Readit News logoReadit News
Hamcha commented on Overengineering my homelab so I don't pay cloud providers   ergaster.org/posts/2025/0... · Posted by u/JNRowe
8fingerlouie · 25 days ago
While i get the whole homelab thing is exiting and a great learning experience, it's simply not worth the time and effort for the majority of people.

You will end up paying much more for your services, along with spending a ton of time maintaining it (and if you don't, you will probably find yourself on the end of a 0-day hack sometime).

In Northern/Western Europe, where power costs around €0.3/kWh on average, just the power consumption of a simple 4 bay NAS will cost you almost as much as buying Google Drive / OneDrive / iCloud / Dropbox / Jottacloud / Whatever.

A simple Synology 4 bay NAS like a DS923+ with 4 x 4TB Seagate Ironwolf drives will use between 150 kWh and 300 kWh per year (100% idle vs 100% active, so somewhere in between), which will cost you between €45 and €90 per year, and that's power alone. Factoring in the cost of the hardware will probably double that (over a 5 year period).

It's cheaper (and easier) to use public cloud, and then use something like Cryptomator (https://cryptomator.org/) to encrypt data before uploading it. That way you get the best of both worlds, privacy without any of the sysadm tasks.

Edit: I'll just add, as you grow older, you come to realize that time is a finite resource, and while money may seem like it is finite, you can always make more money.

Don't spend your time hunched over servers. Spend it doing things you love with people that matter to you. Eventually those people won't be there anymore, and the memories you make with those people will matter far more to you in 20 years, than the €20/month you paid for cloud services.

Hamcha · 24 days ago
Have you seen the prices for Google Drive et al? The NAS setup you describe (which I wouldn't consider worth the money for that little space) is what, 12GB with 1 parity drive?

Google One for 10TB is 274,99€/mo (at least in my country) so you'd make the entire nas price and subscription cost within a few months, let alone years.

There just aren't compelling public cloud for large sizes (My NAS is 30TB capacity and I'm using 18 right now) and even if you go the more complex loops with like S3 and whatnot you still get billed more than it's worth. Public cloud is meant for public files, there's a lot of costs you're paying for stuff you don't need like being fast to access from everywhere.

Hamcha commented on LibreLingo – FOSS Alternative to Duolingo   librelingo.app... · Posted by u/hyperific
mobtrain · 4 months ago
This comment would be 60 times more helpful if in addition to your strong opinion on the failures of learning with Duolingo it’d supply some of the good alternatives.
Hamcha · 4 months ago
As someone learning Japanese I'm really appreciating tools built for JP specifically: Renshuu and Wanikani. Both use SRS (same as duolingo) but spend a considerable amount of time actually teaching the grammar and nuances, they both avoid starting from everyday phrases like "I would like sushi" to instead build a foundation first, and many other little things that make it a much nicer experience than Duolingo who's trying to use a very generic approach that maximises small term satisfaction in exchange for painful long term learning.
Hamcha commented on Why we picked AGPL   blog.paradedb.com/pages/a... · Posted by u/philippemnoel
Hamcha · a year ago
Correction: they chose AGPL with a poison pill (CLA) so they can benefit from it and take it away whenever they want more.
Hamcha commented on Windows 10 will start nagging you to switch from local account to MS Account   neowin.net/news/windows-1... · Posted by u/croes
ryandrake · a year ago
Same thing with Windows Mail. I just got a message telling me, "We've decided to move you to Outlook (which I don't want) instead of the Windows Mail client that you're happily using." Now I've got to go searching for the magical wizard spell I need to cast in order to stop it from doing this.

I really wish a Windows Product Manager could comment here and explain why the hell they keep doing this shit despite the user not wanting any of it. I know they won't. They're ashamed of what they are doing, and/or hide behind some "do not post online" corporate policy.

Why can't operating systems just stay out of the user's way? Go schedule the CPU, manage the filesystem and network peripherals, and stop with the user behavior modification experiments.

Hamcha · a year ago
As someone who has been on the email client hunt ever since Google Inbox was taken off my feet I can say that I'm a very happy customer of eM client and it's actually one of the few apps that make it painful to leave Windows (since the devs have no intention of porting it to Linux).

It's pay once and it comes with a free version if you just wanna give it shot, the only bad thing for me was how annoying the website was with dark patterns trying to push sales, the software itself is great.

Hamcha commented on W4 Games raises $15M to drive video game development with Godot Engine   w4games.com/2023/12/07/w4... · Posted by u/j_maffe
Vespasian · 2 years ago
1. Congratulations to them. Godot is some great piece of open source software and everything that strengthens it is beneficial to the market segment as a whole.

2. Given the list and impact of 3rd party contributors and the absence of a CLA I think there is little ability for them to change the licensee in the future to something proprietary (nor is there any indication that the current key people at W4/Godot would want to do something like this)

3. That said, how do the venture capital companies hope that W4 makes them back their investment and a healthy profit on top. To be crystal clear, there is nothing wrong with that but I would like have it out in the open before. "Console support" seems a little bit thin although I'm ready to admit that I may not know enough about the industry.

If anyone could provide some additional information I'd be very thankful.

Edit: personally I prefer the open stewardship model like Blender or the Linux foundation where it is clear that Major financial contributors expect to get software for their own businesses out of it and support an open project in order to share costs and have a say in the direction it takes.

Hamcha · 2 years ago
Console support and porting effort in general is the main biz of some companies, the most popular being M2 (mostly emulators) and MP2 Games (handles Clickteam Fusion ports to console like Freedom Planet, Baba is You), but there are many other smaller studios. They mostly seem to have their own proprietary tech. That kinda work also can't be open source as official console SDKs are expensive and covered by NDAs.

If the next Undertale/Minecraft gets built in Godot, W4 Games would be the easiest way to get that game to consoles and rack in tons of royalties, so I think the investment is justified (though hoping it doesn't poison Godot in some way)

Hamcha commented on StyleTTS2 – open-source Eleven-Labs-quality Text To Speech   github.com/yl4579/StyleTT... · Posted by u/sandslides
mlsu · 2 years ago
We're now at "free, local, AI friend that you can have conversations with on consumer hardware" territory.

- synthesize an avatar using stablediffusion

- synthesize conversation with llama

- synthesize the voice with this text thing

soon

- VR

- Video

wild times!

Hamcha · 2 years ago
Yup, and you can already mix and match both local and cloud AIs with stuff like SillyTavern/RealmPlay if you wanna try what the experience is like, people have been using it to roleplay for a while.
Hamcha commented on Google plans to disable legacy V2 browser extensions next June   theregister.com/2023/11/1... · Posted by u/beardyw
gnicholas · 2 years ago
> Users impacted by the rollout will see Manifest V2 extensions automatically disabled in their browser and will no longer be able to install Manifest V2 extensions from the Chrome Web Store.

Does this mean there are no plans to remove the ability to sideload V2 extensions?

Hamcha · 2 years ago
Maybe not yet? Google already made having non-store extensions as annoying as possible (e.g. a nag every time you open Chrome that tells you to disable them) and maybe they think that's working well enough to dissuade people.
Hamcha commented on Ask HN: Why is OpenAI firing Sam Altman such a big deal?    · Posted by u/soneca
ants_everywhere · 2 years ago
> 3. It occurred during market hours and blindsided their investors and partners.

(Possibly dumb) question: OpenAI isn't publicly traded right? Do market hours really matter for this sort of thing for private companies?

Hamcha · 2 years ago
It probably scared the downstream, see Microsoft pushing out a press release as soon as possible since they have been investing tons of money and PR into their OpenAPI partnership and needed to calm their investors and partners.
Hamcha commented on The Lack of Compensation in Open Source Software Is Unsustainable   trstringer.com/oss-compen... · Posted by u/pjmlp
kawhah · 2 years ago
What is the evidence for this feeling of entitlement?

I use tons of free software. I've never either demanded that anyone work on it for free, nor have I expressed any sense of entitlement or expectation.

Hamcha · 2 years ago
Just look around forums and socials like Reddit. I see people bitching how OBS Studio doesn't work for them the exact way they want it while contributing nothing to the project almost daily.

This happens less where the FOSS choice is a drop in a sea of established proprietary packages (FreeCAD, KiCad, Godot) but way way more when they have already established themselves as the popular pick (OBS Studio, Blender) so they get flooded by less tech-savy, more casual users that don't really see the value of open source other than they don't pay for it.

"Normal" people have always had stuff given to them for "free" (either "you are the product" or built-in licenses like Windows) so they don't realize the goodwill and sacrifices that FOSS goes through.

Hamcha commented on Munich court tells Netflix to stop using H.265 video coding to stream UHD   nexttv.com/news/achtung-b... · Posted by u/clouddrover
clouddrover · 2 years ago
> It is "patent free" only because Google claimed it was

You're confusing two separate issues: patents and the licensing of those patents.

AV1 is not "patent free" at all. There are plenty of patents that pertain to AV1 owned by the Alliance for Open Media. AOMedia gives you a patent license to use AV1 royalty-free:

https://aomedia.org/license/patent-license/

https://aomedia.org/press%20releases/the-alliance-for-open-m...

What's happening separately is that patent licensing organizations are forming their own patent pools in an attempt to seek rent from existing and future AV1 users. Their claim is that they have patents essential to AV1 and you must pay them a licensing fee.

Sisvel is trying it on: https://www.sisvel.com/licensing-programmes/audio-and-video-...

And so is Avanci: https://www.avanci.com/video/

They characterize this is as providing AV1 implementers the "opportunity" to minimize the risk of being sued:

https://www.streamingmedia.com/Articles/ReadArticle.aspx?Art...

These grubby patent pool organizations are the practical reason why it's better to stick with royalty-free formats and protocols on the internet.

And why more work must to go into making sure internet audio and video formats are and remain royalty-free.

Hamcha · 2 years ago
At least from face value it seems the value of those patents is exactly to fight back patent pools organizations, at part of the AOM stipulation is that if someone tries to sue over AV1 patents they would lose access to every patent holder portfolio (for AOM that would mean Google, Apple, Amazon and many others tech giants). Though it seems that still won't stop everyone.

u/Hamcha

KarmaCake day1245January 25, 2015
About
I ramble about stuff at faulty.equipment and knowledge.fromouter.space
View Original