commented on Providing ChatGPT to the U.S. federal workforce   openai.com/index/providin... · Posted by u/gmays
morninglight · 18 days ago
Will the IRS promote ChatGPT for preparing individual tax returns?
Isamu · 18 days ago
That smells like a help for filling free returns, so no, we don’t seem to want that.

But based on my experience with AI-generated code reviews, the IRS could definitely generate all kinds of “problems” for you to address in your return. Maybe even boost revenue by insisting on bogus extra unpaid taxes. What could you do to respond? File a ticket against the bug? Meanwhile you are menaced with fines.

Isamu commented on UR5 with Robotiq 85 Gripper: Object Grasping and Placement Simulation   github.com/leesweqq/ur5_g... · Posted by u/kyleliiii
spwa4 · 19 days ago
Love it. How complicated can you make the objects to be picked up?
Isamu · 18 days ago
Looks like just cubes for this simulator, I think the focus is on the two-finger gripper integrated with this arm kinematic. Planning a gripper strategy for a complex object would be a another layer but definitely could be incorporated.
Isamu commented on UR5 with Robotiq 85 Gripper: Object Grasping and Placement Simulation   github.com/leesweqq/ur5_g... · Posted by u/kyleliiii
kyleliiii · 22 days ago
This project simulates a UR5 robotic arm with a Robotiq 85 gripper, performing autonomous object grasping and placement tasks in the PyBullet environment. Using inverse kinematics (IK) for precise arm control and synchronized joint control for realistic gripper motion, the robot grasps cubes from random positions and places them on a tray.
Isamu · 18 days ago
Thanks for sharing this here, it’s always good to see some robot projects here.
Isamu commented on Providing ChatGPT to the U.S. federal workforce   openai.com/index/providin... · Posted by u/gmays
Isamu · 18 days ago
Don’t they mean to say “replacing the entire U.S. federal workforce with ChatGPT”? Surely that is the future everyone is looking to.

u/Isamu

KarmaCake day5761January 22, 2010
About
prosolar mechanic
View Original