Cahier (https://getcahier.com), the software I'm developing, supports creating cards with references to passages in the PDFs read.
It's exciting to see the developments that are being made in this area in the past few years.
(I guess my only concern is around potentially reinventing the wheel when it comes to some of these areas. E.g. do you plan to integrate every feature from Zotero, like the web-integrated grabber? That sounds like a prodigious amount of work, but without it it’s hard to fully supplant Zotero as a reference management solution. I’m curious as to your roadmap for this and what you see as the ultimate feature set and user workflow.)
But these synergise—we all know that scene and P2P film releases percolate from private sites to public ones, for instance. Torrents may die in the public sphere before being reseeded from an obscure, yet shielded and resilient, private archive (I have done this). The economies of private sites encourage the contribution of new content, which after a requisite delay is disseminated outwards to the public sphere. Light is the left hand of darkness, darkness the right hand of light. (The same model applies among private sites too as content is cross-uploaded, building resilience in the shadow archive. When one private or public site shuts down, that content doesn’t all have to disappear.)
I would actually argue that where public materials are less available, it’s less because of the private sites (which will always exist) being private and more because there are no public sites for that media type to be mirrored to. Think Libgen, which absorbs almost all contributions to private book sites eventually. Music enjoyers aren’t so lucky usually, which I think is because of the language gap between the major public music site that you mentioned and private music sites which are predominantly English-language.
I imagine fonts are like a plot full of weeds, there’s all sorts of information they give off to people who know, but most people don’t have eyes for what they are looking at.
But I'm a bit hazy about how derivative works are actually defined.
What is the Obsidian Academic Stack?
I’ve been working on a stack which allows a workflow from Zotero > Obsidian > Pandoc > Word (with proper citations).
The idea being that essays and thesis can be written using Obsidan and then exported to word to be compatabile with the needs of other academics.
One key insight was that Pandoc supports Citation Style Language (CSL) so you need a workflow that supports CSL end-to-end if you want that a valid bibliography and in-text citations to pop out the end.
Here’s my overall workflow:
All your academic papers are saved into Zotero along with references to books, websites etc.
Zotero is synced to Obsidian, which lets you write papers and notes in Obsidian and add references to sources from Zotero.
So now you want to convert one of your Obsidian notes into an "academic paper". The tool you need for this is pandoc. The pandoc tool understands many academic referencing styles such as APA7 and Harvard. Specifically you install the pandoc plugin for Obsidian and configure that.
Once the pandoc plugin is setup; On the note you want to convert to an 'academic paper' you can run the pandoc command and it will generate a Word Document that automatically includes correct inline referencing and an auto-generated references section with all the references listed, at the end of the document.
I’ve been documenting it all here. Please star and raise an issue if you need any help setting this up.
https://github.com/evolve2k/obsidian-pandoc-academic-word-do...
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40313143